Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by ShardPhoenix on Monday January 05, 2009 @01:20AM
(#420078)
I honestly don't think that that second Macbeth paragraph is necessarily better than the first one. There's something to be said for succinctness/directness.
necessarily better
It all depends on the audience.
The first sentence is "better" for passing an exam the next day, but hardly enjoyable if one is to immerse themselves in a work of fiction.
Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by nostrademons on Monday January 05, 2009 @11:14AM
(#420620)
The second sentence has a lot that could be cleaned up about it - it is overly wordy, a bit pretentious, and may not describe the right details. But if I saw the first paragraph in a published novel I was reading, I'd be very disappointed. It doesn't immerse you in the story at all.
Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by silentbicycle on Monday January 05, 2009 @07:53AM
(#420344)
Abstract concepts have trouble performing actions, because, well, they don't exist.
Exactly. But how many people have died because somebody truly believed their abstract concept literally existed?
Fiction benefits greatly, though. Compare these paragraphs:
"Macbeth is malicious. He is staring straight at you. You are getting scared. You start walking away. Your footsteps are the only thing you can hear."
"Macbeth fixes you with a beady-eyed stare. Dark flickers of malice creep across his pupils, and the intensity of his gaze makes you take an involuntary step backwards. A shiver of fear runs down your back, skin crawling. You start tiptoeing backwards across the room, eager to put more distance between you and him, yet too scared to make a sudden move. Your tiny footfalls echo across the great hall, providing the only relief to the oppressive silence."
Yes, the second one uses more words, and yes, it describes more. That's the point. By eliminating "is", it forces you to think more carefully about what you want to say.
P.S. +1 for writing your comment in E-prime. ;-)