News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by esarbe on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:14AM (#42182601)
It is easy; nations that attack other nations unprovoked are "evil" (at fault).

Ukraine has never infringed on Russia's sovereignty or territorial integrity before it was attacked. Therefor this war is entirely Russia's fault.

The world is mostly shades of gray. But this case it black and white.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:45AM (#42182825)
Are you aware of why NATO was founded? Are you aware that NATO expansion into Ukraine seemed very likely at the time of Russia's invasion?

I am neither Russian nor European, so I don't have any horse in this race. But Russia's concerns sure seen valid from the outside.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by db48x on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:12AM (#42183033)
The whole idea that NATO is a threat to Russia is ridiculous. Read Article 1 again. <https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/official_texts_17120.ht...>
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:36AM (#42183876)
Do you know whether a Tomahawk missile is nuclear-tipped, or not?

No, you don't.

And neither do the Russians.

So, are you going to be so superficial when Cuba gets Kalibr's deployed?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:57AM (#42185568)
What Tomahawks, where? If this is supposed to be some kind of clever hint about weapons in countries that have joined NATO since the end of the Cold War, then unfortunately none of them have Tomahawks, or anything close to them, or anything at all beyond the domestic conventional forces, so this entire comparision bears no resemblance to reality.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Thursday November 21, 2024 @04:24AM (#42202512)
NATO has deployed Tomahawks in the past and threatened to put them in Ukraine in the not so distant past. Tomahawks were used during the NATO bombing of Yugoslavia.

Tomahawks are designed to carry nuclear weapons.

I find your ignorance of this fact deplorable. Please inform yourself.

Would you find the deployment of Kalibr (the Tomahawk analog on the other side) to your borders, within 7 minutes flight time of your capitol city, to be an acceptable state of affairs - especially if the deploying party had recently torn up any involvement in the treaties designed to reduce their proliferation?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Thursday November 21, 2024 @07:14AM (#42203550)
> NATO has deployed Tomahawks in the past and threatened to put them in Ukraine in the not so distant past.

Not true.

> Would you find the deployment of Kalibr (the Tomahawk analog on the other side) to your borders, within 7 minutes flight time of your capitol city, to be an acceptable state of affairs - especially if the deploying party had recently torn up any involvement in the treaties designed to reduce their proliferation?

That is already a reality with Russian missiles in the middle of Europe, in Kaliningrad: https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/files/2016/1...

Should we bomb Moscow to get rid of them?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:42AM (#42204213)
>Not true.

Yes, true:

https://armyrecognition.com/focus-analysis-conflicts/army/co...

Tomahawks used in the illegal attacks on Yugoslavia:

https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA478026

>That is already a reality with Russian missiles in the middle of Europe, in Kaliningrad

Russians deploying Russian nuclear weapons on Russian territory, versus Americans deploying NATO nuclear weapons on non-NATO territory: whats the difference?

>Should we bomb Moscow to get rid of them?

That depends - do you want to die in a thermonuclear blast?

Because that's how you die in a thermonuclear blast.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Thursday November 21, 2024 @11:46AM (#42206130)
Russians deploying Russian nuclear weapons on Russian territory,

You're playing word games here to avoid acknowledging the commenter's perfectly valid point, and it's really quite silly.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Friday November 22, 2024 @04:46AM (#42212469)
Believe it or not, this is the basis of international law.

You don't get to have standards for one nation but entirely different standards for another.

The USA can deploy missiles anywhere it wants - on its territory, or on the territories of its allies. But of course it needs to suffer the consequences if it decides to forward-deploy them on someone elses territory.

Same goes for Russia. Or, is there some other standard that you're applying that makes it okay for the USA to put nuclear-capable missiles on the borders of its enemies, but not okay for any other nation to do it?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Friday November 22, 2024 @04:50PM (#42217652)
The issue here is that you're shifting the goalposts.

Here's a boiled-down transcript what just transpired between yourself and the other commenter:

   You:  NATO seeks to deploy missiles within 7 minutes flight time of Russia's capitol. That's bad, threatening.

   They:  But we already have Russian missiles in the middle of Europe, in Kaliningrad.

   You:  But those missiles are on Russian territory, so that makes it OK.
There's simply no logic in your follow-up. Either the concern is missile proximity as you initially stated, or it isn't. And if it is -- you can't simply say it's intrinsically threatening and destabilizing when one country does it, but somehow benign and non-threatening when another country does (simply because in their case the missiles happen to be on their own territory).

Plus there's Russia's announcment of its intent to employ actual nuclear-armed missiles in Belarus, which no one has mentioned. Which would seem to make its complaint about non-nuclear deployments in Ukraine (which everyone knows will be exactly that) largely moot.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Monday November 25, 2024 @07:13AM (#42235587)
Does Russia have the right to apply policies equivalent to the US' own Monroe Doctrine, or doesn't it?

If not, why do you think Russia doesn't have that right, when the USA does?

Also, your entire position assumes that Europe==USA, when in fact it simply doesn't. The USA is forward-deploying its missile systems in (currently) friendly states - what happens when those states turn against the USA? Does the USA simply invade and retrieve its missile systems?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Monday November 25, 2024 @02:14PM (#42239207)
Does Russia have the right to apply policies equivalent to the US' own Monroe Doctrine, or doesn't it?

No country has a "right" to apply the Monroe Doctrine, anywhere, of course.

The idea that we should defend or empathize with (or "understand") Russia's current smash-and-grab operation underway in Ukraine, based on a perceived similarity between its actions and whatever bad things other empires have done, way back when -- I find to be really quite bizarre.

Why do you think Russia doesn't have that right, when the USA does?

I don't think the US has any such right -- and I find it quite strange that pretend to "know" that I would.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Monday November 25, 2024 @04:16PM (#42240308)
"that you should pretend ..."
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Monday November 25, 2024 @06:19PM (#42241100)
> Does Russia have the right to apply policies equivalent to the US' own Monroe Doctrine, or doesn't it?

Yes it does, but I think you've misunderstood what the Monroe Doctrine was. The Monroe Doctrine was not a blank license for the US to invade other countries and kill people there. The point of Monroe Doctrine was to protect western hemisphere from wars initiated by European colonial empires. A good example of this is the French invasion of Mexico in 1862 in an attempt to turn the newly-independent Mexico into a colony and install European aristocrat from the Habsburg dynasty as the emperor of Mexico. Americans offered military aid to Mexico, and after a few years of fighting, that emperor got executed by a firing squad and French forces were expulsed. Sounds familiar?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_French_intervention_in_...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximilian_I_of_Mexico

Russia is acting like one of those colonial empires that sought to conquer and exploit the Americas. The Monroe Doctrine was formulated against such behavior.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by hollerith on Monday November 25, 2024 @06:21PM (#42241125)
And yet when in 1962 the USSR at the invitation of the legitimate Cuban government tried to install missiles in Cuba, the US stopped them through a naval blockade.

Also, if government of Mexico ever decides to invite the People's Liberation Army into Mexico to help Mexico defend itself, and the PLA accepts the invitation, I want and expect my government (i.e., Washington) to stop them -- with organized violence if necessary such as is currently happening in Ukraine.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Monday November 25, 2024 @06:29PM (#42241166)
Also not really about the Monroe Doctrine, as the US action was in response strictly to the deployment of offensive missiles (what it saw as a de facto aggressive action against it) -- not the simple fact of Cuba forming a close relationship with the USSR per se.

Also, if government of Mexico ever decides to invite the People's Liberation Army into Mexico to help Mexico defend itself

And if that invitation happened only after Mexico was invaded by the US (on as grounds as equally stupid and unprovoked as Russia's current invasion of Ukraine) -- then I'm sure we can trust that you will not only unequivocally condemn that aggression, but solidly champion Mexico's right to defend itself against it by whatever means necessary.

See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42199619

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Monday November 25, 2024 @06:54PM (#42241328)
Legitimate is an interesting choice of words for any government in a country that has not had free elections since 1948. Fidel Castro was in charge of Cuba for 50 years without receiving a single ballot cast in his name, despite promising free elections in his first year.

Such dictatorships propped by a foreign power from another side of the planet at the expense of the safety and well-being of people in the Americas looks exactly the kind of thing Monroe Doctrine sought to prevent.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Monday November 25, 2024 @07:12PM (#42241412)
To be fair to the other commenter -- this was back in 1962, when Fidel's regime was (elections or no) by all accounts quite popular and broadly supported, and in any case much more legitimate than the regime which preceded it. Meanwhile, the US never had even borderline free elections until some 130 years after its founding (and they were never really quite free until the 1960s). Ironically, by 1962 its elections were still not "free" by modern standards.

Still, "legitimate" is a weird choice of words to describe unnecessary and provocative WMD deployments in any context.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Monday November 25, 2024 @07:25PM (#42241488)
Even by such early point in time, Cuba had already banned free elections. Castro proclaimed in 1961 that "the revolution has no time for elections" and that his dictatorship represents the highest form of democracy. If anyone argues for legitimacy after this point, then they have more faith in the loyality of Cuban people to Castro than he himself apparently had.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Thursday November 21, 2024 @08:59AM (#42204355)
> Yes, true

No, not true. Nothing in any of the provided sources says that Tomahawks have ever been given to Eastern Europe nor that there is any intention to. Ukraine has requested them, but your own source says that Ukraine is "unlikely" to receive them.

> Tomahawks used in the illegal attacks on Yugoslavia

They put an end to 10 years of wars in Yugoslavia and brought a lasting peace to the region. In worst massacres, more people were killed by Serbs over a single weekend than died in the entire NATO aerial bombardment campaign that lasted several months.

> Russians deploying Russian nuclear weapons on Russian territory, versus Americans deploying NATO nuclear weapons on non-NATO territory: whats the difference?

Again, nothing you say is true. No-one has given anyone Tomahawks, but Russia has deployed their missiles to Belarus: "Putin confirms first nuclear weapons moved to Belarus" https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-65932700

> That depends - do you want to die in a thermonuclear blast?

That's the question Russians should ask themselves when they keep pushing westwards with their nukes and attacks on European countries. Do Russians want to die in a thermonuclear blast that they act so recklessly?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Friday November 22, 2024 @04:49AM (#42212481)
>No, not true. Nothing in any of the provided sources

Read my words again: the threat was made. Russia responded to that threat, as the notion that nuclear-capable missiles would be deployed on borders within minutes of Moscow was deemed intolerable, and thus the deployment was cancelled.

>They put an end to 10 years of wars in Yugoslavia and brought a lasting peace to the region.

How many years of war occurred between the coup-government of Ukraine and the territory of Donbass before Russia invaded? And, again, the duplicity of your argument is clear: illegal wars are 'okay' as long as they result in peace and quiet afterwards?

That's not working out much for Gaza though, is it?

> No-one has given anyone Tomahawks,

I didn't say they did - I said that the threat to do so was made, and it was made - and as a result, we have war and calamity in Europe where we could have had a real, lasting peace between aligned nations.

If not for that coup.

>Russia has deployed their missiles to Belarus

Ah, and the USA has deployed their missiles all over Europe - so do allies have a right to engage in military agreements, or do they not?

You can't have it both ways. This is the entire point of MAD, which you seem to think doesn't apply to Washington, but does to Moscow.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Friday November 22, 2024 @12:31PM (#42215715)
> Read my words again: the threat was made.

You are making things up at this point. Eastern Europe has no Tomahawks, and nor has anyone given any indication that this would change, nor does the extreme caution in supplying much weaker weapons give a reason to even speculate about Tomahawks.

However, supplying more advanced weapons to Ukraine would be justified, given that Russia has broken the promises given to Ukraine in exchange for dismantling their nuclear weapons. I hope to see it happen!

> How many years of war occurred between the coup-government of Ukraine and the territory of Donbass before Russia invaded?

Zero. The European Court of Human Rights has ruled that there were no "separatists" in Donbas except for unmarked members of Russian armed forces and security services, fully under Russian command. And as in Yugoslavia, many lives could've been saved if NATO was more assertive in bombing the aggressor and establishing peace instead of looking the other way.

> Ah, and the USA has deployed their missiles all over Europe

American missiles stand where they stood when Nixon was still in office and countries that have joined alliances since the Cold War host none of them.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Monday November 25, 2024 @05:40AM (#42235044)
>Eastern Europe has no Tomahawks, and nor has anyone given any indication that this would change

Indications:

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/tomahawk-cruise-missi...

https://euromaidanpress.com/2024/11/22/potential-envoy-to-uk...

https://www.politico.eu/article/volodymyr-zelenskyy-confirms...

"“We know the plan is realistic. U.S. own military studied it and said it is realistic,” a Ukrainian official familiar with the matter told POLITICO when granted anonymity to be able to speak about a sensitive foreign policy issue."

Pay attention to the dates.

>American missiles stand where they stood when Nixon was still in office and countries that have joined alliances since the Cold War host none of them.

Why abandon involvement in a treaty designed to prevent proliferation, if not to proliferate?

https://www.iiss.org/online-analysis/online-analysis/2024/08...

Oh, and about those treaties ..

https://carnegieendowment.org/posts/2021/12/the-us-exit-from...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Monday November 25, 2024 @05:26PM (#42240789)
The quote you picked is from Ukrainians who are requesting Tomahawks.

US responses in the articles you linked:

1) "the U.S. and NATO are hesitant to endorse due to fears of nuclear escalation."

2) "I don’t see the Biden administration ready to do so yet."

3) "senior U.S. official described the Ukrainian request as totally unfeasible."

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Friday November 22, 2024 @01:58PM (#42216454)
How many years of war occurred between the coup-government of Ukraine and the territory of Donbass before Russia invaded?

There was no coup d'état.

Simply put - it's a false narrative.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Monday November 25, 2024 @05:34AM (#42235009)
>There was no coup d'état.

Yes, there was.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Monday November 25, 2024 @08:15AM (#42236019)
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by stoperaticless on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:06PM (#42188617)
What does it mean to be “nuclear tipped”?

As in uses depleted uranium (because of density characteristics) or radioactive waste stuff just for being radioactive?

(Obviously mass of tomahawk is too low for any chain nuclear reaction)

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aa-jv on Thursday November 21, 2024 @04:22AM (#42202506)
As in, contains a nuclear warhead. The Tomahawks are nuclear-capable.

Would you want nuclear-capable missiles deployed on your borders, within 7 minutes flight time of your capitol city?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:13AM (#42185050)
Yes, and Russia had similar "we won't be the first to be aggressive" language for many years as well. You can see that with new leadership comes new interpretations of when "peaceful means" are no longer sufficient.

From Russia's perspective, NATO has been infringing on both Russia's sphere of influence and on her buffer states. Russia has _twice_ been invaded by the Europeans, she hasn't forgotten that. And with Ukraine in NATO, there are no natural barriers between European powers and Russia.

Need I remind you how the US responded when the USSR set up missile positions in Cuba?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:58AM (#42185576)
Need I remind you how the US responded when the USSR set up missile positions in Cuba?

We can safely say "no", being as there is no analogy between the two situations.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by holowoodman on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:52PM (#42187400)
Well, there was the Cuba missile equivalent of stationing missiles in Turkey. Which, seemingly as part of the negotiation to end the crisis, were removed from Turkey afterwards.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:42AM (#42185403)
> And with Ukraine in NATO, there are no natural barriers between European powers and Russia.

I have already asked you in another comment to tell me how long NATO has been literally on Russia’s border.

Why are you dodging the question?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:43PM (#42186775)
I'm not dodging questions. I'm demonstrating the Russian perspective. I don't care one way or the other.

In any case, I'm not on HN constantly. Maybe once every hour or so I'll take a look. Aggressiveness and impatience are not appreciated on HN, if I get around to answering you I will. And maybe not if I don't feel that _I_ have something to learn from the conversation. I'm not here promoting some dogma, and I don't have to answer your questions.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:00PM (#42186910)
I'm not dodging questions.

You were absolutely, unequivocally were dodging the commenter's question.

I don't care one way or the other.

If you plainly don't care, and won't answer questions, and since you obviously don't invest the time to keep even basic tabs on the actual situation on the ground anyway -- then it's extremely difficult to see why you're bothering to engage at all, here. It looks like you're just out to stir the pot, basically.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Thursday November 21, 2024 @01:14AM (#42201610)

  > You were absolutely, unequivocally were dodging the commenter's question.
Because I didn't answer in an hour? I'm not glued to HN all day to argue. And if I don't feel like engaging with someone looking for an argument, I don't engage them.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Friday November 22, 2024 @01:44AM (#42211663)
Then don't engage.

But if you do respond, but you ignore an obvious key question that was asked -- then by any standard of discourse -- you're pulling a dodge.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:51PM (#42186839)
For. How. Long. Has. NATO. Been. On. Russia’s. Border.

Again, you are dodging the question.

Either you will say they aren’t, in service of your argument that russia invaded Ukraine to prevent NATO from coming up to their border, in which case you would be wrong since NATO has shared a border with russia in Europe for at least the past 24 years.

Or, you will say at least the past 24 years, which undermines your argument that russia only invaded Ukraine to prevent NATO appearing at their immediate borders, since they were already there. For at least the past 24 years.

We can do this all day.

I’ve got another question for you. Almost certainly you will dodge it, because it is blindingly obvious that you are not impartial as you pretend to be, and that you have a strong bias for the Putin regime and its illegal war and genocide, but let’s go through the motions anyway.

How did the Moskva sink?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:23PM (#42189145)
Some other guy already answered you on your post with the original question: "4 April 1949 the day NATO was founded"

  > How did the Moskva sink?
Didn't the Ukrainians shoot it with either an anti-ship missile or a drone jetski? Is this some test to see "what side I'm on"? I frankly don't care - like I said I was demonstrating the other side of the coin. But I see that was extremely offensive to you. I'm neither European nor Russian, I really don't care who's right. But I do listen to both sides of the story.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:13PM (#42190768)

    > Some other guy already answered you on your post with the original question: "4 April 1949 the day NATO was founded"
Let’s go with that answer. If NATO has been on russia’s border since before Putin was born, how could russia’s justification for invading Ukraine, annexing territory, and slaughtering thousands of civilians possibly be that they were nervous about NATO coming closer to their borders?

It also doesn’t explain why earlier you said “And with Ukraine in NATO, there are no natural barriers between European powers and Russia.”

How does that make any sense at all? There have been “no natural barriers between European powers and russia” for decades already. It has nothing to do with Ukraine.

    > Didn't the Ukrainians shoot it with either an anti-ship missile or a drone jetski?
Interesting! That’s not what the russian government said. Surely you’re not suggesting the russian government would lie, are you?!

    > I really don't care who's right. But I do listen to both sides of the story.
This is hard to believe given the strong bias you have shown towards Kremlin propaganda.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @01:09PM (#42196619)
Dude you need to calm down and realize the person you are discussing this with is not nearly as partisan as you. You are confusing discourse for propaganda and explanation for excuse.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @01:23PM (#42196726)
As a society we don't accept Holocaust denial. Nor should we accept the legitimisation of russia's invasion and genocide in Ukraine.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:10AM (#42183014)
Why do they seem valid?

How long has NATO been on russia's border? This is an important question. Please try to answer it.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by pasc1878 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:50PM (#42186236)
4 April 1949 the day NATO was founded.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:00PM (#42186912)
NATO has been on both Russia’s western (land) border and eastern (sea) border since it was founded in 1949.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by esarbe on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:01AM (#42182939)
Russia's "concerns" are not valid.

It's not even that there was absolutely no active process of joining NATO when Russia attacked Ukraine in February 2014 and started all this. No; if Ukraine wants to join NATO, that's entirely Ukraine's decision. Russia has no say in it. Ukraine is sovereign and can join any military alliance it wants. Just as Russia is free to do so.

No nation has extra-territorial security interests that it needs to defend by attacking a neutral, peaceful and friendly neighbor.

You have been fooled into defending imperialism. Or worse; you're consciously defending imperialism.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:19AM (#42185129)

  > Russia's "concerns" are not valid.
Dismissing Russia's concerns is exactly what led to this war.

  > It's not even that there was absolutely no active process of joining NATO when Russia attacked Ukraine in February 2014 and started all this. No; if Ukraine wants to join NATO, that's entirely Ukraine's decision. Russia has no say in it. Ukraine is sovereign and can join any military alliance it wants. Just as Russia is free to do so.
NATO stated in the 2008 Bucharest Summit that "Ukraine will become a member of the Alliance" and reiterated that statement in the 2021 Brussels Summit. I didn't even remember those details, it was easy to find with google and a vague idea that NATO had shown interest in Ukraine.

> No nation has extra-territorial security interests that it needs to defend by attacking a neutral, peaceful and friendly neighbor.

Then you know nothing of US doctrine. The Central Americans will tell you how the US will even invade just to lower the price of bananas - no joke.

  > You have been fooled into defending imperialism. Or worse; you're consciously defending imperialism.
No, I really don't have a side in this. I'm simply presenting Russia's viewpoint as I understand it. I also understand the Western viewpoint as well, but there's no need to defend it in present company, we all agree about NATO, European, and US positions on the matter.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:50AM (#42185485)
> > It’s not even that there was absolutely no active process of joining NATO when Russia attacked Ukraine in February 2014 and started all this. No; if Ukraine wants to join NATO, that’s entirely Ukraine’s decision. Russia has no say in it. Ukraine is sovereign and can join any military alliance it wants. Just as Russia is free to do so.

> NATO stated in the 2008 Bucharest Summit that “Ukraine will become a member of the Alliance” and reiterated that statement in the 2021 Brussels Summit. I didn’t even remember those details, it was easy to find with google and a vague idea that NATO had shown interest in Ukraine.

A little bit more competent Googling would fill in the context you’ve clearly missed:

(1) The 2008 statement was a way of mollifying Ukraine after acceding to Russia’s demand that Ukraine and Georgia be denied NATO Membership Action Plans at the 2008 summit. (Russia responded, by the way, to this accession to their demands by invading Georgia. Might have done the same to the Ukraine soon after, except by the time they were at a stable point with Georgia, they’d already managed to get a Russia-friendly government in Ukraine.)

(2) Ukraine publicly abandoned any interest in a foreign military alliance between the 2008 summit and the 2014 invasion by Russia.

(3) Ukraine abandoned its neutrality stance and restarted attempts to join NATO only after the 2014 invasion.

(4) The 2021 statement was, again, a way of putting a nice face for Ukraine on NATO again rejecting Ukraine’s attempts to join in the near term.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:53AM (#42185524)
Dismissing Russia's concerns is exactly what led to this war.

Provided one accepts that those concerns are valid.

And that its stated "concerns" were in fact its actual reasons for starting the war.

But there is no compelling logical basis for us to accept either of these premises.

I don't have time to fully dissect what you're saying about the NATO issue -- other than that you are leaving out some very important details which for some reason were not presented to you in whatever sources you are reading from. (Which is a polite way of telling you: your sources are apparently misinformed, or worse).

But the main point is: none of the NATO stuff ever amounted to an actual physical threat against the Russian state, or otherwise any rational reason for Russia's regime to start a war.

More to the point, it wasn't the real reason it chose to the start the war. It's just something it says, for internal and external propaganda purposes.

So no - we don't have to "accept that Russia's concerns are valid".

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:44AM (#42185429)
This is not "Russia's viewpoint", but a narrative to advance their ambition of enslaving again the roughly 100 million people who became free after the USSR collapsed.

The Russian viewpoint is that Eastern Europe would be much easier to conquer if they were internationally isolated and could be picked off one by one like in the 1940s. The current war against Ukraine is an excellent example of this; international cooperation is a leading reason for the failure of the invasion. All the complaints about NATO lead back to the fact that for Russia it elevates the cost of invading Eastern Europe. Without NATO, they would face only limited conventional forces in Poland. With NATO, an attack on Poland go as far as activating American carrier groups or even a nuclear response.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by esarbe on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:18PM (#42187062)
> Dismissing Russia's concerns is exactly what led to this war.

No. Russia invading a peaceful, friendly and neutral neighbor with unmarked military units is what lead to this war.

> NATO stated in the 2008 Bucharest Summit

FR, ES and DE made it clear that Ukraine would not be a candidate for NATO and nothing came of it. The first step in admitting a nation into NATO is a Membership Action Plan (MAP) - there never was a such for Ukraine. NATO membership for Ukraine was dead in the water in 2014, when Russia heinously attacked with unmarked military units.

But that is besides the point, really; Ukraine is sovereign. It is a sovereign nation that can itself decide which alliances to join. Ukraine is not beholden to Russia and Russia doesn't get a say in Ukrainian politics. Russia is not the Soviet Union and Ukraine is not the Ukrainian Soviet Republic.

> Then you know nothing of US doctrine.

Ah, yes. The "this one over there is a murderer too" defense. You're still defending imperialism, you're just defending imperialism with more imperialism.

> I'm simply presenting Russia's viewpoint as I understand it.

Russia's viewpoint is that Ukraine has no right so sovereignty. That's in direct violation with multiple treaties with Ukraine that Russia has signed.

Russia does not want an independent Ukraine. That's why they have been attacking Ukraine for 10 years now, first clandestine and then ever more openly. That's why they have been bombing civilians, that's why the formally annexed Ukrainian territory, that's why they will not grant peace to their neighbor.

Because without Ukraine, there can be no Russian Empire.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:31AM (#42183822)
NATO was founded to defend against invasion from e.g. Russia, if it comes to pass. NATO has never and will never be an aggressor, see article 1 as someone pointed out.

If anything, Russia has put themselves in serious shit for invading Ukraine. If they hadn't started this, over 600.000 of their people wouldn't be dead or wounded.

How many countries has NATO invaded?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by SiempreViernes on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:37AM (#42183885)
> NATO has never and will never be an aggressor

Not to defend the regime in power then (nor now!), but if you ask Serbia they might offer some other lived experiences on how consensual Operation Allied Force was.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:40AM (#42185379)
Why did NATO bomb Serbia?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by SiempreViernes on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:02PM (#42189418)
It was not because Serbia invaded a NATO country, if that's what you were asking.

Thought of course you knew that already since you obviously know what the operation was called, a fact basically nobody today knows (without looking it up).

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by deanCommie on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:34PM (#42189631)
It was to stop a genocide.

Just because they weren't "defending a NATO member" doesn't mean that the operation was "offensive".

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:05PM (#42190734)
I do know why NATO bombed Serbia. Often when it’s brought up, people neglect to mention why it happened. The result is we have thousands of people who believe NATO is evil because supposedly they’ll bomb cities for no reason.

But there is a reason, which curiously enough you neglected to mention. As the other commenter pointed out, it was to stop an active genocide which was being prosecuted by Slobodan Milosevic’s military and paramilitary forces.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:17AM (#42185106)

  > NATO was founded to defend against invasion from e.g. Russia
Exactly. Russia views NATO as an anti-Russian entity. And both sides have phrases that amount roughly to "the best defense is an effective offense".

Would you feel threatened if your neighbours set up weapons right outside your property line, ostensibly to defend in case you attack? And especially if they've already invaded your property twice (France and Germany both invaded Russia).

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by wbl on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:55AM (#42185545)
Russia signed treaty after treaty saying countries can make their own alliances. NATO has not put nukes eastward or any permeant allied presence, other than the armies of the allied states themselves in the region.

Russia refused to withdraw from Moldova to implement CFE II. This is not the action of a state worried that it's disadvantage in conventional arms will lead to invasion.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:01PM (#42185605)
Would you feel threatened if your neighbours set up weapons right outside your property line, ostensibly to defend in case you attack?

Except that never happened in Ukraine, or in any of the other NATO countries close to Russia.

You know that, right?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:39PM (#42186736)
I'm showing you the Russian perspective. I don't care one way or the other.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:58PM (#42186899)
Funny, it definitely seemed as if you were presenting it as your own.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by esarbe on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:22PM (#42187095)
That's not the Russian "perspective", that's just a Russian propaganda lie.

The actual Russian perspective is "Let's quickly grab Ukraine before they completely turn towards Europe, otherwise Russia cannot be an empire again."

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fsloth on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:05PM (#42188606)
Bravo sir, this is Alexander cutting the knot of muddled relativism.

It may be strange to modern western minds but Russians still consider their imperial project as wholesome, good and nearly sacred. To get into the correct mindstate, you can read for example how Churchill venerated the British empire. The Russians hold this same veneration to their imperial project today. They also know western audience probably would not appreciate this reasoning so they need to invent laughable excuses like ”we were afraid of NATO expansion” that clueless western commentators happily repeat as the foundational reason.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by stoperaticless on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:57PM (#42188540)
I guess it’s one way to frame it. The other could be:

Somebody is refusing to pay protection money and is forming a “neighbourhood watch”. We need to make example of them.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by kjkjadksj on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:57AM (#42185569)
You act like there aren’t a hundred missiles in Montana trained at russian targets for the past 70 years. Should russia invade montana?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dotancohen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:40PM (#42186745)
Is Montana right up on Russia's border, severely limiting time to respond in case of launch?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by yakshaving_jgt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:53PM (#42186861)
So why hasn’t russia invaded Poland?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mopsi on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:39AM (#42185370)
What weapons? Cold War era stockpiles have been dismantled in Europe and nothing has been installed in countries that have joined since the Cold War.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by esarbe on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:20PM (#42187086)
Ukraine was not a NATO member when Russia attacked it in February 2014, not was there a membership action plan to get Ukraine into NATO.

This has nothing to do with NATO. Only with Russian imperialism.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:14PM (#42185778)
Are you aware that NATO expansion into Ukraine seemed very likely at the time of Russia's invasion?

Actually it was effectively impossible, as NATO's bylaws prevent the admission of states with active border conflicts. This is most likely why Putin invaded both Georgia and Ukraine -- to create permanent border conflicts, to prevent them from becoming NATO states.

So in fact there was no imminent possibility of Ukraine becoming a NATO state at the time of the 2022 invasion. And it was never the reason Putin chose to launch the full-scale invasion, anyway.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dmpk2k on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:46PM (#42186187)
One thing I've learned watching politicians the past few decades is that laws are guidelines. If the political will exists, politicians will find a way.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by esarbe on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:24PM (#42187111)
The war started in 2014. There was even less imminent possibility of Ukraine becoming a NATO member back then, when Putin first sent unmarked military units to attack Ukraine.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:38PM (#42187260)
The war started in 2014.

That's known, and already implicit in what I said.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by holowoodman on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:56PM (#42187438)
West Germany joined NATO during an effective border conflict about whether it should actually be just Germany, reunified with the eastern parts. However, that conflict never actually was a war, just part of the "cold war".