Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by ThePherocity on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:42AM
(#4203218)
I'm so glad you mentioned that, I wasn't going to watch it at first. A synopsis prepared by Hawking hours earlier read on command by his robot voice, all the while having the camera focused on him while he's shifting in his seat waiting for the statement to end, didn't interest me. But that smile at the end made my week.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by Eliezer on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:01PM
(#4201458)
Yep! Congratulations to the field of physics as a whole for having a substantially better grasp on... call it, "completing the pattern of reality"... than I thought it did. My credence in dark matter and dark energy is also substantially increased.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by sinak on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:16AM
(#4202078)
I remember having a conversation with Peter Thiel at the Singularity Summit in 2009 where he expressed a pretty strong opinion that humanity seriously pursuing advances in theoretical Physics was a momentous waste of brain power. At the time I was a relatively recent Physics graduate, I wasn't too pleased to hear that. I wonder if his opinion on this has changed at all.
Anyway, nice to have you here Eliezer ... like the commenter below, I'm a massive Methods of Rationality fan too :).
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by scrame on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:11AM
(#4202193)
Yeah, Peter Thiel also thinks college is a waste of time, because you could be working at making a bunch of money instead.
The fact of the matter is, without the continuous research and application of this type of "momentous waste of brain power", we wouldn't have the accessible and affordable technology to enable his wealth and position where people think they should give a shit what he thinks about science.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by Eliezer on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:31PM
(#4204265)
Peter Thiel doesn't think Einstein was wasting his time, and isn't expressing disapprobation of physics or science; he's expressing disapprobation of modern physics-academia, and the presumption that the thing to do with your genius is obviously string theory.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by raverbashing on Thursday July 05, 2012 @05:16AM
(#4202309)
Well, maybe what would be easier is to waste massive amounts of brain power in building computers that can solve the most complicated issues in theoretical physics
But of course, for theoretical physics to advance, experimental physics has to advance as well...
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by dasil003 on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:10AM
(#4202698)
With all that brainpower they could almost certainly crack the Facebook monetization problem, because all that data has got to be worth something. Theoretical Physics? Well that will never break him into the 11 figures no matter how many bosons they discover.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by StavrosK on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @08:33PM
(#4201280)
Semi-offtopic, but I'm currently reading his book, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, and it's just amazing. Quite a page-turner. I highly recommend it.
Also, I've never read any of the original Harry Potter books, so don't sweat it if you haven't either.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by JoshTriplett on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:55PM
(#4201446)
Also offtopic: for anyone interested in starting it, especially late in the evening, try http://www.comic-rocket.com/go?uri=http%3A//hpmor.com/chapte... ; that way, when it gets to be early in the morning, you can stop, mark your place, and come back later.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by SoftwareMaven on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:29PM
(#4201388)
I'm currently reading it to my 11 year old son (who loves it). I love how it gives me an opportunity to sneak in some lectures on rationality as I explain some of the jokes.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by jpalomaki on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:11AM
(#4202194)
Did he make the bet because:
a) He did not believe Higgs boson exists?
b) He believed Higgs boson exists, but could not be "found"?
c) Just for fun
d) Publicity stunt
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by dbaupp on Thursday July 05, 2012 @12:05AM
(#4201701)
There is quite a few broad topics suggested for the LHC[1], and even right now there are 3 other experiments running on it[2]. (ATLAS is the Higg's boson experiment, although it isn't just looking for the Higg's boson.)
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by peeters on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:50PM
(#4201672)
Figure out how the heck the Higgs boson actually behaves, for starters (they just found it). But my understanding is the LHC is not a single-purpose tool. You can observe a variety of particles at a variety of energies.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by DigitalSea on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @08:55PM
(#4201321)
Fair enough they've found proof that Higgs Boson exists but this is only the beginning. Nothing will come of this discovery for a very long time, it's a start but there are many more years of research before any benefit of this discovery is seen or felt. Great news though, I knew they'd find it eventually.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by dedward on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:42PM
(#4201650)
The same could be said of many subatomic particles that were found as we built larger and larger colliders.... it's a very big deal in advancing our understanding of.... everything.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by DigitalSea on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:37PM
(#4206106)
I don't mean to double post, but I noticed that Stephen Wolfram (no stranger to physics) has even come out saying that he is disappointed and believes the chances of another discovery in this lifetime are pretty low. http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/07/why-th...
We've proved the simple model, but as I said I don't think anything else will come of this and even if something does come of this I doubt you or I will be alive to see the results.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by DigitalSea on Thursday July 05, 2012 @06:54PM
(#4205426)
I'm not saying it's not a big deal, but what I am saying is this means nothing at this point in time. Discovering proof of the Higgs Boson opens up the possibility of understanding our universe and how things work, but at present the discovery means nothing to anyone but the investors involved and the employee's at CERN who keep their jobs for another few years.
There is a possibility that even though we've discovered the Higgs, nothing else will ever be discovered or come of it.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by zitterbewegung on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:41PM
(#4201157)
Think of it this way.
What does Stephen Hawking get if he is wrong?
-$100 dollars
+Media coverage saying that he was wrong which promotes physics.
What does Stephen Hawking get if he is right?
+$100 dollars
+Media coverage saying that Stephen Hawking is right which promotes physics.
This is not altruism this is intelligent promotion of a topic that you want children and young adults to be educated in.
It is a paid advertisement for physics by a celebrity. Similar to athletes who get paid endorsements. It encourages people to challenge him. Using his celebrity status can inspire people into doing Physics, Math or Engineering. We need more scientists and engineers. Professor Hawking knows Physics but even better he knows how the play the media.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by dekz on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:13PM
(#4201092)
I wouldn't say altruism, more like an anarchist's expectation. It seems some people would've liked there to be no observation just to 'shake things up' and then have to move to a new model. Hawking does mention in the video that the greatest discoveries come from unexpected results. The Higgs Boson has been expected for decades.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by imrehg on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @08:13PM
(#4201244)
I'm a physicist, and I can predicting something then the measurement matching the prediction is freakin' awesome! I have loads of "amazing how well physics works" moments in the lab all the time.
Of course, when it doesn't, it's time for more theory, then more labs, which is fun as well indeed. It's a win-win.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by rokhayakebe on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:06PM
(#4201469)
Nope, he is just reminding every person on earth, and especially scientists, that science is not dogmatic, that there is no set stone, that to every Ptolemic theory we may hold, a Copernican view is waiting to be expounded.
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by andyjenn on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:39AM
(#4201871)
Something I've wondered, presumably for several hundred years, Ptolemy's observations could be thought of as the standard model, and consistently day after day, year after year, the sun rose in the east and set in the west to 5 or 6 sigma etc.. that it could be said was proof he was correct.
Ptolemy is often spoken in the pejorative, but for so long until the man from Krakow came along, how could you prove otherwise?
Does this situation apply today and that a future "Copernicus" will turn the Higgs Boson on its head?
Genuinely interested how a consistent set of findings which correspond to predictions, can really be said to prove a discovery?
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by david927 on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:11AM
(#4202192)
But remember, his theory had huge holes, such as the movement of the planets. Newton's model, too, explained much more, but still not everything, and Einstein then helped fill that gap. It's not a case of Model A is 100% right but, look!, Model B is also 100% right and better. It's more like Model A is 97%, Model B 99.1%,...
Re:Stephen Hawking lost $100 bet over Higgs boson discovery
by bluestix on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:11AM
(#4201930)
"The Egyptians pride themselves on being the most ancient people in the world. In their authentic annals ... one may read that since they have been in existence, the course of the stars has changed direction four times, and that the sun has set twice in that part of the sky where it rises today."
Anyway, nice to have you here Eliezer ... like the commenter below, I'm a massive Methods of Rationality fan too :).
The fact of the matter is, without the continuous research and application of this type of "momentous waste of brain power", we wouldn't have the accessible and affordable technology to enable his wealth and position where people think they should give a shit what he thinks about science.
But of course, for theoretical physics to advance, experimental physics has to advance as well...
Also, I've never read any of the original Harry Potter books, so don't sweat it if you haven't either.
I can read/skim faster than videos play so I hate video news where I have to waste a couple of minutes when I could have read it in 30 seconds.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne–Hawking–Preskill_bet
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Hadron_Collider#Purpose [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Large_Hadron_Collider_e...
edit: s/behave/observe/
http://press.web.cern.ch/press/PressReleases/Releases2012/PR...
We've proved the simple model, but as I said I don't think anything else will come of this and even if something does come of this I doubt you or I will be alive to see the results.
There is a possibility that even though we've discovered the Higgs, nothing else will ever be discovered or come of it.
I have no idea how to feel after watching this video.
What does Stephen Hawking get if he is wrong?
-$100 dollars
+Media coverage saying that he was wrong which promotes physics.
What does Stephen Hawking get if he is right?
+$100 dollars
+Media coverage saying that Stephen Hawking is right which promotes physics.
This is not altruism this is intelligent promotion of a topic that you want children and young adults to be educated in.
It is a paid advertisement for physics by a celebrity. Similar to athletes who get paid endorsements. It encourages people to challenge him. Using his celebrity status can inspire people into doing Physics, Math or Engineering. We need more scientists and engineers. Professor Hawking knows Physics but even better he knows how the play the media.
Of course, when it doesn't, it's time for more theory, then more labs, which is fun as well indeed. It's a win-win.