News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moral Design by skrebbel on Sunday July 08, 2012 @04:50PM (#4215663)
On Farmville:

> The design of the game is inherently immoral, and it is immoral not because it is badly made, deceptive, or ineffective, but because the ultimate aims of the design are destructively selfish: one gains, the other loses.

What? How is people giving a company money for having fun playing a game "destructively selfish" of said company?

Re:Moral Design by jtheory on Sunday July 08, 2012 @07:10PM (#4216013)
There's a pretty strong argument to be made that most people playing Farmville are not, on the whole, having fun.

Certainly the psychological prods that Zynga deploys to keep people constantly returning are not all (or even mostly?) fun-based.

I also wonder how many treasured memories of hours spent clicking on cows the younger generation of current Farmville players will fondly recount to their grandchildren, many years hence.

Of course there's a short-sighted argument that "people pay for it, therefore they want it, therefore they must be enjoying it" to justify this sort of stuff. It's a shitty justification, though, if you even think about how human psychology seems to work; no advanced study required.

I guess there's always "if we don't sell it, someone else will, and they'll get all the money instead", as well, though that doesn't even really pretend to be creating a moral good anymore.

[side note: sorry to seem to fire this at your short comment... it's a topic that troubles me deeply, and I'm leaving just this one comment in the discussion.]

Re:Moral Design by cabalamat on Sunday July 08, 2012 @05:41PM (#4215826)
> How is people giving a company money for having fun playing a game "destructively selfish" of said company?

The same way that giving a company money for alcohol/tobacco/cocaine/etc might be destructive to the buyer and selfish for the seller.

Re:Moral Design by stfu on Sunday July 08, 2012 @06:25PM (#4215920)
Well, the "big" difference is, that those destructive "things" are substantially impacting the health of their users, while a game, no matter how sophisticated, rarely does (except for a few extreme examples). One might more draw the argument into the gambling direction.

But I personally think that the addiction argument is highly problematic construct. For example we all remember the studies demonstrating that people are addicted to "the internet" or "mobile telephones". When the first animal was domesticated one probably could also have done a study into how they are conditioning human behavior, by requesting food, affection, play, etc. A lot of this seems context based.

Re:Moral Design by saraid216 on Sunday July 08, 2012 @11:43PM (#4216582)
> Well, the "big" difference is, that those destructive "things" are substantially impacting the health of their users, while a game, no matter how sophisticated, rarely does (except for a few extreme examples). One might more draw the argument into the gambling direction.

We could have fun and bring up spiritual health. :D

Re:Moral Design by eevilspock on Sunday July 08, 2012 @05:52PM (#4215856)
I am a crack cocaine dealer and I entirely agree with you.