News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by zelon88 on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:50AM (#42204271)
> Afterward, NASA even calculated how much it would have cost the agency to develop comparable capabilities using its traditional contracting methods. The result? Four to 10 times as much.

The result is that instead of the US taxpayer OWNING the exclusive rights to the most advanced knowledge and technology in the world, we now LICENSE it from oligarchs who bought it with our money to hold over our heads forever.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by ethagknight on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:02AM (#42204379)
You wanna make the same argument about Microsoft or Apple or Boeing or healthcare administration? Far more government resources goes towards those.

Bold to assume that the US government could’ve accomplished what SpaceX has accomplished in the same timeframe in this day of Federal contracting. Bear in mind that no other country, no other competitor comes close to SpaceX’s throughput at this time.

They should be commended, not seen as a threat to the US

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by PrismCrystal on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:05AM (#42204403)
> They should be commended, not seen as a threat to the US

¿Por qué no los dos? Recognizing that a private endeavour is a commendable achievement, but then nationalizing it so that it conforms to the nation’s interest (whether the direct interest of the populace, or more oblique national-security interests) has played out again and again throughout history.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by ethagknight on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:12AM (#42204470)
Nurturing a competitive private industry will yield far greater dividends
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rapsey on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:18AM (#42204525)
Examples please.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by PrismCrystal on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:26AM (#42204596)
As probably the most historically impactful example, consider the nationalization of the East India Company, where Britain had long relied on a highly favoured private entity, but eventually it felt that its interests would be better served by bringing that entity under direct control.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rapsey on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:38AM (#42204712)
And this is somehow applicable to spacex and the us gov in 2024.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by piva00 on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:26AM (#42204600)
> They should be commended, not seen as a threat to the US

They can be both, commended for the technical prowess and achievements while also being a threat if they gain leverage over the US government. That's the fine balance to walk on, SpaceX could only exist because of American taxpayers footing the bill for their launches when they still had to prove they could do it and no other entity more risk-averse would pay for their launches, the government got a product out of it (cheaper launches) but it doesn't mean there's any loyalty involved.

The moment corporations start to have leverage over strategic assets of a nation it starts to shape into a bad time for everyone.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by zelon88 on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:23AM (#42204562)
When NASA performs experiments and learns something, that knowledge belongs to the American people.

When SpaceX learns something, that knowledge belongs to SpaceX, and specifically a trashboat named Elon Musk.

I'd rather spend 10x more and have the American people benefit. And your assertion of SpaceX's supremacy makes you look like a corporate simp.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by Dalewyn on Thursday November 21, 2024 @10:14AM (#42205060)
This comment exemplifies that this whole narrative stems from political disagreements with Musk rather than anything to do with SpaceX's technological and commercial merits.

As an aside, Musk was once upon a time aligned with the Left/Progressives/Democrats. He even fell out with Trump before during his first term, not that anyone probably remembers. Understand that Musk was on your side and got pushed away, like a lot of ex-Democrats turned Republicans.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 21, 2024 @11:31AM (#42205964)
Musk has always been right-wing. He didn't start Tesla because he was an environmentalist, he started it because he believed in the nonsensical Peak Oil theory.

He certainly has become more right wing over time.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by CyberDildonics on Thursday November 21, 2024 @05:35PM (#42209395)
Musk wasn't "pushed away", russia wasn't 'provoked' into invading a sovereign country and people, especially powerful ones are responsible for their own actions. No one made them do terrible things, especially not some vague amorphous label.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by Dalewyn on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:32PM (#42210381)
>Musk wasn't "pushed away",

Consider that most of the country shifted Right/Republican this election, which is another way of saying ex-Democrats turned Republicans.

Kind of ironically, the Democrats also became the party of neocons and war hawks by inviting the likes of Bush and Cheney.

The Democrats keep moving further Left, leaving normal people behind. You can only play the "world is out of touch" Simpsons meme so much before even that becomes too stupid to bother.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by bdangubic on Thursday November 21, 2024 @11:22PM (#42211170)
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by Dalewyn on Friday November 22, 2024 @12:01AM (#42211333)
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/11/06/us/politics/p...

>Of the counties with nearly complete results, more than 89 percent shifted in favor of former President Donald J. Trump in the 2024 presidential election,

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by bdangubic on Friday November 22, 2024 @05:45AM (#42212711)
ahhhh the "electoral college" argument... :)
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by aguaviva on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:37PM (#42210405)
Consider that most of the country shifted Right/Republican this election

Actually it was more like about a 4 percent shift.

Think about it.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by CyberDildonics on Thursday November 21, 2024 @11:03PM (#42211076)
Kind of ironically, the Democrats also became the party of neocons and war hawks by inviting the likes of Bush and Cheney.

You know this didn't happen right? There was no war and they didn't switch parties, they just said trump was so dangerously corrupt that people should vote against him.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by Dalewyn on Thursday November 21, 2024 @11:58PM (#42211323)
>You know this didn't happen right?

You mean the likes of GWB, Liz Cheney, et al. all going on the record endorsing the Democrats were all fake news?

Hyperbole aside, no, it is fact that the chief targets of criticisms lodged against the Republicans during the 00s made their new home in the Democrat Party this election and probably onwards. Getting told by corrupt warmongerers that the opponent is a corrupt warmongering Nazi is ironic, for all their faults I thought the Democrats swore off such people.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by CyberDildonics on Friday November 22, 2024 @12:46AM (#42211466)
So now it's not the Democrats also became the party of neocons and war hawks, it's GWB, Liz Cheney, et al. all going on the record endorsing the Democrats.

No one controls what they say.

Hyperbole aside

What you said wasn't hyperbole, it just wasn't true at all.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by krapp on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:50PM (#42210468)
That's only ironic if you actually buy into the propaganda that the Democratic Party is actually leftist, much less extreme leftist/neo-Marxist or whatever the Republican hyperbole du jour is.

Everyone else, including American leftists forced to ally with the Democrats because they're the only game in town, is well aware that the Democrats been moving steadily to the right since Carter.

It didn't help that the only reason anyone voted for Biden to begin with was that he wasn't Trump. Biden's only mandate was to be less evil than the other side and he couldn't even manage the simple, basic task of being against genocide. And then Harris doubled down on it.

Which is really why they lost - not because they're too radically leftist for "normal people" (the implication that no leftists are normal is seen and noted) but because they aren't nearly leftist enough, and so Democrats decided to stay home in droves, or cast futile votes for third party.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by aguaviva on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:11PM (#42210545)
If toxic windbags like Musk are turned off by the Left/Progressives/Democrats -- that actually speaks quite favorably of the latter.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rapsey on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:54AM (#42204309)
> we now LICENSE it from oligarchs who bought it with our money to hold over our heads forever.

Oligarchs who went all in and risked their entire net worth to make it work you mean.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by tossandthrow on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:10AM (#42204452)
This comment tastes bad: It says that an oligarchy is OK as long as the oligarchs "risked their entire net worth".

Would you say this also applies to other systems? Like dictatorships, etc?

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by class3shock on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:06AM (#42204417)
No, they meant what they said, a huge amount of the funding for these ventures comes from the taxpayer.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rapsey on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:21AM (#42204548)
And they got what they payed for. A great result for all involved.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rad_gruchalski on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:02AM (#42204376)
Take spacex as an example: spacex received $20bn in funding from federal government. That's 10% of the pre-Trump-election net worth of the oligarch owner.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by ANewFormation on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:29AM (#42204623)
SpaceX received very little in 'funding' from the government. However they sold extensive services to the government, primarily by offering the best value on competitive contracts.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rad_gruchalski on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:37AM (#42204691)
Yes, I'm sorry, funding is not the right term. They received $20bn in federal contracts. And they do fantastic work. My point is, the government is certainly aware that spacex does a great job and delivers. It's not a competition between NASA and spacex.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by ethagknight on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:03AM (#42204392)
And SpaceX has done exactly what they were asked to do with that money. Great value for the taxpayer.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rad_gruchalski on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:07AM (#42204419)
Indeed. Because they whole deal of them getting that money was to do the job for NASA the way NASA cannot due to public scrutiny.
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by ethagknight on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:09AM (#42204444)
That’s a fictional accusation
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rad_gruchalski on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:25AM (#42204590)
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by kingkawn on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:58AM (#42204345)
oligarchs who knew that with their monopolies they could always extract more cash from their market-capture on demand
Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by ANewFormation on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:25AM (#42204586)
One thing that's important to recognize is that this all isn't just a game where you spend some amount of money on R&D, and inevitably unlock the next tech.

In a parallel timeline where NASA gets 100billion a year, but there is no SpaceX, it's entirely possible that the pre-SpaceX status quo just continued on indefinitely. After all when SpaceX was first developing their tech, they were being actively mocked by Boeing/Lockheed (via Tory Bruno) with comments akin to 'yeah cute idea, we worked it out decades ago - not economically feasible. have fun learning.'

The SLS was going to be NASA's next big vessel, and costs there are trending to what could be around 4 billion a launch. With costs like that you're never going to do beat things in space.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 21, 2024 @09:34AM (#42204666)
The actual designs are much less important than the assurance that the general approach works and the expertise of the personnel. The actual designs are worth little in comparison. We had the design and license to build the fabulous Russian RD-180 engines, but chose not to because it would have been too hard. We have the designs for the Saturn V, and wouldn't be able to build it even if we wanted to.

OTOH, China is basically copying the SpaceX designs, even without the designs.

One great thing about Elon Musk is that he's so horrible to work for that lots of people join SpaceX straight out of school, get that expertise and then leave for better bosses or start their own company.

c.f. the "traightorous 8" that left Shockley to start Fairchild. Shockley almost singlehandedly created Silicon Valley by being a horrible boss.

Re:As NASA increasingly relies on commercial space, there ar... by rich_sasha on Thursday November 21, 2024 @04:15PM (#42208738)
Which would be fine if they paid taxes...