> I doubt they'll pull this particular one
As I understand the process, applications on Kickstarter go through a screening period that can take weeks. You're right that this "project" is on the borderline of the site's intended use, but I think if they didn't judge it appropriate we'd never have even known it existed.
"Takes weeks" seems high. As a data point, my May Kickstarter submission was approved after 27 hours.
But your point is true--Kickstarter almost certainly approved this project before it launched.
I think of this as a Kickstarter to pay for a year's worth of comics. These guys keep a schedule of three comics a week, and they're offering to do that in a novel way. They also have some stretch goals as well of things they'll do instead of dealing with advertisers.
Re:Penny Arcade Sells Out
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:27PM
(#4229908)
It doesn't seem all that novel to me. They're just changing the source of their revenue from ads to Kickstarter.
You could argue that this lets them be freer with their art and writing, since they won't have to worry about offending their advertisers, but has that ever been an issue for them in the past? (The closest thing I can think of would be the Strawberry Shortcake comic, but that wasn't an ad-related issue.)
If you need costs to justify it, they need to pay the salaries of their employees and all the other costs involved in running a business. Only real difference I can see between this and, say, the Double Fine Adventure, is that Penny Arcade is a pre-existing product and the Double Fine Adventure isn't.
That's precisely the distinction that Kickstarter claims to be making, though: they'll fund new projects, but not ongoing business expenses.
They said they won't fund life expenses. That's a bit different. Though it is a somewhat fuzzy distinction to be making.
So KS wouldn't applicable to Dwarf Fortress?
Re:Penny Arcade Sells Out
by AlexDanger on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:33AM
(#4227886)
Perhaps not if it was worded support DF development for a year but perhaps if it was reworded pay for the development of a tightly integrated graphical interface for DF[1] then it sounds like a distinct project with clear objectives. Perhaps the developer was planning to do this work anyway but pitched as a project I believe its well within KS territory.
[1] example only
There's a way you can squint and call this a specific project, a time-limited "remove ads from PA for a year" experiment. But it sure looks like it's getting close to that raise-general-funds line that Kickstarter claims to not want to cross. In particular, the "costs" of the project that are being funded are entirely notional opportunity costs (foregone revenue), not actual expenses, whereas KS claims to be oriented towards raising funds for actual expenses that are needed to complete projects.
I doubt they'll pull this particular one, even if they determine it does violate their ToS, because PA is too high-profile (and, perhaps, because PA has fans known for being somewhat vindictive). But it seems like they'll have to either do something to prevent more of these kinds of Kickstarters going forward, or else just drop that language in the ToS and agree that anyone can use KS to raise a year of operating funds for their business.