News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by jeffbee on Thursday October 31, 2024 @08:59PM (#42013079)
Any way you look at it, the government has to kick existing owners in the teeth to fix this crisis. Housing prices need to return to a reasonable multiple of wages, and that can only be done with supply. Everyone is going to have to get over the idea that they are "building wealth" and "getting ahead" by merely owning a box.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by ta_1138 on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:32PM (#42013244)
If you can avoid population loss, it's still going to work out, because a great approach to increasing housing supply is more density. Grab 3 adjacent houses, demolish, turn them into 24 condos that are only a little bit cheaper, and once you account for the costs of construction, it still works out for everyone.

So what happened to the owners of those three houses? Well, their land, which before could only had 3 dwellings, has 24. So while the value of the built houses they had dropped to zero, the value of the land they were built on went up spectacularly, so their investment paid off anyway.

Barring the craziest of regulatory situations, no house is ever a good investment. They degrade and get worse! But most homeowners end up ahead, because they own the land, and it appreciated faster than the house depreciated. And as a city gets bigger and more prosperous all land near it gets more valuable.

So all in all, in cities that aren't shinking, it's likely most homeowners end up way ahead, and the closer to downtown, the more they gain. It's only when a city shrinks that the homeowner really loses money.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by packetlost on Friday November 01, 2024 @10:36AM (#42017329)
"bUt thE nEiGhbOrHoOd'S cHarAcTeR"
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by carom on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:32PM (#42013240)
As someone who wants higher density, I see very little progress of this happening. Voters consistently vote against it. The one exception is California state has passed some good laws around ADUs and parking minimums. People will keep voting for rent control and affordable units to prevent construction.

The other side of the equation is that wages could increase relative to the price of housing.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by brailsafe on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:52PM (#42013342)
Rent control is absolutely important; although it does probably have a measurable effect on how quickly things get built, I don't think it's near the top of the list of bottlenecks.

> The other side of the equation is that wages could increase relative to the price of housing.

It's a system problem with various feedback loops, and people absolutely aren't getting paid enough and don't appreciate how little money they're making relative to what it can buy. In my city we're at a point where a new studio condo with no walls along a major thoroughfare outside the downtown area starts at ~$600k CAD, and older one bedrooms in the same range will still have asbestos and coin-op laundry in the basement. My landlords recently moved out and our living circumstances long-term are being considered. I had a conversation with one of them and she was seemingly clueless about how vulnerable it might have made us, and that's a bit humiliating; "but you guys have been here a while and surely you're making good money since moving in 5 years ago", to which I actually laughed and didn't elaborate, since we now depend on them putting in a good worth with our new overlords. We don't have the job security, we don't have the proportional increase in earning potential. Any decent money made gets erased in the next round of layoffs. Burn it all down.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by consteval on Friday November 01, 2024 @02:05PM (#42019777)
Kamala has some plans to federally incentive home supply. Some subsidies and goals. Here in Texas, Austin has had great success with pushing supply and now rents actually went down since last year. So based on that I think voters are changing their minds.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by carom on Friday November 01, 2024 @05:52PM (#42021916)
What is weird to me about her proposal is that they talk about 3m homes but that is the normal number of housing starts in 4 years. Do they mean they will double it or are they just giving tax incentives for the expected home construction so they can point to it and get credit?
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by bachmeier on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:14PM (#42013144)
> kick existing owners in the teeth to fix this crisis

You're assuming a definition of "crisis". 2/3 of households own their own homes, and a big chunk of those that don't aren't looking to buy in any circumstances. As much as we hear about the high cost of housing, it's only an issue for an extremely vocal minority. That's not to say I don't view it as a problem (clearly it is) but I'm skeptical it's going to win any political battles.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by mistursinistur on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:29PM (#42013217)
> 2/3 of households own their own homes

1. "Household" is not the right unit of analysis, since a household is defined as the set of people in an existing home. Some of these include adults who would like to move out, creating a new household not accounted for in your denominator.

2. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the average American moves approximately 11.7 times throughout their lifetime. In other words, current homeowners generate demand for housing just as non-homeowners do.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by maxerickson on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:38PM (#42013273)
I have a decent amount of equity in a house that didn't cost me a lot. Small town, housing supply is okay, market has been up in recent years.

If I lost my job and was unable to find something reasonable in my relatively non-existent local job market, I would be looking to move to somewhere with a larger employer base and barely be able to make a down payment on entry level housing.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by brailsafe on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:34PM (#42013255)
It's only a political battle to win as long as the disenfranchised accept arguing about it is the only framework for dealing with it. People who consistently oppose change are lucky everyone else is relatively chill—so far—about losing access to a certain kind agency over one's future in their community. One could imagine a tipping point whereby the disenfranchised start approaching the situation more directly.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by grugagag on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:04PM (#42013092)
But is it going to happen? In the next 10 to 20 years that I personally care about? And it’s not just supply, the housing market is rigged in various ways.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by zeroonetwothree on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:15PM (#42013148)
The majority of voters are homeowners so that’s probably why it isn’t going to happen so dramatically.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by leereeves on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:18PM (#42013163)
Regular homeowners aren't benefiting much from high house prices. If they sell they just have to buy another, so it's a wash. If they borrow against it, they have to repay at currently high interest rates.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by Supermancho on Thursday October 31, 2024 @10:03PM (#42013406)
> If they sell they just have to buy another, so it's a wash.

They have to buy another at a higher interest rate. It's not a wash, I think it's a loss for most. If I sold my house, then bought another at the same size, the gains would not cover the monthly mortgage increase for very long.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by brailsafe on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:23PM (#42013193)
I guess that'll naturally change when there's enough pissed younger millenials, zoomers, and whatever else who don't have boomer parents with money, in aggregate surpassing the soon to be diminishing demo who owns them all. Just the numbers of voters though, no legit policy improvements.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by OxO4 on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:14PM (#42013145)
Great. Housing should not be an investment and chasing ever-increasing property values as a society is obviously unsustainable. If you own a house as your primary residence, then its market value shouldn't really matter, because the value has no impact on your quality of life.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by bachmeier on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:21PM (#42013182)
If you buy a house and it appreciates 40%, you can borrow against that equity. You've got a heck of a cushion in the case of any negative event. Including losing your job.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by rangestransform on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:40PM (#42013288)
Letting a majority of voters benefit from their home equity was a colossal mistake that will harm society for ages to come
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by Sleaker on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:16PM (#42013156)
But it is valued based on its impact to your quality of life.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by the_gipsy on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:17PM (#42013161)
Increasing supply in population centers also raises demand. Think about why it's in demand in the first place: it's because there is high density (and more opportunities).
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:23PM (#42013190)
Barring unlimited immigration, we could build enough high-density housing in cities to meet demand. (At least, we could if we fixed zoning.)

(Or, we could in most cities. A few, like New York and San Francisco, are very limited in terms of available land.)

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by wussboy on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:26PM (#42013202)
Zoning and parking minimums are the real problem. Ensure houses are safe (fire, collapse, etc.) and let the market decide where, when and what should be built.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by infotainment on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:35PM (#42013257)
Exactly -- Tokyo has kept housing costs under control for this reason.

There are zoning codes in Tokyo, but they're quite flexible compared to what people in the US are used to. In addition, perhaps most importantly, it's not possible to oppose construction, as opposed to the the US, where literally anyone can halt a construction project indefinitely for literally any bogus reason. "It might cast shade on 1 square foot of the street!"

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by brailsafe on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:41PM (#42013292)
It was a sad day when I learned there exist actual shade inspections as part of the development approval process in some places. I legit thought it was just a way to mock NIMBYs who say that stuff. It was on that day I kind of just stopped hoping for a better future in terms of housing.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by mattmcknight on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:46PM (#42013316)
parking minimums are a red herring.

zoning, absolutely. however, in a lot of places we have homeowners' associations as well.

random density doesn't help much, need to build density near existing and planned infrastructure.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by wussboy on Friday November 01, 2024 @12:05PM (#42018345)
> parking minimums are a red herring

Care to explain more? I hard disagree, and I think the research is on my side.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by mattmcknight on Sunday November 03, 2024 @01:39PM (#42035079)
They are at best a very minor cost addition when it comes to large projects. I see more problems from insufficient parking which is why many of these exist in the first place. There is very little independent research into the topic, it's mostly from the anticar crowd.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by HeyImAlex on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:40PM (#42013287)
I feel like immigration is effectively unlimited from the perspective of big cities. There's friction moving states, and some things keep people anchored, but the market is nationwide. If you built enough in NYC to make rent comparable to other major cities, then significantly more people would want to move to NYC.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 01, 2024 @03:30PM (#42020647)
From the perspective of any one big city, yes. From the perspective of, say, the top 20 cities in the country put together? No - not unless immigration into the country is unlimited.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by the_gipsy on Friday November 01, 2024 @05:35AM (#42015310)
You can't build faster than demand is rising (because building increases demand again). Except if demand goes down due to an external crisis. Or if you magically could double housing with a snap, but once again later once that new housing gets occupied... more density means more job means more opportunities.

"Just build more" is not a solution on its own, at all.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by kylebenzle on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:16PM (#42013155)
Governments will choose the path of least pain everytime and that means EVERY SINGLE TIME they will choose to hyperinflate the money supply rather than pay their debts.

No one is going to purposfully crash the single largest market in the world. Hyperinflation is comming.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by damiankennedy on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:33PM (#42013253)
Do you think it will get as high as %50 per month or something like %25 a year and would this inflation have any effect on future US Federal liabilities?
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:30PM (#42013226)
Been hearing that since the 1970s, with more reason. 1979 looked a lot more like hyperinflation than 2023 did, with 14% inflation.

By the way, hyperinflation doesn't just mean "large inflation". It's defined as 50% increase in prices per month. Yes, governments often (not always) choose to inflate the money supply rather than pay their debts. No, nobody deliberately chooses hyperinflation.

Mind you, you could be right this time. It could be that the next government will overspend enough (no matter who wins) and Congress will be irresponsible enough that we do in fact wind up in a hyperinflation. But so far, naysayers have predicted ten of the last zero hyperinflations.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by Dalewyn on Thursday October 31, 2024 @09:38PM (#42013276)
I agree, "The USD/American economy will crash!" and "China will implode!" are perhaps the two textbook examples of yokels yapping baselessly about doomsdays I've consistently heard and turn out wrong over my entire lifetime.

Entire foreign countries (read: most of the world worth caring about) invest in and hold the US, whether that's stocks or bonds (Treasury bonds especially) or literal USD. The only way the US crashes at this point is if the entirety of humanity has shit the bed, it's otherwise a force of nature only going up up up.

Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 01, 2024 @08:30AM (#42016295)
Well, I'm not quite that optimistic. The only way the US crashes is if it stops being the best option out there. If the EU and the euro, or China and the yuan, or India and the rupee become better options than the US and the dollar, then people will stop holding so many dollars, and the US will be in trouble. That is a thing that can happen, even though it hasn't in 80 years.
Re:The Economy Is Going Great, Except for the Housing Market by kylebenzle on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @11:11AM (#42052631)
Exactly, I really like your style and thinking, AnimalMuppet.

My fear for 10+ years has been that another county or block will start a gold, commody or electronic based currency and the world will flood to the backed currency dumping USD as fast as possible. Bitcoin ALMOST became that black hole of USD before Adam Back's Blockstream was able to sucessfully hijack the BTC GitHub repo and inject hacks like SegWit and RBF that essentially killed BTC as a currency.

USD doesn't have to die, just something slightly better has to come along.