News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The culture myth by potatolicious on Saturday July 07, 2012 @01:08AM (#4210781)
"Corporate culture engineering" has always struck me as a cargo cult. Large, immobile, boring companies try to reinvent themselves as small, nimble, exciting... by copying the symptoms of a great corporate culture, not the causes.

Free food is not corporate culture. Scooters is not corporate culture. Beanbags is not corporate culture. They are the natural expressions of an already-working culture, and will not lead themselves to one just because you've decided to build airplanes out of straw and bamboo.

Shortly before I left Amazon I was given a plastic (code) ninja action figure, which was, supposedly, some kind of new corporate mascot. We were all encouraged to take pictures with this ninja in interesting places, as some kind of "fun" thing. But of course, you can't order fun into existence, and the whole thing smelled very obviously of stuffy suits failing to get it. A fun, exciting company invents traditions like this, not vice versa.

Re:The culture myth by riffraff on Saturday July 07, 2012 @02:50AM (#4210951)
I have a bit of confusion about your situation so pardon me asking:

If you work in a team of four and your manager hands you a toy ninja and says "let's take pictures with it!", that is cool IFF there is no higher management?

Or, is it cool only if a peer thinks of it?

Or, the issue is that the idea came from more people at a distance more than X?

Or the issue is that they told you that you must take pics with it, rather than saying "you know what would be cool" ?

Or is it just a general "this doesn't feel right".

Because it would seem to me that your company _invented_ a tradition like that, it's just that you didn't like that it wasn't invented from the guy sitting next to you.

I understand and have experienced the feeling of looking at BigCo and thinking "boy, they are trying too hard to seem fun", but I am wondering how much of the judgement is the _existing_ notion that they are a boring corporate.

Re:The culture myth by Domenic_S on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:46AM (#4211054)
Meh, I think it's a function of company size.

FROM: Corporate Fun Squad <[email protected]>

TO: All US-WEST Employees <[email protected]>

SUBJECT: Put your picture on Sharepoint!

Re:The culture myth by potatolicious on Saturday July 07, 2012 @05:32AM (#4211218)
It is very much contextual.

At my current job, if my manager hands me the toy ninja, I would happily try to take pictures with it. Because my manager is very much knee-deep in the trenches with the rest of the devs, designers, and QA folk day in day out. He has, without fail, and repeatedly, shown that he understands the situation "on the ground" and has always treated our concerns with the respect and gravity demanded.

At Amazon there was not a chance - my manager was the guy barking orders from up high, funneling the whims of even higher management down with little to no filtering or defense for our ability to get it done. He was a straight pass-through, and it sucked. Him handing me the ninja would have been a damned insult (and it was).

The question is not job titles, it's entirely about the working relationship, and this is also why "inventing culture" fails. When you have an incredibly segmented workforce, where management is entirely separated from the grunts, and neither side have any respect for the other, any such "culture" is naturally a decree enforced from the top, rather than a genuine expression of what employees already feel.

Re:The culture myth by WalterSear on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:34AM (#4211032)
People do stupid stuff like taking pictures of plastic toys >because< they are having fun, which is a decent sign that the culture is good. Doing goofy shit isn't inherently fun just because its goofy. It certainly won't improve your corporate culture - it's the result not the cause.
Re:The culture myth by generalk on Saturday July 07, 2012 @12:00PM (#4211933)

  > Because it would seem to me that your company _invented_ a tradition like that, it's just that you didn't like that it wasn't invented from the guy sitting 
  > next to you.
No, the company didn't "invent" a tradition. Here's two scenarios:

1) Your boss goes around and hands everyone a plastic action figure and says "okay let's all take pictures of him doing funny things!" Nobody's going to do it. It's going to feel forced, and it's going to have the opposite effect.

2) You come in one morning and find your boss taking a picture of an action figure bent over and peering into the guts of a server. Then you see a few coworkers doing it the next day. Pretty soon you're trying to top them.

Management can demand that people have fun, but the only way it works is if you observe it in action.

Re:The culture myth by krishnakv on Saturday July 07, 2012 @09:15AM (#4211551)
Its cool if the manager means it when he says - take this ninja and take pictures and do fun things and MEANS it

Its NOT cool if the manager gives you this stuffed toy because someone else told him it would be a good idea and its the new corporate direction

In short, the gesture is meaningless irrespective of who it comes from unless the person means it and its in keeping with his/ her character. i.e. not FAKED or FORCED

The line between cool and douche is driven largely by intentions (being in character v/s being manipulative)

Hope this helps

Re:The culture myth by dasil003 on Saturday July 07, 2012 @08:59AM (#4211521)
The other replies address the nuance of your relationship with the person you handed you the ninja, but I think there's something more fundamental.

If you're happy at work and then you're generally having a good time and more inclined to do goofy stuff like this. If work sucks and you're stressed out then there's nothing more irritating than someone trying to paper over real problems with a hollow gesture like this.

Re:The culture myth by dionidium on Saturday July 07, 2012 @04:09PM (#4212583)
Because it would seem to me that your company _invented_ a tradition like that, it's just that you didn't like that it wasn't invented from the guy sitting next to you.

Yes, but even if the reason for bucking the new "tradition" is spite or envy (and I don't think it is in this case) that's reason enough. The whole point is that culture emerges; it is not prescribed. It doesn't matter why it didn't emerge. If it didn't, it can't be forced.

Re:The culture myth by batista on Saturday July 07, 2012 @05:49AM (#4211240)
>Because it would seem to me that your company _invented_ a tradition like that, it's just that you didn't like that it wasn't invented from the guy sitting next to you.

You don't seem to get it.

The whole thing about culture is that it must not be _invented_, it must be _organic_ (grassroots).

That "it wasn't invented from the guy sitting next to you" is the WHOLE bloody point which makes it not a culture but some lame pointy haired idea in the vein of "this culture thing sounds nice, build us one by Wednesday".

Re:The culture myth by bermanoid on Saturday July 07, 2012 @07:06AM (#4211367)
But the point the poster was making is that what is "grassroots" depends on who the idea comes from. If it's someone that you interact with daily and actually get a significant chunk of time with, then it seems natural; if it's coming from someone too high up the chain to remember your name, it seems contrived.

Whereas the genesis of the idea may have been the result of the exact same thought processes either way.

Re:The culture myth by batista on Saturday July 07, 2012 @07:39AM (#4211400)
>But the point the poster was making is that what is "grassroots" depends on who the idea comes from. If it's someone that you interact with daily and actually get a significant chunk of time with, then it seems natural; if it's coming from someone too high up the chain to remember your name, it seems contrived.

Well, that's the very definition of grassroots, isn't it? If it's coming from "up the chain", it's not grassroots anymore.

>Whereas the genesis of the idea may have been the result of the exact same thought processes either way.

Not really. When it comes from the bottom, i.e the people actually doing it, it is not an "idea", it's something you do _spontaneously_, for fun, etc.

One is something that just happens --which can then be codified, repeated, passed on to new team members, built into a culture--, the other is something that is designed.

Re:The culture myth by einhverfr on Saturday July 07, 2012 @04:07AM (#4211090)
I was recently playing around with modelling business growth using logistic equations, and I came upon a possible reason why large companies are unable to be nimble and dynamic in the way small companies are.

Note: The basic logistic equation is 1/(1 + e^-t) which one can extend to be S = M / (1 + e ^ (-rt-y)) where M is the maximum growth capacity, r is growth rate, y is number of years to the 50% mark. Anyway, it produces nice S-shaped growth curves that generally approximate growth in a limited environment.

Anyway working with these a few things occurred to me. Near the bottom of the growth curve, growth is very slow. It then picks up suddenly, grows to a certain point, then growth rate declines and the market size tapers off. Lack of immediate success along these curves may be due to a growth rate that is too low or a market size that is too small (duh) but when we vary both maximum size (M) and growth rate (r) something really interesting happens.

If we have a curve that successfully predicts two or three years of growth but then overperforms what we observe, this has exactly two causes: Either M is much bigger than expected and r is much smaller (meaning smaller growth now but much more growth later), or M is much smaller and y is much bigger (meaning the market is already saturated). You can't differentiate these just looking at how a project is performing.

A small business can bet against the short term and for the future. A larger, publicly held business is often less able to do so, so getting over the slow growth in the lead-in of the logistic sigmoid is really tough in a larger corporate environment. This is probably a good part of the reason why big companies have a much harder time innovating.

Re:The culture myth by wpietri on Saturday July 07, 2012 @08:46AM (#4211492)
Sadly, there is a substantial market for helping companies pretend to acquire fashionable trait X without making any of the substantial changes that would require.

I was involved in "Agile" before the term had been coined, and there was a ton of meat there. But year by year the substance was leached away, until most of the consulting money was in, as you say, adopting symptoms. In talking with manufacturing people, the same thing happened with Lean Manufacturing. And I see it starting to happen with the Lean Startup thing. It kills me.

I originally thought this was driven by cynical assholes. Which I could have solved as soon as I figured out how to dispose of the bodies. But the problem is worse: it's all well-meaning people who just aren't paying enough attention to what's really going on.

Re:The culture myth by mh_ on Saturday July 07, 2012 @08:57AM (#4211515)
Agree 100%. In fact in 2010 I wrote a post titled:Cargo Cult startups on exactly this: http://blog.thinkst.com/2010/04/cargo-cult-startups.html
Re:The culture myth by RegEx on Saturday July 07, 2012 @02:10AM (#4210887)
Reading this saddens me. Amazon is where I'm hoping to end up in about 5 years...
Re:The culture myth by potatolicious on Saturday July 07, 2012 @05:17AM (#4211195)
Don't be too married to the idea. I know many, many, many Amazon alumnus, and not a single one wishes they were back there. There are a few beacons of light in the giant swamp that is Amazon, but IMO there are very few redeeming corners of the company. Overall, in general, the place is a dump (employer-quality speaking, the work they do is unquestionably amazing). Try asking your recruiter about the average tenure of an Amazon engineer and see them scramble madly to dodge the question (I know the number, but for the sake of politeness I won't put it out there).

They are, culturally, very much a big-giant-corp pretending like they are a small nimble startup. Everything from the "two pizza team" concept down to "frugal like a startup" (read: this is code to mean that your dev machine won't have been built in the last 5 years) is meant to evoke it, but really just elicits frustration and anger instead. Even in the "good" teams it will constantly feel like your boss is waging an epic battle against Evil just so you can have the peace to get your work done.

Fun note: circa 2011 my dev machine was a Celeron 1.5GHz. My codebase took a whopping 15 minutes to build even though a $1000 machine could have built it in a tenth the time. I knew incrediby talented, amazing engineers who were given 2 15" monitors dating circa 2002 and told to live with it. I'm not one for exorbitant gear, but this is entirely indicative of Amazon's internal culture.

I'm glad I cut my teeth at Amazon out of college, but I am extremely glad to have graduated out of both Amazon and Seattle, and have found much happier employment and residence elsewhere.

Re:The culture myth by justinmk on Saturday July 07, 2012 @11:08AM (#4211797)
> circa 2011 my dev machine was a Celeron 1.5GHz.

Of all the negative anecdotes I've read about Amazon, this is the most effective.

> glad to have graduated out of both Amazon and Seattle,

care to elaborate on Seattle?

Re:The culture myth by WiseWeasel on Saturday July 07, 2012 @12:41PM (#4212058)
Seattle has terrible weather. You can tell by the quality of the raincoats everyone is wearing.
Re:The culture myth by saraid216 on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:13PM (#4212426)
Seriously. This fucking sunshine is like being in an oven.
Re:The culture myth by potatolicious on Saturday July 07, 2012 @08:43PM (#4213176)
> "care to elaborate on Seattle?"

It was a city that was wholly incompatible with me, and many others. I'm not going to come out and strictly say that Seattle is a bad place to be - because I know some people who are very happily situated there.

There were a few things that greatly bothered myself and many of my peers at Amazon/Microsoft:

- weather. I grew up in the Northwest, so this wasn't a big deal for me, but I know a lot of people were particularly annoyed at the constant overcast drizzliness. Note that Seattle doesn't actually rain very much, it's mostly just constantly damp, cold, and cloudy instead. Some time in September the sun will disappear behind clouds, and be completely absent until the following April. People in Seattle are extremely active and outdoorsy during the summers, but that's sort of like handing a starving man a bucket full of cheeseburgers.

- really limited social scene. Seattle isn't a convergent city - i.e., the vast majority of its population are locals, born and raised. Their social groups do not at all intersect with that of transplant workers who arrived later. There's a thinly veiled contempt by the locals for perceived transplant invaders driving up their cost of living (a belief that is IMO mostly true). The transplant demographic is extremely limited, and is almost entirely software people. These two factors put together means that 99% of your friends will be software people, and every party you go to will be full of software people. I had some crazier hobbies (read: hipster) that mitigated this to some extent, but even that wasn't enough. The social isolation and the homogeneous transplant population really gets to me.

Compare with where I am now (SF), where despite the dominance of tech, I still end up meeting tons of people from different walks of life just in daily life.

- transportation. I'm a pretty staunch urbanist, and while many neighorhoods in Seattle boast of the urban, carless experience, it doesn't actually pan out. Downtown, Belltown, Capitol Hill all try to execute on this lifestyle, but it's pretty half-assed - a lot of resources you will need are not accessible by transit or walking, and you are depriving yourself of the region's best food and sights if you go carless. Cars are not optional for a high quality of life in Seattle, even if you live centrally. Oh, your friends are talking about this amazing K-BBQ place in Federal Way? Welp, get a car. There's awesome dumplings up in Shoreline? Get a car. Want to do something other than drink on a weekend? Welp, car or you're hosed. Overall, King County Metro is the second-worst transit system I've ever used. It is somewhere between "ass-tastic" and "complete clusterfuck".

Re:The culture myth by rogerbinns on Saturday July 07, 2012 @09:55PM (#4213308)
The Everywhereist (a wonderful blogger and Seattle resident) has some good postings. The social thing is named the "Seattle Freeze".

http://www.everywhereist.com/the-seattle-freeze-making-frien...

And a bonus http://www.everywhereist.com/15-things-you-should-know-about...

Re:The culture myth by justinmk on Sunday July 08, 2012 @12:48PM (#4214961)
Thanks for a very informative answer. I've been considering Seattle as a possible destination.
Re:The culture myth by TheCowboy on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:32AM (#4211028)
Corporations are temporal things, tools to achieve a purpose. Don't put your dreams in them or make it a goal to make one of them part of your identity in X timeyearthings.

Identify what you think is attractive and a positive value and pursue that in 5 years time.

Re:The culture myth by jmduke on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:22AM (#4211009)
As someone who's currently working at Amazon -- don't worry. I love it here.
Re:The culture myth by jaimebuelta on Saturday July 07, 2012 @05:59AM (#4211252)
Don't think of big companies as a one, gigantic and monolithic culture. The fact is that inside big companies there are lots of departments, and they can be quite different one for the other...

I had this experience with different big corporations, where department A is a really nice place to work and department B is awful... There are some shared things, of course, but it could be different enough to make a huge difference...

Re:The culture myth by enjo on Saturday July 07, 2012 @02:23AM (#4210907)
That's the thing about "culture". It's defined very much by the people involved most directly in it. Within a company like Amazon you will have teams that foster amazing environments. You'll also have teams that hand out toy ninjas.

The trick is to figure out how to land yourself in the former.

Re:The culture myth by jmduke on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:24AM (#4211015)
This is a great point. I think the big difference in 'culture' at BigCos is that when you're thinking about scales of thousands of employees, its impossible to try and really instill cultural values at a micro level, especially with things like bean bag chairs. It occurs at a much smaller level -- the team.
Re:The culture myth by phene on Saturday July 07, 2012 @02:22AM (#4210905)
Don't do it! Go find a small start-up doing something that interests you.