Of course, it doesn't need to. Google controls enough space in the web content itself. On Firefox there are options to disable that; at least it is a supported setting. For Google, you need third party extensions to take care of this.
Not saying that I like that Firefox displays ads / is ad supported, but Chrome not displaying ads in its UI is hardly a positive against Firefox.
This reply however focuses on comparing Firefox and Chrome. Yes, Firefox is better.^1 But the parent's comment is still valid.
There is so much in Firefox's design that is not for browser users but for the benefit of others. Mozilla cares deeply about web advertisers and an online advertising "ecosystem". This is reflected in the design.
1. On average, but not in every respect. For example, in Chrome I can set the default search engine to any valid URL. I use a localhost-bound netcat that serves a useful web form^2 that I created in lieu of a "search engine". In Firefox, this is not possible.
2. It sends text clips from Chromebook Chrome to the "developer mode" (frecon) console stdout.
I do agree with the parent commenter that some things in Firefox are not designed for the user, but for the adcertisers. Which is something I don't like about Firefox.
> In Firefox, this is not possible
You can implement OpenSearch (which is basically a small XML file describing your search engine to write), then you'll be able to add your local search enigne: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/OpenSearch. It's a bit less straightforward than just a URL but if you implemented an actual search engine, it's nothing, and you probably want to handle suggestions, for which you need OpenSearch anyway.
Though for your use case, the web shortcuts feature of firefox seems a bit more convenient. I guess you don't always want to direct your searches to your web console, just sometimes, so you currently have to temporarily switch search engines when you want to do this. With a web shortcut, you just prefix your text with a word (which can be one char long). This works by adding a bookrmark, and setting this word in the bookmark.
The web form is for sending copied and pasted text to the frecon console.
For various reasons, I do not use the Ctrl-Alt-T browser-based "console".
I do not use a graphical web browser much. I do searches from the console. I type the search query on the command line or into a file if I am doing bulk searches.
As such, when I set a localhost address as a custom default search engine I am doing so as a way of disabling searching from the address bar. It also functions as a shortcut to reach local HTML files served by a localhost-bound httpd/netcat. For example, if the default search URL is set to http://127.0.0.1/%s.html and the local HTML file is a web form called clip.html, then I type "clip" in the address bar to open the web form.
Mozilla really wants to send everything that a user types in the address bar to a remote address, e.g., that of its business partner Google, before the user ever hits Enter. This desire, perhaps an implicit or explicit requirement of their contractual relationship, is reflected in the Firefox default settings, i.e., the design of Firefox.
> Mozilla really wants to send everything that a user types in the address bar to a remote address, e.g., that of its business partner Google, before the user ever hits Enter. This desire, perhaps an implicit or explicit requirement of their contractual relationship, is reflected in the Firefox default settings, i.e., the design of Firefox.
All browsers do this, including Chrome. There is nothing Firefox specifically does here. I don't like this feature but it is expected to be there by default from virtually every user. It is also very easy to disable this feature.
But I don't need to be conviced that Firefox is ad supported and doesn't have optimal defaults because of this. I know, and I wish it were not like this, and kinda hope another browser with another business model will somehow appear if Firefox can't be this browser, but for now every browsers are ad supported. Even Safari (which also has fundings from other sources of income that I don't like neither). And Chrome, of all browsers, is absolutely not a model that can be used against Firefox on the topic.
Yet Mozilla apparently wants us to believe Firefox is different. If in fact it was a browser designed for users cf. advertisers, it would surely choose a different design. Alas, it chooses essentially the same design geared toward facilitating online advertising.
On the one hand HN commenters defending Mozilla argue Firefox is different, in fact better than Chrome. And yet on the other hand Firefox more or less matches Chrome, "feature" by "feature". HN commenters claiming to have worked for Mozilla in the past have stated this is intentional and makes sense. They are likely correct.
Anyway, I am not a graphical browser user. I use different, text-only software. I see no ads. This works and makes sense for me.
Comparing graphical browsers does not make much sense for me. To me, they all suck. They are more similar than different.
For others who rely on these graphical browsers, comparisons might make more sense.
Computer owners and internet subscribers striving to control their hardware, e.g., trying to prevent unwanted UDP and TCP transmissions. These so-called browser "features" seem to benefit advertisers and advertising corporations more than they benefit computer owners and internet subscribers.
Chrome actively prevents proper adblockers from working as it has removed the extension framework integral to their function, and most web ads are Google's to begin with.
You can’t complain about them advertising their own services while still producing a leading browser.
this is not some small charity, they were generating $500 MILLION a year from the search deals
they should have shoved the the billions of dollars into an endowment
from that they could have funded a medium sized team focusing on the browser in perpetuity
but no, they blew it on obvious boondoggles (like Firefox OS)
The glimmers of technical hope within Gecko like Servo and Rust were chopped.
> but no, they blew it on obvious boondoggles (like Firefox OS)
I agree they wasted money on a heap of useless things (as we see plenty of failed companies do - like Borland).
But I thought Firefox OS was one of the most promising ideas. I'd still like to see a vendor try and produce a phone that supported browser-tech for Apps - the idea is clearly valuable for Apps delivered using WebViews on iPhone and Android.
Personally I think the rot is throughout the org - and blaming one section is pointless - it weren't just management or tech. Watching previously successful corporations die has a similar feel to me.
Mozilla could have done the same thing if they had a little foresight and didn't just assume the piles of cash would keep flowing in forever.
And that is why I'm very annoyed by the fact that every year the donation begging is more in my face. Bigger, louder, harder to block.
Since they don't need the money that bad, why not keep it to a small banner and respect the users FFS.
Mozilla should have done everything in its power to gain it's independence(and still should).
I have been a Firefox user since day 1. I rememember, it was Phoenix, then Firebird, and for the last few years, Firefox.
I still use Firefox, which makes me so sad to see how incompetent(or potentially just greedy) the Mozilla leadership is.
Great product, poor stewards.
they can't seriously think this can they?
who was asking for telemetry, mr robot, pocket, VPN ads, "use our email" (relay) ads, "check your accounts!!" (monitor) ads and built-in AI slop generators
and soon, more built-in ads: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/advertising/
I don't think a single user wanted any of that
at least Chrome doesn't actually show you ads directly throughout the browser's interface