News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:02PM (#41988704)
> in practice I’m not noticing a productivity boost.

How can this be possible if you literally admit its tab completion is mindblowing?

Isn't really good tab completion good enough for at least a 5% producitvity boost? 10%? 20%?

Select line of code, prompt it to refactor, verify they are good, accept the changes

Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by thih9 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:20PM (#41988908)
> How can this be possible if you literally admit its tab completion is mindblowing?

What about it makes it impossible? I’m impressed by what AI assistants can do - and in practice it doesn’t help me personally.

> Select line of code, prompt it to refactor, verify they are good, accept the changes.

It’s the “verify” part that I find tricky. Do it too fast and you spend more time debugging than you originally gained. Do it too slow and you don’t gain much time.

There is a whole category of bugs that I’m unlikely to write myself but I’m likely to overlook when reading code. Mixing up variable types, mixing up variables with similar names, misusing functions I’m unfamiliar with and more.

Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by throttlebody on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @05:57PM (#41989845)
How does AI learn from it's mistakes ? Genuine question as i have only briefly used ChatGpt and found it interesting but not usefull.
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by beepbooptheory on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:47PM (#41989213)
I think the essential point around impressive vs helpful sums up so much of the discourse around this stuff. Its all just where you fall on the line between "impressive is necessarily good" and "no it isn't".
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by m3kw9 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:09PM (#41988778)
In experience, I always have to spend time to check and most times it doesn’t do what I need unless it’s very simple asks.
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:48PM (#41989223)
> How can this be possible if you literally admit its tab completion is mindblowing?

If I had a knife of perfect sharpness which never dulled, that would be mind-blowing. It also would very likely not make me a better cook.

Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by goosejuice on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @09:55AM (#41994771)
Having a sharp knife will make you far more efficient if you know how to use it in the first place and sharpening knives takes time away from doing the cooking.

This is kind of a wonky analogy though.

Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by kortilla on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @05:03PM (#41989379)
If someone can eat 20 golf balls that’s impressive but it doesn’t improve my golf game
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by hackable_sand on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @12:18AM (#41991939)
That is actually very impressive.
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by bradford on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @05:04PM (#41989395)
> How can this be possible if you literally admit its tab completion is mindblowing?

I might suggest that coding doesn't take as much of our time as we might think it does.

Hypothetically:

Suppose coding takes 20% of your total clock time. If you improve your coding efficiency by 10%, you've only improved your total job efficiency by 2%. This is great, but probably not the mind-blowing gain that's hyped by the AI boom.

(I used 20% as a sample here, but it's not far away from my anecdotal experience, where so much of my time is spent in spec gathering, communication, meeting security/compliance standards, etc).

Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @07:14PM (#41990412)
> that's hyped by the AI boom

I always personally thought the AI boom was more about 'what can be done automation/improvement wise for non-tech industries'