Re:Charset="WTF-8"
by account42 on Tuesday November 26, 2024 @09:32AM
(#42246091)
1) The "real" WTF-8 charset [0] is a cool and useful encoding.
2) This may be an unpopular opinion but I think restricting name input to latin is an OK thing to do, especially if the entered names are being viewed/used by humans who cannot be expected to be know all scripts.
3) Similarly, internationalized domain names were a mistake. If your business card tells me to go to stępień.com then chances are I won't bother to try end remember how to enter those accents on my keyboard layout. Most users won't even be able to enter them. Worse are letters that are visually indistinguishible - and no, registries preventing confusable names is not enough when I still won't know which letter to enter. This makes IDN domains less useful while retaining all the security issues they bring.
Most languages were already forced to deal with ASCII and have developed standardized ways to "romanize" names and other words to that character set. This solution achieves peak interopability - not only between computer systems but also between the fleshy components operating them.
2) This may be an unpopular opinion but I think restricting name input to latin is an OK thing to do, especially if the entered names are being viewed/used by humans who cannot be expected to be know all scripts.
3) Similarly, internationalized domain names were a mistake. If your business card tells me to go to stępień.com then chances are I won't bother to try end remember how to enter those accents on my keyboard layout. Most users won't even be able to enter them. Worse are letters that are visually indistinguishible - and no, registries preventing confusable names is not enough when I still won't know which letter to enter. This makes IDN domains less useful while retaining all the security issues they bring.
Most languages were already forced to deal with ASCII and have developed standardized ways to "romanize" names and other words to that character set. This solution achieves peak interopability - not only between computer systems but also between the fleshy components operating them.
[0] https://simonsapin.github.io/wtf-8/