drupeek

A team and I built something like this (www.pilot.me). It's written in Ruby and we're looking to hand it off to new owners. Unfortunately, there is a government stakeholder who put some money into it and they'll probably need a small amount of money to release it completely. andrew dot peek at gmail if you'd like to know more.

I wish I could upvote this post a dozen times.

Access to information would also mean that employees lobbying for an increase, would have to justify their performance against their peers. That's a lot more personal and objective than simply stating, "I think I'm doing great."

Essentially what I'm saying is that I'm not sure I agree that open salary information would result in all salaries moving upward.

I have to say that this comment thread is far beyond what we expected when publishing our post.

Our original intention was to start a discussion around honing your pitch, telling your story - and to demonstrate how costly it can be when you don't do that well. By no means do we feel that we are "there" yet, but at the time of the post, we felt there was some progress from when we had interviewed.

Interestingly, this thread has now provided us with a tremendous amount of additional value (for much less of a cost) which we intend on putting to use in the coming weeks.

Thanks to all those who took the time to read the post, sit with it for a moment, and then carefully and compassionately construct their feedback in an honest and direct way.

We genuinely appreciate it.

I think you might be right.

There is only a minute of deliberation between interviews which isn't enough time to pull out the next application and refresh on it before the next interview is scheduled to begin.

This is a very good point and probably one that I undervalued going in.

In my preparation between the accepted application and the interview, I was cautioned that the interviewers will not remember your application when you walk in the room.

Is there truth to this?

This speaks to the problem we're trying to solve. Siasto is in the space. Wunderkit too. In a lot of ways, Posterous (YC company) tried pivoting into this space from a truly social angle as well.

You're right. My mistake.

Let me look into that.

I have no idea what compels you to "hate" so easily. There must be a great deal of things in your hate list.

There are several that exist from our first version of the app (example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LuCXE2aOQSY).

We've re-built the product recently and as such, don't have demos of the new application yet.

I am still searching for the additional insight I am supposed to gleam from your blog post, relative to the comment thread attached to the original.

Despite my best efforts, all I see is a deliberate attempt to be malicious for the purpose of increasing your HN cred.

You've asked 7 rhetorical questions. Assuming your post (and this is a generous assumption) was to ask these questions in earnest, here is my best attempt at answering them:

1. What are you solving?

>> We are trying to create a "better than email" environment for ideas and insights, shared within teams. Email is great at task management, but orders content by recency, which means that important thoughts (that aren't time-sensitive) get lost in archives.

2. What are the tools that are currently being used?

>> Email. Google Docs. And sometimes teams use the writeboard within their project management application.

3. Why are they so horrible?

>> I've explained email above. Google Docs doesn't give you attribution and ownership over your ideas. It's also very poor at allowing you to organize your docs. Finally, it's also incredibly hard to add to a doc quickly from a mobile device.

4. Do people wake agonize over these treacherous solutions, ripping their hair out and wishing there was something better?

>> This doesn't need an answer. You're mostly just interested in hearing yourself speak here.

5. So who actually needs what you’re building?

>> Creative teams (web design/dev shops, agencies, startups), Freelancers (part of many teams), Students & Educators (project groups and classrooms), Networked organizations (like YC who manage a portfolio of companies).

6. Have you talked to potential customers?

>> We're approaching 300 user interviews.

7. Have you reached out and gathered honest opinions?

>> Again. No answer required here.

The interesting thing about this experience (aside from the tremendously helpful feedback provided by some HN users), is that there seems to be this widely held assumption that branding and positioning a product are the "easy" parts.

People look at the fact that we've been at this for a year and a bit, and judge our progress, yet there is an endless amount of literature that's been created about how to do it well. If it was such a simple task, would you expect there to be such a large body of work around it?

We actually have two of the best in Toronto. :)

Will do. Appreciate the interest.

If that is the thing you'd like to collaborate around, then yes, you could use it for that purpose. ;)

We had someone plan a wedding with it during the pilot.

I'm going to print out the thread and cut it into workable chunks of feedback in order to organize and understand it.