A lean current-epoch human -- with our food abundance, access to modern medicines, higher standards of life, lower risks of injury, etc -- is likely going to be markedly healthier than a non-lean current-epoch human or a lean human from a prior age where medicine/food/etc was worse.
Or is it, in fact, the direct result of the drug?
Even if folks gain tolerance that doesn’t seem overly concerning. Mental health drugs also have tolerance issues and changing medicines every few years, while it has challenges for the patient, is an accepted part of long term psychiatric treatment.
At a personal level? Sure. Social level? Absolutely not. Eating less and moving more has failed in our current environment for the majority of people. There is no major social change on the diet and lifestyle front, so this is likely the best best thing. I say this generally agreeing eating right and being far more active is the much better choice for nearly everyone.
At least my personal and many friends experience refutes your suggestion you need to continue to increase dosing. That came from the phase 2 and 3 drug trials which limits dosing guidelines for obvious reasons. No one I know tritiated up to the maximum dose, and once they (and I) reached target weight, all successfully titrated downwards to either a maintenance dose or off the drug entirely. Too early to tell the long term on that, but early results seem quite promising.
I’d be off Tirzepatide entirely if it were not for IBS - the GIP component seems to slow down my bowels enough to completely eliminate symptoms for me, while having little to no impact on appetite.
Except that there apparently is mounting evidence that GLP-1 agonists also address some issues that are not generally addressed by just restricting calories. TFA touches on this briefly: "The weight loss involved with GLP-1 agonist treatment is surely a big player in many of these beneficial effects, but there seem to be some pleiotropic ones beyond what one could explain by weight loss alone."
I seem to recall seeing claims that they reduce COVID-19 mortality even controlling for BMI (possibly because they inhibit systemic inflammation), reduce alcohol consumption, and even (though I think just anecdotally) may help overcome gambling addiction.
See, for example:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8425441/ [COVID-19]
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/search/research-news/19361/ [Addiction]
Don't get me wrong - those are miraculous drugs. First real non-stimulant low side effect appetite suppresion that will help millions. But let's wait for honest research on lean people before spreading marketing on how it improves overall health.
Also, how nobody mentions the need for increasing the dosage and tolerance build-up (just check reddits how much people end up having to take after months of continuous use). You cannot be on it "for life".