News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by Taters91 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @09:58AM (#42136731)
The court system worked very well in this case. A set of parents brought a civil lawsuit against a well-known man who was spreading what they thought were lies and inflicting emotional distress. Jones had plenty of time to respond, and he decided not to. Therefore, the case was decided in default, as is the way all civil cases would have been. Then, a jury of his peers was brought in to decide on the size of the penalty. After hearing evidence, and giving Jones a chance to respond and question (which his lawyers absolutely failed to do effectively), the jury decided on a penalty. This is a very simple case of a civil court system working as intended. Just because Jones lies to his audience and his audience is beholden to Jones's view of the world, does not mean the court system is malfunctioning. Listen to Knowledge Fight, it's better than InfoWars.
[dead]
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by Taters91 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:28AM (#42137813)
Discovery isn't just giving over random documents. It's about giving over the documents that are requested by the other side. So giving more documents than they ask for is actually a hinderence. And the case was not about specific documents, it was the overall actions. Because of the "consistent pattern of discovery abuse" (quoting the decision), the parents could not see that evidence.

As for the larger point, in public opinion, most people see Jones getting what he deserves. He lied over and over again, caused harm to many families, and is now getting punished for it. He did this while knowing he was lying.

I'm also interested in what way during trial Bankston made himself look bad or anti-first amendment or against justice.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:00PM (#42138227)
> It's about giving over the documents that are requested by the other side.

Right, 100%. The point of contention is that documents that don't exist were demanded and those documents that don't exist are what the court claimed a default judgement over. This is per the court's own records.

> the parents could not see that evidence.

What evidence do we believe we are talking about here? If this evidence was never entered into the trial, why should us spectators believe it existed?

> the "consistent pattern of discovery abuse" (quoting the decision)

This here is what gives Alex ground to say "the court was on trial", in the greater context that an undercover journalist caught someone who works for the CIA on video admitting that the suits against Jones are lawfare. If you have not seen this video, you may not know how much information you are missing on this topic. If you dismiss the video because a particular group filmed the video, then we're not playing a game of mutually pursuing the truth here.

Throughout the entire process, Alex alleged a consistent pattern of discovery abuse on the part of the court. Deprivation of rights under color of law is a very serious crime that carries a 10+ year prison sentence. And yes, judges do sometimes have federal lawsuits filed against them for it.

> caused harm to many families

The other major point of contention, is this was never demonstrated in court, let alone meaningfully argued in court.

> He did this while knowing he was lying.

This also was never demonstrated. The court records don't show anything like this ; perhaps they show something like this on a procedural matter around discovery, but not anywhere on the topic of the supposed substance of the case.

> and is now getting punished for it

The other so-called echo chambers, the ones that don't have a shadowbanning and censorship problem, the one one the side that won the majority vote in the recent election, don't see it this way at all.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by Taters91 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:54PM (#42138981)
Just read through the motions and pleadings and you get the picture of what is going on https://infowarslawsuit.com/heslin-versus-jones/

They brought a case. They asked for discovery. The Jones team explicitly did not respond to discovery. The court sanctioned for a while, giving Jones more time. Eventually the case was brought to default. Because this is a civil case, that is very reasonable given the extraordinary lengths Jones's team went to avoid actually complying with court orders. Then the damages hearing was held, where evidence was presented to show that defamation happened. The jury agreed. The only real issue with this is that people don't like to read, and they would rather listen to Alex Jones's version of the story. This was a defamation case, which everyone has a right to, and Jones repeatedly spat in the face of the process (including destroying evidence). It is hard to see how this case was handled poorly, and bad vibes alone aren't enough to say it was mishandled. This was a long process that Jones could have handled, but he gambled with his legal strategy and lost.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by Taters91 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:12PM (#42139232)
He did present his view in the damages portion. And the court ruled that he did not comply with discovery. Then later in the damages portion of the trial, it was proven he lied. Like, on live camera.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:07PM (#42139168)
> they would rather listen to Alex Jones's version of the story

The major point of contention is that Alex Jones' version of the story was never presented in court. The court records, from the primary sources, and not a smear website run by Alex Jones' opponents, are congruent with Alex Jones' statements about the court prohibiting Alex from defending himself.

> The Jones team explicitly did not respond to discovery.

The Jones team has stated otherwise.

At the very best, nothing meaningful has been proven against Jones and Jones lost the case on procedure, "technicality", and looks railroaded.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by recipe_man_ on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:34AM (#42137892)
I think you would be of interest to cognitive researchers. Here we have living proof that intelligence is not a necessary prerequisite for the use of language!
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:51AM (#42138103)
> hurr durr i think ur a doodihead

Not an argument.

If you had the intellectual acumen for argument you would present one, but you don't, so we know where you and I stand relatively intellectually.

inb4: "I don't have an argument because I already think I'm right"

  https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fi.kym-cdn.com%2Fphotos%2Fimages%2Foriginal%2F001%2F175%2F924%2F751.jpg
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by dang on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:42PM (#42139598)
We've banned this account for breaking the site guidelines. Please don't create accounts to to do that with.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by dang on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:41PM (#42139594)
We've banned this account for breaking the site guidelines. Please don't create accounts to to do that with.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by shadowgovt on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:33AM (#42137882)
The court records show that he claimed he could not find documents that were then turned over, inadvertently, to the plaintiffs' attorney in an unrelated filing. This seriously raises the question of whether he is actually that inept at finding documents when compelled by law or intentionally tried to hide them.

It turns out juries don't like feeling they were deceived. And he did himself no favors calling the whole situation a "Perry Mason moment."

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/alex-jones-may-have-lied-co...

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:04AM (#42136815)
> Then, a jury of his peers was brought in

But no one is actually stupid enough to believe they are his peers, not even you.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by Taters91 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:16AM (#42137679)
Do you think that I think his friends and colleagues were on the jury?
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:12PM (#42138396)
I appreciate you don't attempt to argue that the jury was comprised of persons who could be reasonably construed as Alex' peers.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by Taters91 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:32PM (#42138682)
Again, what do you mean by "peers"? In the justice system, it just means a cross-section of the community that is as impartial as possible, as filtered out by the voir dire process. I don't think in any way these are his friends or family or colleagues or buddy-buddy with him. They were just what is typically called a jury of one's peers, as in fellow citizen. I do believe they were his fellow citizens that ruled on the judgement, yes.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by jwkpiano1 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @09:57AM (#42136724)
This is a ridiculous comment. They basically refused to participate in the trial, so much so that they got a default judgment against them. Any reasonable observer sees what happened here. You’re not fooling anyone.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:01AM (#42136755)
> They basically refused to participate in the trial

By doing what, exactly? Are you telling us Alex and his legal team did not show up to the court? Alex Jones did show up to court, did he not?

The court demanded documents that did not exist, did they not?

Your response is in itself looking extremely ridiculous.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by greenie_beans on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:56AM (#42137474)
bro you need to stop reading info wars
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:03PM (#42138256)
I appreciate you attempting to answer the questions I presented above. What a grand demonstration of critical thinking skills. Thank you so much.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by atlanticaccent on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:04AM (#42136804)
I'm a bit confused. Whilst you don't explicitly say it, are you not suggesting it would be better for the public's opinion of the justice system to not sanction Alex Jones to the full extent of the law, if at all?

Your first sentence is that the courts have to be impartial and functional. Ignoring the influence Jones has on the public and fully executing the law as it is laid out by taking InfoWars from Jones sounds like the courts are acting perfectly impartially and functionally.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:07AM (#42136858)
> Ignoring the influence Jones has on the public and fully executing the law

What "law" exactly do you think needs to be "executed"? Defamation laws? Were these defamation laws ever argued in court? Did you actually follow the trial?

The court claimed that Alex Jones didn't provide documents, documents that never existed, and defaulted him. The defamation laws were never argued in the court case. This action by the court is deprivation of rights, due process rights, under color of law. The judge is a criminal.

If the courts don't function properly, this creates an extremely dangerous climate.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by ImHereToVote on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:47PM (#42138887)
We are laughing at the gay frogs man here. Get out if here with you mature analysis of the death of the judicial branch of the United States.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by researcher52 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @03:15PM (#42140693)
Pesticide atrazine can turn male frogs into females

  https://news.berkeley.edu/2010/03/01/frogs/

What is a "low information voter"?

Wonder why Alex named his operation "InfoWars".. huh

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by TomK32 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:03AM (#42136787)
Have you missed the bit where Jones's lawyer sent a full copy of his phone to the plaintiff's legal team. Alex Jones says, no lies, a lot of things but the evidence that he lies is there https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/03/alex-jones-s...
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:08PM (#42138329)
I did not miss this. I followed this closely as it happened. And this "gotcha" right here, that he does not have perfect memory of all of his text messages sent over the two years previous, was the most significant allegation that has been brought to light against him.

And, those text messages revealed nothing of substance, they had nothing to charge with him with. They didn't even attempt to charge him. They didn't even go after the supposed perjury charge because it was weak. If it wasn't weak, they would certainly go after him for it.

Nobody has a perfect memory of all text messages they have sent over the last couple of years. If you think you have a perfect memory of all text messages you have sent over the last couple of years, you don't understand your own memory. Let alone a guy who runs a business with 20+ employees reading a deluge of news articles and whitepapers from when he gets up to when he goes to sleep.

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by amaizhe on Thursday November 14, 2024 @06:11PM (#42142248)
You're being intellectually dishonest, the argument was never that he did not have "perfect memory of all his text messages," it was that in discovery he claimed he searched for and found _no_ text messages pertaining to Sandy Hook, when in fact the evidence accidentally revealed by his own counsel showed that relevant messages did exist, and were retained. A perfunctory search for the term "Sandy Hook" should have turned up those text messages, meaning he either lied about performing the search, or (more likely) lied about the search not turning up anything. Either way, abuse of discovery.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by micromacrofoot on Thursday November 14, 2024 @09:56AM (#42136712)
> Whether this is actually true or not (and I haven't looked into)

sounds about right

Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by nixdev on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:09AM (#42136882)
Because it's irrespective to the larger point that was written there. Reading comprehension skills are very important. Your posted response is rather unfortunate.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by MisterBastahrd on Thursday November 14, 2024 @12:20PM (#42138520)
Your ignorance of how the legal system actually works does not make you immune from the consequences of defying the legal system. You've gotten accurate explanations multiple times and yet you continue to throw a pedantic tantrum in the comments. Calm down, conspiracy guy.
Re:The Onion Buys Alex Jones's Infowars Out of Bankruptcy by portpecos on Thursday November 14, 2024 @09:58AM (#42136730)
> We must not forget that for a functioning democracy, *impartial and functioning courts* are absolutely essential

Very important for people to remember universally.