News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by gjsman-1000 on Monday November 04, 2024 @09:06AM (#42041628)
> I see most Christians as completely disinterested and even actively opposed to scholarship like this.

If they are Catholics, it's not that big of a deal (for better or worse), they do studies all the time.

If it's Protestants, there's 34,000+ groups of them. Among those groups, huge surprise, there is strong distrust for other people's opinions, just like there are with any group. There's also questions regarding the underlying motives - do the people who want to find Q, do it to glorify God or to encourage questioning scripture? (I am sure the church of HN hates the opinions of the church of Apple; even though the church of Apple has objectively won consensus ;) )

On that note, I'm not convinced by the Q Thesis, and there are good counterarguments (most notably, zero mention by Saint Jerome, who would have almost certainly known).

Re: by redwoolf on Monday November 04, 2024 @09:13AM (#42041683)
You're absolutely right. The thing is that in America, Catholicism isn't the cultural force that it is in other parts of the Americas or in Continental Europe. Protestantism is the brand of Christianity that fights the culture wars here. So for me "Christian" has become a shorthand for "Evangelical Christian." This is somewhat intellectually dishonest and definitely sloppy.
Re: by moomin on Monday November 04, 2024 @09:24AM (#42041768)
I can tell you that when I went to university the catholic chaplaincy maintained a library, and none of it was about how to prep a sermon for youth group.

There’s plenty to criticise about the Catholic Church, but it takes scholarship extremely seriously.