News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Dust Over India by aggronn on Sunday July 08, 2012 @04:12PM (#4215550)
In what way is regulatory capture corruption? What is the alternative? I'm reluctant to consider it corruption in the same sentence as bribery, despite that it is an inherent conflict of interest.
Re:A Dust Over India by dredmorbius on Sunday July 08, 2012 @09:21PM (#4216263)
Regulatory agencies are supposed to, by charter, look to the public interest in overseeing companies.

If they are captured by the companies they regulate, and serve the companies' interests rather than the public's, by definition their mission has been corrupted.

Your question is highly disingenuous.

Re:A Dust Over India by aggronn on Sunday July 08, 2012 @10:44PM (#4216461)
Your assessment of my question isn't fair. Serving companies interests vs serving public interests isn't a dichotomy, and very rarely is a regulatory decision as clean cut as 'this is obviously bad and a net loss for the society, but we're going to let them set do it anyways'. Believing that to be the case is far more disingenuous.

Regardless, moving between industry and regulatory bodies isn't necessarily done in a corrupt manner. If you're the president of a state energy board, you don't need to break any rules to get a higher paying job in industry. you're already, perhaps necessarily, more qualified than almost any other candidates. This is not inherently corrupt, this is what OP was referring to (or, this is a common meme which is associated with what he described).

Re:A Dust Over India by dredmorbius on Monday July 09, 2012 @12:26AM (#4216672)
No, it's accurate.

What part of "when a state regulatory agency, created to act in the public interest, instead advances the commercial or special interests that dominate the industry or sector it is charged with regulating" don't you understand?

That is the definition of "regulatory capture".

Note that regulatory capture is not "balancing the public interest with commercial realities" or similar such wording.

If you're perhaps debating some other term, please provide us with an accepted term and definition of same, rather than creating a Lewis Carrol "glory" (see: http://sabian.org/looking_glass6.php) and passing off as accepted wisdom.

On my planet, the appearance of impropriety is considered largely as bad as actual impropriety. Taking an example from a US government website: http://ig.navy.mil/Complaints/Complaints%20%20(Appearance%20...

If the revolving door consistently operates between regulatory agencies and the organizations those agencies regulate, then yes, I'd say that this comprises systemic corruption.

Re:A Dust Over India by aggronn on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:38AM (#4216842)
It might suffice to say that 'regulatory capture' is used more broadly in economic literature than what the wikipedia article you're referencing leads on. Maybe not. We disagree fundamentally on the 'appearance of impropriety' comment here. I don't consider the reason for changing jobs to be so cut and dry. I don't see this moving onto a productive discussion.
Re:A Dust Over India by dredmorbius on Monday July 09, 2012 @11:43AM (#4218682)
If you're finding an alternate definition, cite your reference.
Re:A Dust Over India by kamaal on Monday July 09, 2012 @12:29AM (#4216677)
>>Serving companies interests vs serving public interests isn't a dichotomy

It actually is, many times. Especially when companies are ready to pay up any amount of bribe to get their job done.

To give you an example. A manufacturer can sell, low quality transformers to electric board. This is goes against public interests. But at the same the manufacturer can argue he creating jobs by running a company, so he can cheat.

>>If you're the president of a state energy board, you don't need to break any rules to get a higher paying job in industry.

Regular job income is chicken feed for these people compared to the money they make in bribes, commissions etc.

Re:A Dust Over India by aggronn on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:18AM (#4216801)
I'm specifically not referring to bribes. That is undoubtedly corruption.

>A manufacturer can sell, low quality transformers to electric board. This is goes against public interests.

You're going to have to give more details than this in order to make that statement. Are they in a competitive market? Is someone picking winners? What effect does this have on prices? Moreover, is he creating jobs? How is that cheating?

Re:A Dust Over India by kamaal on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:38AM (#4216846)
In India its pretty common to have this scenario. We call it the 'License Raj System'- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licence_Raj

Licenses for supplies, manufacturing, export, services etc. Heck nearly everything is controlled by licenses. Which are in turn issued by the government. The Net result is heavy bribes are paid to get licenses. And then bribes are paid to regulators to by pass violations.

You might think lobbying and campaign funds are too much of corruption in US. Come to India, you have to pay bribe for everything and anything.

To give you a specific scenario. Lets say you bid for a contract to build roads. Lets say you tar roads. Firstly this can be won only through if you are licensed contractors(You have to pay bribe to get one). Then tenders are allocated for the road construction, you have to pay commissions to get selected.

Now after heavily bribing your way through all this. The only way you can make profit is by sacrificing quality. Therefore you now use low quality material. If saw you are asked to tar the road 8 inches, you do only 3 inches. You don't tar lanes. The quality of tar you use doesn't last one rainy season.

Regulatory authorities are severely bribed to over look all this.

This is the regular story in India, In nearly ever walk of life. This happens from birth to death. People even bribe for birth and death certificates, voter identification cards, passports. You name it, and there is corruption associated with it.

Re:A Dust Over India by r00fus on Sunday July 08, 2012 @08:49PM (#4216207)
Regulatory Capture is, according to Wikipedia, a clear aspect of corruption, see "corruption" wiki template: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Corruption

Not sure how else to remedy your confusion here.

Re:A Dust Over India by aggronn on Sunday July 08, 2012 @10:39PM (#4216435)
Its not confusion. I'm more qualified to talk about 'regulatory capture' than I'm leading on, but its a real question: how is moving from industry to regulation, or the other way around, inherently corrupt? I disagree that having a system with poor incentives necessarily means it's 'corrupt'. Bribery is undoubtedly corruption. But when a state power regulator lowers restrictions on pollutants and greenpeace calls foul play, how can tell that that they're doing it because they believe its prudent or because they're looking for a job?

A major complaint that a lot people have is that oh, when you leave your S&P job thats paying 60k a year for an IB job that pays 300k a year, you're a symptom of corruption. But hell, what if your experience working for S&P necessarily means your qualified to do derivatives trading?

If you're getting job offers that are conditional on you making certain regulator decisions, thats bribery. Eventually wanting to get into the business side of things because they pay more isn't the same thing.

Re:A Dust Over India by JabavuAdams on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:08AM (#4217724)
> I'm more qualified to talk about 'regulatory capture' than I'm leading on, but its a real question: how is moving from industry to regulation, or the other way around, inherently corrupt?

It ignores human nature. People don't rat out their friends. If you're the jerk at the party, you stop getting invited to the right parties.

Re:A Dust Over India by kamaal on Monday July 09, 2012 @12:35AM (#4216696)
>>how is moving from industry to regulation, or the other way around, inherently corrupt?

Because regulations work only if regulators are honest.

Re:A Dust Over India by GoodIntentions on Sunday July 08, 2012 @04:38PM (#4215627)
>> In what way is regulatory capture corruption?

Try getting a decent mobile data plan in Canada. It will be rapidly apparent to you.

Re:A Dust Over India by aggronn on Sunday July 08, 2012 @04:49PM (#4215659)
I see what you're saying, but in what way is that strictly corruption? I think what I'm really asking is, where do we draw the line on what is corruption and what isn't? To me, regulatory capture, and a fair amount of public economics, is just 'how things are'. There are ways to try to reduce certain aspects of it, but are we really willing to ban movement between working in industry and the regulatory side of things like we ban bribery?
Re:A Dust Over India by GoodIntentions on Sunday July 08, 2012 @05:02PM (#4215698)
When a government created and sanctioned body has the effective ability to make or break players in an industry, and that body becomes utterly owned by the incumbents. It stops representing the public interests and begins defending the incumbents from market forces that motivate those incumbents to compete fairly, offer reasonably current services or even innovate new ones as a means to compete.

In short, they represent corporate interests while ostensibly being the people's governing body. This is imho, corruption. I don't know how exactly you regulate this away - perhaps mandate a percentage of the regulators specifically be from outside the industry.

Edit: for completion of sentence/thought

Re:A Dust Over India by srean on Sunday July 08, 2012 @05:05PM (#4215712)
I have some answers to your questions, not all, and then they are my answers, not necessarily correct answers. But, I think it will not do much good to just state them.

I would say give the questions and their underlying assumptions some thought and also time. For me I had to fight of the tendency to just close the question with some answer and be done with it.