News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers

Hi HN community! My friend has an interesting problem and I am hoping some engineering / hacking ingenuity can help. She has two glass containers stuck together, one inside the other, see here: https://ibb.co/5hwDR8P.

She has tried all kinds of things including: trying to separate them inside a water bath, greasing them, creating a temperature differential (ice on top, warm bath on the bottom), and even using WD-40. Nothing helped.

Any suggestions?

( 9 comments | 3 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by r2_pilot on Thursday November 07, 2024 @03:01PM (#42080324)
I didn't view the picture but I did run your prompt against Claude : Let me help think through some physics-based approaches to separate these stuck glass containers safely.

First, it's important to understand why glasses get stuck: typically it's due to: 1. Vacuum seal formation 2. Microscopic surface adhesion 3. Slight temperature/pressure differences when they were nested

Here are some additional methods to try, in order of increasing complexity/risk:

1. Dish soap and hot water method: - Fill sink with very hot (not boiling) water - Add lots of dish soap - Submerge both containers - Gently twist while pulling apart - The soap can break surface tension and act as lubricant

2. Vibration method: - Tap gently around the rim with a wooden spoon - The vibrations can break microscopic bonds - Combine with dish soap method above

3. Compressed air method: - If there's any gap, try forcing compressed air between them - Can use canned air duster or bike pump with narrow nozzle - Air pressure might help break the seal

4. Expansion/contraction method (more controlled than previous attempts): - Put ice water in inner container - Run hot water ONLY on outer container - Wait 1-2 minutes - Try gentle twisting motion - The differential thermal expansion might help

Important safety notes: - Avoid extreme temperature differences that could crack the glass - Don't use metal tools that could chip the glass - If trying percussion method, be very gentle - Wear gloves in case of breakage

Has she tried any of these specific variations? The key is often in the details of how methods are combined and applied.

Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by armcat on Thursday November 07, 2024 @04:40PM (#42081381)
Nice! That was the first thing I did as well, ask ChatGPT. The only one not attempted from the list above is the compressed air method. Thanks!
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by doormatt on Thursday November 07, 2024 @03:02PM (#42080328)
Compressed air - shoot it down between the two containers.
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by armcat on Thursday November 07, 2024 @04:39PM (#42081373)
Great suggestion, that's the one she hasn't tried, I'll let her know!
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by mikewarot on Thursday November 07, 2024 @07:19PM (#42082704)
Since you can get water between them, dump the water out of the top one, wrap the whole thing in a towel, and chuck it in the microwave, either they come apart, or not.
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by ActorNightly on Thursday November 07, 2024 @08:46PM (#42083290)
Those things are pretty strong, so using force shouldnt be an issue. You just 2 need reverse action pliers with rubber tips, stick one on either end under the lips and pry them apart.
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by solardev on Friday November 08, 2024 @04:18AM (#42085498)
Put them both in the freezer overnight?
Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by rehto21 on Friday November 08, 2024 @05:51AM (#42085865)
Surprised to see a reddit like question being asked here on hackernews.

Water, soap, oil, compressed air etc will not work. Ask your friend to gently tap around the edges of the container that is stuck with either a wooden spatula or the back of a wooden ladle. Gentle taps in the direction of getting unstuck all around the edge of the stuck container. May require few minutes of tapping.

Source: This has happened to me many times.

Re:Ask HN: Separating Two Glass Containers by nbernard on Friday November 08, 2024 @06:08AM (#42085935)
Seconded. In chem labs, it happens quite often that glass labware pieces get stuck together. The gentle application of a wooden mallet is the usual solution...