I’m a white male but actually had a similar thing happen to me during school. (I brought a water gun to school and people expressed that even bringing a toy gun to school could get you into trouble and to hide it for the rest of the day). So I don’t know how much race was truly a factor.
In my opinion you are being closed-minded to other possibilities.
Maybe I'm a little bit closed to other possibilities (the same way a lot of people trying to advocate that this wasn't actually racist incident). Occam's razor plays a factor for me too.
> I’m a white male but actually had a similar thing happen to me during school
But lets compare your experience as a white kid. you did not get you English teacher calling the police on you after taking your stuff. You did not get arrested by the police who not only question you but took you to a detention center and did not make Mug shot for you. You did not got into much troubles because of maybe you were lucky. You did not got to leave the country because a lot of conservative shows and figures spreading conspiracy theories and attacking you.
You can say that you believe that this 14 years old kid was trying to to get reaction but this is a claim that you can support because you don't have a way to get back in 2015 neither do you have a way of reading people's mind. I believe this is even irrelevant. After police was called and things clarified ,the redirection to detention facility and the suspension of school (after everything cleared) and the conspiracy theories are what makes this racist incident. If the school just called cops and they dealt with it differently, there is a good chance that we weren't going to hear about that.
So comparing your experience and white male (non-Muslim I guess and sorry if this was not true) against a black Muslim kid yielded two different outcomes.
It wasn't until during English class, when he took it out, plugged it in, and set the alarm, that's something happened.
I have to wonder if the GP would have a similar experience if he kept waving the water gone around after being told to keep it in his bag.
And even though, I don't think suspension and police overreaction and taking a kid to be questioned without his parents present is justified. This is my problem and this is what makes this no just an ordinary incident that just happens everywhere. There was a racial profiling involved.
> Mohamed said he brought the clock to school because he "wanted to impress all of his teachers".[12] His engineering teacher, upon seeing the clock said, "That's really nice", but advised him to keep the device in his backpack for the rest of the school day.[14] Mohamed, however, later plugged it in during his English class and set a time on the clock.[12] When the clock alarm started beeping, the English teacher requested to see it, and said, "Well, it looks like a bomb. Don't show it to anyone else."[11]
Here's an older revision so you can't claim it wasn't there earlier:
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ahmed_Mohamed_clo...
HN users tend to think they are more logical and thus, somehow more immune to racism, while failing to understand that's simply not how racist attitudes develop.
People are even bending the facts to try to blame it on a 14 years old. I wonder if even if he tried a prank or something (which is a claim that wants to be proved) then does it require that kid to be detained and escorted into detention facility? I mean if it was misunderstanding, wouldn't this get solved quickly. They could have just checked that it is not a bomb, apologies and then life goes. Even after the case waa found that it is clear misunderstanding, He got suspended from school.
I wonder also if people did actually read the contents of the Wikipedia article because their claims are not even in alignment with that. The attacks and conspiracy theories that this kid and his family received is very sad. He even had to leave the US. There ia one claim that this is just a setup by his politician father and the suitcase was filed quickly suggesting malicious intent. They failed to mention that his father was a political rival to the dictator and war criminal wanted be the ICC Omar Elbashir and that he moved to the US in the 80s and lived significant portion of hia live there.
I think people on HN can be better than to spread conspiracy theories and avoid racism.