News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by Terr_ on Friday November 15, 2024 @05:04PM (#42151706)
> The most crucial decision when joining Mastodon is choosing the most friendly instance.

I was very disappointed to find out that whatever instance you choose can essentially hold your identity and content hostage.

I'd been hoping for something where my identity comes from a private key that I could take elsewhere.

Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by ASalazarMX on Friday November 15, 2024 @06:44PM (#42152621)
Mastodon allows you move instances with minimal effort. You can redirect your old profile to the new one in another instance, or permanently move it keeping your follows and followers.

No one there wants to hold your information hostage, you can always export it, and while it doesn't support importing, you can repost it through their API if you really want to.

https://docs.joinmastodon.org/user/moving/

Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by Terr_ on Saturday November 16, 2024 @12:44AM (#42154613)
I may have been misremembering Lemmy instead.

> You can redirect your old profile to the new one

Is that true even when the reason for the change is because the instance operator wants to silence you? If you can't put up a metaphorical "Go Here Instead" sign, could they also stop you from "proving" that your new home is legitimate and that you're the same author as before?

Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by rglullis on Saturday November 16, 2024 @06:55AM (#42155944)
> You can redirect your old profile to the new one in another instance, or permanently move it keeping your follows and followers

But you lose all the posts and interactions. Most importantly, you are not keeping your identity, but merely creating a new account with a copy of your follower/following collections.

> No one there wants to hold your information hostage,

Tell that to a friend of mine who got banned from their instance for committing the crime of being an Ethereum developer. The admin suspended his account and didn't let him go back or initiate the migration process.

Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by Dylan16807 on Sunday November 17, 2024 @12:00AM (#42162089)
A redirect is a pale imitation of a real move.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by hugs on Friday November 15, 2024 @06:18PM (#42152404)
"something where my identity comes from a private key that I could take elsewhere" is a literal technical description of how Nostr works. Relays/servers are basically dumb pipes. You own your data and can repost to different relays (and encouraged to do so.) Problem is if your key is lost or stolen, you're kinda screwed.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by Terr_ on Friday November 15, 2024 @06:20PM (#42152421)
I looked into running my own instance, but.... It was non-trivial.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by hugs on Friday November 15, 2024 @06:41PM (#42152591)
Yeah, self-hosting the whole stack can be a lot (like Mastodon). I only signed up via the Primal mobile app and left it at that. Private key stays local.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by ASalazarMX on Friday November 15, 2024 @07:02PM (#42152797)
Except Nostr is mainly populated by crypto bros, that's not something I'd like to read on a daily basis.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by jghn on Friday November 15, 2024 @06:28PM (#42152492)
But not really. I only ever want to see people I follow in my feed. And I can follow people from wherever, not just my instance. So the decision of what instance I chose was inconsequential.
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by chc4 on Friday November 15, 2024 @10:21PM (#42153858)
Good news! You just described how Bluesky works
Re:Maybe Bluesky Has "Won" by lolinder on Friday November 15, 2024 @11:44PM (#42154332)
Except for that, as discussed in TFA, Bluesky isn't actually decentralized (yet).