News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rocketr, Don’t Tell A Story. Answer Questions. by irahul on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @07:13AM (#4223071)
I guess all kind of publicity is good publicity, but I would count as early adapters and after reading 2 blog posts(this one and the one posted by them) and exploring their site, I have no idea what they do.

I still don't see how "collaborative note taking"(whatever it means) is different, or more importantly, better than a wiki.

The marketing copy is making some wide claims and I am unable to follow.

> how we capture information (using personal tools),

That's as open ended as it gets. Notebook, bookmarks, wikis, emails, cms, reminders, calendar, todo...

> how we get work done (using team-based tools).

Team based tools: Git, Issue tracker, IRC, some wiki, basecamp style messaging

Non team based tools: Vim, some programming language, some framework, some libraries, browser to look up things, ebooks...

Now, I can see where the worlds collide(todos and issue trackers, emails and basecamp messaging), but I don't see where does the collaborative note taking come into action. If I need a discussion, I will use a threaded message board. If I am accumulating input, I will use a wiki.

Bottomline: If after much deliberation(much longer than 10 minutes), Rocketr's purpose is lost on me, I am not surprised it were lost on YC in a 10 minute assessment.

Re:Rocketr, Don’t Tell A Story. Answer Questions. by adrianhoward on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @08:28AM (#4223359)
A resounding "me too". I'm only about 75% sure I understand the pain points they're trying to address - and I have no freaking clue what the product actually does.

(and if I'm right about my understanding of the pain points then it's really bad - since I suffer from 'em and would like a solution :-)

Re:Rocketr, Don’t Tell A Story. Answer Questions. by danso on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @08:22AM (#4223331)
How is there not an easily accessible demo, even a screencast, of a project two years in the making?
Re:Rocketr, Don’t Tell A Story. Answer Questions. by drupeek on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @09:53AM (#4223739)
There are several that exist from our first version of the app (example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LuCXE2aOQSY).

We've re-built the product recently and as such, don't have demos of the new application yet.