This is honestly wear I think LLM really shines. This also gives you a very good idea if your documentation is deficient or not.
I've been wondering about that and am glad to hear it's working in the wild.
I'm now wondering if using a fine-tuned LLM (on the corpus) to gen the hypothetical answers and then use those for the rag flow would work even better.
Interestingly, going both ways: generate hypothetical answers for the query, and also generate hypothetical questions for the text chunk at ingestion both increase RAG performance in my experience.
Though LLM-based query-processing is not always suitable for chat applications if inference time is a concer (like near-real time customer support RAG), so ingestion-time hypothetical answer generation is more apt there.
What we find really effective is at content ingestion time, we prepend “decorator text” to the document or chunk. This incorporates various metadata about the document (title, author(s), publication date, etc).
Then at query time, we generate a contextual hypothetical document that matches the format of the decorator text.
We add hybrid search (BM25 and rerank) to that, also add filters (documents published between these dates, by this author, this type of content, etc). We have an LLM parameterize those filters and use them as part of our retrieval step.
This process works incredibly for end users.
Can you expand on what the LLM work here is and it’s purpose?
> 3. Hypothetical answer generation from a query using an LLM, and then using that hypothetical answer to query for embeddings works really well.
Interesting idea, going to add to our experiments. Thanks.
This is an interesting observation to me. I would have expected that, since LLMs evolved from autocomplete/autocorrect algorithms, correcting spelling mistakes would be one of their strong suits. Do you have examples of cases where they fail?
At this moment I would not trust AI to automatically make changes.
I actually think even BERT could be overkill here -- I have a half-baked prototype of a keyword expansion system that should do the trick here. The idea is is to construct a data structure of keywords ahead of time (e.g. by data-mining some portion of Common Crawl), where each keyword has "neighbors" -- words that often appear together and (sometimes, but not always) signal relatedness. I didn't take the concept very far yet, but I give it better than even odds! (Especially if the resulting data structure is pruned by a half-decent LLM -- my initial attempts resulted in a lot of questionable "neighbors" -- though I had a fairly small dataset so it's likely I was largely looking at noise.)
It can definitely be automated in my opinion, if you go with a supermajority workflow. Something that I've noticed with LLMs is it's very unlikely for all high-quality LLM models to be wrong at the same time. So if you go by a supermajority, the changes are almost certainly valid.
Having said all of that, I still believe we are not addressing the root cause of bad searches which is "garbage in, garbage out". I strongly believe the true calling for LLM will be to help us curate and manage data, at scale.
>3. Hypothetical answer generation from a query using an LLM, and then using that hypothetical answer to query for embeddings works really well.
What sort of performance are you getting in production with this one? The other two are basically solved for performance and RAG in general if it is related to a known and pre-processed corpus but I am having trouble thinking of how you don't get a hit with #3.
For live experiences like chat, we solved it with UX. As soon as you start typing the words of a question into the chat box, it does the FTS search and retrieves a set of documents that have word-matches, scored just using ES heuristics (eg: counting matching words etc)
These are presented as cards that expand when clicked. The user can see it's doing something.
While that's happening, also issue a full hyde flow in the background with a placeholder loading shimmer that loads in the full answer.
So there is some dead-time of about 10 seconds or so while it generates the hypothetical answers. After that, a short ~1 sec interval to load up the knowledge nodes, and then it starts streaming the answer.
This approach tested well with UXR participants and maintains acceptable accuracy.
A lot of the times, when looking for specific facts from a knowledge base, just the card UX gets an answer immediately. Eg: "What's the email for product support?"
Ha, that's brilliant. Thanks for sharing this!
Initially I generated categories by asking an LLM with a long prompt(https://github.com/itissid/Drop-PoT/blob/main/src/drop_backe...) But I like your idea better!
My next iteration to solve this problem – I never got to it – was gonna be to generate the most appropriate categories based on user's personal interest, weather, time of day and non PII data and fine-tune a retrieval and a ranking engine to generate categories for each content piece personalized to them.
Few learnings I've collected:
1. Lexical search with BM25 alone gives you very relevant results if you can do some work during ingestion time with an LLM.
2. Embeddings work well only when the size of the query is roughly on the same order of what you're actually storing in the embedding store.
3. Hypothetical answer generation from a query using an LLM, and then using that hypothetical answer to query for embeddings works really well.
So combining all 3 learnings, we landed on a knowledge decomposition and extraction step very similar to yours. But we stick a metaprompter to essentially auto-generate the domain / entity types.
LLMs are naively bad at identifying the correct level of granularity for the decomposed knowledge. One trick we found is to ask the LLM to output a mermaid.js mindmap to hierarchically break down the input into a tree. At the end of that output, ask the LLM to state which level is the appropriate root for a knowledge node.
Then the node is used to generate questions that could be answered from the knowledge contained in this node. We then index the text of these questions and also embed them.
You can directly match the user's query from these questions using purely BM25 and get good outputs. But a hybrid approach works even better, though not by that much.
Not using LLMs are query time also means we can hierarchically walk down the root into deeper and deeper nodes, using the embedding similiarity as a cost function for the traversal.