News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by wallflower on Monday January 05, 2009 @02:04PM (#420885)
How many people would hang on to their GitHub student accounts way after they ceased being matriculated (fancy SAT word for registered) at that school? Maybe a one or two semester-long free trial - get them using it for their projects.

Usually, at a university, when you have a .edu email address, the school knows when you're a student. If you graduate or leave, unless you went to a school that graduates you to alumni.school.edu - you lose that email address.

Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by sjs382 on Monday January 05, 2009 @05:07PM (#421212)
There are other ways to determine whether someone is a student or alumni. I'm not saying its a GREAT way (or even scam-proof), but Facebook Connect comes to mind... I'm sure there are others.
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by nostrademons on Monday January 05, 2009 @05:32PM (#421243)
Why not time-limit student accounts to a year or so? And require a .edu address to signup?

A year's a long time for a student. It's plenty for any coursework, and should be enough time to decide if a project will become a startup. And the hassle of moving things over gives people an incentive to switch to a real pro account instead of just mooching off the student account forever.

And you can get folks hooked on GitHub, so that's what they go for when they enter the working world.

Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by jackowayed on Monday January 05, 2009 @07:13PM (#421362)
moving stuff over is super-easy with git. you make a new repo and push to it.
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by nostrademons on Monday January 05, 2009 @07:43PM (#421397)
Yeah, but paying $7/month is super-easy for those with credit cards and income. The point's to get people paying for it - for those who would anyway, a simple nudge and slight incentive is probably all you need. And for those who wouldn't pay for it anyway, you keep them using GitHub.
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by merrick33 on Monday January 05, 2009 @03:13PM (#421016)
don't know about other schools, but I am an alumnus of UCLA and was able to recapture my @ucla.edu address.
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by ewoodh2o on Monday January 05, 2009 @04:03PM (#421109)
Georgia Tech also lets you keep your @gatech.edu address permanently, for free. Just having a .edu address does not prove you're associated with higher-ed.

When I signed up for GitHub, the free and a paid accounts were differentiated (to me at least) by the need to keep source code secure. If you remove that distinction by offering free student accounts, you'll end up with a lot of ex-students using them. The movie theaters out here in Arizona figured that out and now only offer student tickets on Thursday nights.

Any group of students trying to launch a website with any chance of turning into a profitable company will have figured out how to come up with $12/month.

Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by mdasen on Monday January 05, 2009 @02:42PM (#420948)
Require an email confirmation at the student email address, say, annually. Also exclude alumni addresses (not too hard to filter 'alum%' or 'post%' and I don't know of schools that use different prefixes for their alumni (speak up if you know; note alum% would get things like alums, alumni, alumnus, alumnae, etc.).

-Sorry for using % as wildcard, but star becomes italics.

Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by soult on Monday January 05, 2009 @11:03PM (#421575)
Only students in America get .edu mail addresses. Many countries use .ac.ccTLD for educational institutions instead.
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by PStamatiou on Monday January 05, 2009 @04:00PM (#421103)
i still have my @gatech.edu, granted i did just graduate
Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by amoeba on Monday January 05, 2009 @06:48PM (#421337)
Two universities I no longer attend, both of which I haven't been a student of for at least three years, let me log into my student accounts just the same as I did when I was a student.

I don't think this is a surefire way of proving studentship.

Re:Ask HN: Free accounts for students? by guruz on Monday January 05, 2009 @02:24PM (#420922)
Huh. It's not fancy, it is latin (or well, english-latin). Just like the "university" and "semester" and "alumni" you used.