Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by nostrademons on Sunday January 04, 2009 @11:48PM
(#420017)
Nuh uh, you used "I am."
Try:
"I might or might not want to kill myself." (The indecisive emo teenager version.)
"Death and existence vex me." (The pompous philosopher version.)
"Life sucks / then you die / so fuck the world / and let's get high." (The goth poetry version.)
"OMGWTFBBQLOL." (The hyperactive netspeak version.)
"?" (The concise punctuation version.)
To exist, or not to exist? That question occupies my thoughts.
Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by whatusername on Monday January 05, 2009 @12:39AM
(#420052)
Existance, or oblivion? I ponder this.
Shakespeare's use of 'esse' in Hamlet is different from it's the use that is criticized by E-Prime I believe. It's worth noting that the Scholastics, influenced by Aristotle, enumerated and distinguished the different meanings of 'esse.' E-Prime seams to be more concerned with identity, Hamlet is concerned with existence.
I am chiefly concerned with the question of killing myself or not killing myself.
EDIT. Oops, 2nd try:
A concern has arisen in my consciousness regarding the question of killing myself or not killing myself.
...I'm trying to keep all the same implications that WS put into the phrase, to hell with scansion.