Re:Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband n...
by deepsquirrelnet on Thursday November 07, 2024 @11:23AM
(#42078047)
Security in LEO will eclipse the cost of everything else. Right now it’s free. When it becomes critical infrastructure, it has to be protected.
Re:Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband n...
by toast0 on Thursday November 07, 2024 @11:53AM
(#42078394)
Security in outside plant isn't free either. We're a long way away from widespread outages because someone thought they could get high with the proceeds of a stolen satellite, but there are lots of disruptions when people take down pole mounted fiber because they thought it would be worth something.
Re:Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband n...
by jtbayly on Thursday November 07, 2024 @12:51PM
(#42079024)
But wires aren’t the only terrestrial option.
I can’t fathom how many satellites it would take to support all the internet users as a monopoly.
Re:Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband n...
by toast0 on Thursday November 07, 2024 @01:10PM
(#42079203)
Fair enough; I didn't read your comment very closely, I guess. Terrestrial radio seems a lot less expensive in areas with population. When you get out beyond rural and more into wilderness, satellite is likely cost competitive, because having a LEO constellation cover the wilderness comes at no additional cost, and having radio coverage in the wilderness involves setting up base stations with low usage --- you can do some things with longer range / larger cells, but it depends on terrain and maybe protocol limits? GSM had a concept of 'timing advance' that effectively limited the maximum cell size, but I don't know if that's a limitation if you're not using TDMA.
IMHO, it's a question of capacity and acceptable service levels.
Starlink monthly pricing is higher than my DSL and nearby cable as well as my local muni fiber. But it's not so much higher as to rule it out. And the install fee is a lot lower than muni fiber. It's going to take a long time to get ROI on my installation cost for the muni fiber if I compare monthly cost to Starlink. Muni fiber service level should be much better, but Starlink service would probably have been good enough.