Google makes about 16-22 billion dollars a quarter in profit but they still do layoffs and they still make decisions that harm consumers but help their own short term growth. Search is a basic utility that is essential to the function of the internet. It's like water and electricity. There are huge structural barriers to being able to compete in that market, so if we care at all about basic economic theory, Google probably ought to at least be operated as a non-profit, and realistically be subject to massive anti-trust enforcement considering they are the modern robber barons on top of our communication networks.
Those opaque tweaks that tank your business are the same ones that keep spam and SEO garbage down.
It seems to me that the important market is online ads (which is where other companies focus), and that Google is the only company willing to invest in web search.
Also ad networks
[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20221118045948/https://duckduckg...
Um, except that they don't? We had entire articles detailing how "Forbes" dominates search rankings with SEO garbage.
Keeping SEO garbage down appears to be very straightforward. It's just incompatible with an ad-driven business model.
Yeah, Google is a monopoly.
Tesla obviously does not have a monopoly on cars or even electric vehicles.
You can believe whatever you like but it's simple economics that big tech companies have monopoly power over their markets. Denying that is pretty baffling but this is Hackernews so I'm not sure what I expected.
There is a ton of vendors who are competing on price. Although to be fair once you pick a vendor you are locked in their ecosystem. There is definitely friction in the market.
> Maybe Google didn't cooperate enough on something classified?
Yeah, sure. Google protects us.
And doesn't HN look down on ad hominem? Anyhow, I don't work for Google if that's what you're implying. Just use their services, like the majority of normal people.
"Whereas with Google you can just use a product, have it work with any device, any OS, across devices and you're never forced into anything else."
"really sucks because Google is the only big tech company that I haven't had negative interactions with."
but the cherry on top is this gem: "Maybe Google didn't cooperate enough on something classified?"MS and Apple both make hardware and control your OS. It is a fundamentally more in-your-face relationship with many more points of contact for an average consumer. That doesn't mean Google has been any less ruthless in pursuit of their almighty quarterly gains.
If we were to try draw equivalence: they'd ask Google to stop paying to be the default search provider on platforms and to offer a choice of search provider on Android. That would be the same as what they required of MS (simply to not bundle Internet Explorer and to open up APIs). What the EU is currently asking of Apple is maybe equivalent.
What the DOJ is currently seeking from Google is way over the top given the MS precedent.
On June 7, 2000, the District Court ordered a breakup of Microsoft as its remedy. According to that judgment, Microsoft would have to be split into two separate units, one to produce the operating system and one to produce other software components. Microsoft immediately appealed the judgment to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. [1]
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_C....
I also assume part of this sudden and intense recommendation is in part due to the upcoming change in power. While the case has been going on for a while, this admittedly feels like an ill-timed overreaction.
The DOJ also seems to be going way beyond their mandate in saying Google monopolizes search and ads. If the Microsoft precedent is anything to go by, just require Android users to choose a browser and search engine, allow other ad companies to bid on showing ads on search results or something, that seems fair.
But forcing them to sell Chrome, open proprietary algorithms to competitors and divest from business parnerships is way over the top and really, really feels like the government is doing a favour to Microsoft and Apple. Maybe Google didn't cooperate enough on something classified?