Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by ShardPhoenix on Monday January 05, 2009 @01:20AM
(#420078)
I honestly don't think that that second Macbeth paragraph is necessarily better than the first one. There's something to be said for succinctness/directness.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
necessarily better
It all depends on the audience.
The first sentence is "better" for passing an exam the next day, but hardly enjoyable if one is to immerse themselves in a work of fiction.
Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by nostrademons on Monday January 05, 2009 @11:14AM
(#420620)
The second sentence has a lot that could be cleaned up about it - it is overly wordy, a bit pretentious, and may not describe the right details. But if I saw the first paragraph in a published novel I was reading, I'd be very disappointed. It doesn't immerse you in the story at all.