That said, the W3C validator does reveal several issues with the HN code. Sure, they aren't do-or-die issues, but they do have an effect. The validator reports that alt text is missing for several issues, that many attributes are missing quotemarks and that the DOCTYPE is missing. These issues harm accessibility and robustness.
In fact, MSN seems to be the only site in the Alexa top 20 that does validate. (But Live.com and Microsoft.com don't validate, so Microsoft isn't consistent about validating)
Justifying something "because someone else does it like that" is akin to childhood playground antics. "But miss, I only kicked him because he kicked me first!"
As my mum always says: two wrongs don't make a right.
I wasn't saying it was justified because google does it too, I was saying it doesn't dictate quality. Many think google has a lot of quality (which is probably most important), and the same for HN.
Making silly analogies to justify standards compliance is just plain dumb if you want to play the name game.
Google doesn't validate: http://validator.w3.org/check?uri=http%3A%2F%2Fgoogle.com...
Standards don't always dictate quality.