News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:22PM (#4200574)
I see that it supports credit cards, but it doesn't support bitcoin.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by whit537 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:23PM (#4200576)
Weigh in here if you'd like to see that:

https://github.com/whit537/www.gittip.com/issues/14

Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:08PM (#4200708)
Thanks. I commented that I will use only this service if it accepts bitcoin.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by whit537 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:11PM (#4200717)
Pull requests welcome. :-)
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kingkilr on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:24PM (#4200581)
Yes, that could be related to the fact that bitcoin isn't something anyone with any familiarity with economics should take seriously. (For the purposes of this comment "familiarity with economics" should be understood to mean: has so much as shopped in a grocery store).
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:33PM (#4200615)
Yes, that could be related to the fact that bitcoin isn't something anyone with any familiarity with economics should take seriously.

You justify <things you don't like> with <anybody with expertise will hate>. This is a total non-starter.

(For the purposes of this comment "familiarity with economics" should be understood to mean: has so much as shopped in a grocery store).

Very low standard it seems. I shopped in a grocery store.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by coderdude on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:40PM (#4200637)
Then you'll know that you can't spend Bitcoin at a grocery store because it's some crap that people made up and not actual currency.

Edit: My comment isn't US-centric, obviously, since I don't know where any of you hail from. Trolls.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:49PM (#4200661)
Then you'll know that you can't spend Bitcoin at a grocery store because it's some crap that people made up and not actual currency.

It's a currency because people actually use it as a currency. It doesn't mean universal acceptance. Did you ever tried spending yen or peso in an American supermarket?

If you ever been to porcfest this year, you will know that a lot of vendors actually accept bitcoin along with precious metal.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by sneak on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:40PM (#4200787)
You're right, the fact that "it's some crap that people made up" made these dozen Krugerrands that I traded my bitcoins for stupid and worthless.

Oh, wait, I can't spend those at the grocery store either. I guess those aren't actual currency either. Silly me!

Re:Is personal funding viable? by ricardobeat on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:55PM (#4201198)
No groceries yet, but you have to start somewhere: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Trade
Re:Is personal funding viable? by executive on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:53PM (#4200670)
except you can spend BTC in some grocery stores. problem Batman?
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:01PM (#4200694)
If you know the name of the store, I would like to know.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by whit537 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:26PM (#4200587)
Mind saying more or linking? I keep hearing strong opinions against bitcoin but haven't heard details.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by rjsamson on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:36PM (#4200624)
The biggest problem I have with bitcoin is that the fixed bitcoin supply and decreased rate at which coins can be mined rewards hoarding behaviors. If you know that the bitcoins you have in your account today will be worth more in the future, you have a powerful disincentive to spend.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:45PM (#4200652)
If you know that the bitcoins you have in your account today will be worth more in the future, you have a powerful disincentive to spend.

That's only if you're a scrooge and don't like spending anything. Since bitcoin started, I spent bitcoin on hosting and domain, t-shirt, musics, development bounties, writers, and other things that I forgot to mention.

I never spent a bitcent on mining hardware, though.

You have to remember that humanity is a not a paper wealth maximizing function. We don't exists to horde money, but to spend it doing things that we like.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by natrius on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:01PM (#4200950)
"We don't exists to horde money, but to spend it doing things that we like."

Deflation increases the incentive to hoard cash. People respond to incentives. Economies based on deflationary currencies end up suffering from problems caused by this. You may not agree, but pretty much every economist does.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by r2DEYdly on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:11PM (#4204156)
How do you respond to incentive to not buy a new smart phone, because it will probably be cheaper a year from now?
Re:Is personal funding viable? by natrius on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:33PM (#4204273)
Some people do respond to that incentive. Perhaps a clearer way for me to have made that point was to say, "Incentives affect the decisions that people make."
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:46PM (#4201047)
I don't dispute the incentive, I only dispute the preference and the outcome.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by michaelt on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:28AM (#4202225)
Let's say I own a business importing widgets. If there's inflation of 2%, the stock I hold just became 2% more valuable. If there's deflation of 2%, the stock I hold just became 2% less valuable.

In other words, in a deflationary economy there's less incentive to invest in productive activity and more incentive to stash cash under the mattress.

And it's not just held stock that works this way - it's also capital investments like that new more efficient widget-making machine.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by natrius on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:59PM (#4201687)
So you're saying that people won't respond to the incentive to hoard cash? An economy based on a currency with low, predictable inflation will have less hoarding than a deflationary currency. Hoarding in itself causes deflation, so deflationary currencies risk causing a deflationary spiral.

Do you have an example of a vibrant economy based on a deflationary currency? I have several historical counterexamples.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by mindcrime on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:34AM (#4203186)
So you're saying that people won't respond to the incentive to hoard cash?

I'm hungry... really f%!#ng hungry, right now. I have $10.00, which - today - buys me 2 hotdogs and a soda. But, if I wait a year, that same $10.00 will buy me a nice steak, some corn chowder, a side of sweet potato fries and a margarita. What do I do? Hmmm....

Re:Is personal funding viable? by natrius on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:30PM (#4204263)
That's not how economics works. Sure, some decisions won't be affected by the increased incentive to hoard. However, there are some decisions where the marginal incentive to hoard pushes people over the edge to decide to hoard. Instead of focusing on the sentence of my argument you chose, try disproving the one that followed: "An economy based on a currency with low, predictable inflation will have less hoarding than a deflationary currency."
Re:Is personal funding viable? by mindcrime on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:35PM (#4204285)
Sure, some decisions won't be affected by the increased incentive to hoard. However, there are some decisions where the marginal incentive to hoard pushes people over the edge to decide to hoard. Instead of focusing on the sentence of my argument you chose, try disproving the one that followed: "An economy based on a currency with low, predictable inflation will have less hoarding than a deflationary currency."

No doubt... just emphasizing the point that we aren't dealing with absolutes here. People do spend money, even with deflationary currency. I'm not saying deflationary currencies are a good thing, or that there aren't some ramifications. But I think some bitcoin critics overstate the importance of the deflationary aspect, that's all.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by michaelochurch on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:29PM (#4201008)
You're making a subjective and emotional argument ("a scrooge") when it's well-established across societies that deflationary currencies have this effect (of discouraging spending and investment). Bitcoin, with its very tight supply, is inherently deflationary-- so long as it continues to gain traction.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:54PM (#4201059)
A scrooge is someone who is reluctant to spend money. There's nothing emotional about it.

I also happens to disagree with the idea of deflation being necessarily bad for society or actually discouraging spending and investment. I contend it that it only shift the timeframe longer into the future, and saving enabling people to buy higher quality lasting goods.

With inflation, it encourages short term thinking and shorter term investment.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by witten on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @08:19PM (#4201257)
The Bitcoin money supply is currently inflating at a rate of 33.3% a year.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by nhaehnle on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:11PM (#4200715)
The most clear-cut argument against Bitcoin is that it is a ridiculous waste of energy. The nature of mining in the protocol implies that if Bitcoin takes off on any significant scale, there is a dichotomy going on: either there are so few miners that single large actors can dominate the total hashing power of the network, making it vulnerable; or, a significant fraction of the total world computing power goes towards mining - which means that the electricity used up by the Bitcoin network would be much larger on any reasonable measure than what you need to maintain other currencies. Wasting energy is not exactly a good plan for the future.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by geoffschmidt on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @08:53PM (#4201312)
While this is an excellent point and one I hadn't heard before, I'm not so sure you're properly modeling the cost of maintaining other currencies. Must we include the Fed? The enormous physical system that securely moves money all the way from the mint to every single cash register? The opportunity cost of the time of all of the smart people who work on international currency arbitrage, but would otherwise be doctors and scientists?

Since paper money is backed ultimately by the threat of violence against those who counterfeit it, wherever they may be in the world, we must include some fraction of our defense spending as well. In fact, the more valuable the currency, the more must be spent on defense to protect it. Isn't this closely isomorphic to your dichotomy?

Re:Is personal funding viable? by kiba on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:48PM (#4200802)
Miners will generally operate when their revenue is greater than their loss in term of electricity bill(if they're not being parasites).

Let calculate the revenue a miner would get if they win all the blocks:

50 bitcoin every 10 minutes mean 300 bitcoin, which mean 7200 bitcoin a day. The price of a bitcoin at the time I am writing this is 6.54 USD, so the total revenue is 47,088 USD per day.

That mean, assuming a miner can win all blocks at 50 bitcoin forever assuming the price and difficulty stay the same, he can afford to pay an electric bill of 47,088 per day assuming that the price hold stable. This equals to 17,187,120 USD in revenue every year.

The market cap of bitcoin is only 60,951,475 USD, which mean miner revenue equals 28% of the market cap. However, most economic activities are certainly not miners, but actually trading bots and speculators across exchanges. In the MtGox USD alone, about 8.7 million dollars worth of bitcoin were exchanged in 30 days. You can also add in the various economic activities other than trading currencies, such as virtual goods, hosting, ice creams, t-shirts, porn, illegal drugs, etc.

You can conclude that the miners are guaranteeing more than just revenues for themselves, as the various activities in the bitcoin economy which actually probably dwarf what the miners are making in term of revenues. As far as being actually efficient method of security for a currency? Probably not right now, assuming that security measures actually scale economically. It could be that the actual electricity cost grows slower as more and more efficient method of hashing are found.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by cabalamat on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:21PM (#4201110)
Mining bitcoins is useless work to exactly the same extent that mining gold is useless work.

> which means that the electricity used up by the Bitcoin network would be much larger on any reasonable measure than what you need to maintain other currencies

This is only true if the other currencies are fiat money. For a non-fiat currency, it is necessary that either (i) it is hard to make (or people will just make enormous amounts and its value will go away), or (ii) it has intrinsic value.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by sgornick on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:38PM (#4203993)
Quite a bit of the money that mining operators receive is now going mostly going towards investment in R&D (and soon, manufacture) of ultra-efficient ASIC based mining hardware.

This things solve the computational work at a couple orders of magnitude greater than GPUs (the currently prevalent mining hardware) does.

So instead of 70% of the cost of mining going to pay for the electricity, it will be 10%, and the cost of the technology consuming the remaining 90%. I.e., in terms of total kWhs consumed for Bitcoin mining, we probably are already past the peak.

One single bank building in Manhattan consumes way more power than Bitcoin ever has.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by 2367o1 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:51PM (#4201677)
Note how ridiculous the counter arguments.

I too have made this argument several times and I have gotten similar nonsense in response.

I recall reading a story about some guy who was visited by police as they thought he was running an indoor pot growing operation, only to find after searching the premises that he was a bitcoin miner. It takes quite a power surge to draw that kind of attention from police. Bitcoin is geeky, and maybe it's idealistic in some good ways, but it's not "green" and it's not practical.

What happens when there's a loss of electricity?

Do we fallback to paper currency then?

Re:Is personal funding viable? by sgornick on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:32PM (#4203966)
Bitcoin payments for person-to-person can be done on mobile. Merchants can run their own point-of-sale or use a hosted solution (or, us a mobile / tablet, just like an individual).

For merchants, just like if VISA/Mastercard/Debit card, etc., goes out due to power problems (and there there is no battery backup or local generation), a merchant can't accept payments until power is restored.

As far as power outages for those mining -- there is no disturbance to Bitcoin even for lots of power distruptions. If the entire world goes dark, your inability to spend bitcoins will be the least of your problems.

Re:Is personal funding viable? by kingkilr on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:27PM (#4200591)
Re:Is personal funding viable? by whit537 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:39PM (#4200634)
Thanks, linked on the ticket.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by olalonde on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:55PM (#4201195)
No need to take Bitcoin seriously. You can simply convert your BTC donations to USD as soon as you receive them.
Re:Is personal funding viable? by sgornick on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:56PM (#4204086)
Will PayPal allow GitTip to escrow the funds?

If not (and likely not, considering PayPal does not allow for their payment network to be used for "pre-sales"), then GitTip can only charge for the actual amounts tipped (and claimed by the donation target).

Right now, let's say I'm willing to tip $150 per year. I can then donating $0.25 to ten people. Since I carry no balance myself (from received tips), that means every Friday I get a charge for the amount I tip. So I would see a charge of $2.50 (10 X $0.25) plus $0.30 plus ($2.50 X 3.9%) = $2.90. So that is a 16% payment network fee.

Certainly this can be optimized, but Bitcoin doesn't have such high fees. The sender pays the fee, and even then it is a fraction of a penny. And the conversion from Bitcoin to USDs is generally under one percent.

Cash (USDs) can be received once each week by GitTip as an ACH direct deposit (using BitFloor) or through Dwolla (using Mt. Gox, Intersango or Camp BX) so easy cash-out methods are covered.

And there are no chargebacks.

So regardless of your politics or what you want to use as a store of value, Bitcoin solves problems very well. Especially for micropayments problems like this.