Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by mkl on Saturday November 02, 2024 @06:59AM
(#42025564)
The project looks interesting. Screenshots would help, as well as a link to the demo at https://signal.vercel.app/edit. The demo asked for MIDI permission, but didn't accept input from my MIDI keyboard until I realised you have to enable it in settings. There's enough lag in the system that most of my notes end up a bit delayed, and the snap-to-grid doesn't seem to be working.
Please consider changing the name. A generic common word is hard to search for, and there is already well-known software named Signal.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by mkl on Saturday November 02, 2024 @07:58AM
(#42025841)
Of course people are free to use any name, no matter how much it sabotages their project. That doesn't mean it's sensible. Names absolutely matter. At work I use a thing called STACK, because it's the best option available to do what we need to do, but the name is a real problem as it makes it really hard to find anything about it.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by yboris on Saturday November 02, 2024 @09:55AM
(#42026408)
Hence the "please consider" in front ;)
I got lucky with naming my app: "Video Hub App" and despite being generic-enough, organically around 50 people find my software every day. With a name like "Signal" I suspect almost no one will ever find this software unless they already knew of its existence and searched specifically with "Midi Editor" prepended to "Signal" :/
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by latexr on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:19PM
(#42027309)
People are also free to smash their own hands with a hammer. Someone saying to them “please consider not smashing your own hand with a hammer because you will be in pain and may lose use of it” doesn’t stop them from doing so, it politely and helpfully gives a suggestion as to why they should think if that’s what they really want.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by maroonblazer on Saturday November 02, 2024 @08:49AM
(#42026089)
Congrats on the project. I like the layout/design. At first glance it looks intuitive and very approachable. Nice work.
I spent much too long looking for a "Record" button. Is the idea that you're supposed to 'draw' your ideas? I have a MIDI keyboard connected to my MBP, but Signal didn't seem to recognize it.
I'm a hobbyist musician and nearly always sketch out ideas by playing them into the DAW. Only after I've roughed out the idea do I get surgical with editing tools like those on display here. Of course to each his own.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by block_dagger on Saturday November 02, 2024 @10:59AM
(#42026764)
Cool project! Please add a five minute demo video at the top of the Readme. Also I would change the name to something more unique. Naming is difficult but important in products and CS.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by zelphirkalt on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:29PM
(#42028195)
5 minute video in a readme ... Are you aware of how much data will need to load to display that? Maybe a link to such a video would be fine. But not 5 minutes embedded into the readme. You might get 30s for that as a reasonable video length.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by pxoe on Sunday November 03, 2024 @12:06AM
(#42031081)
video compression can be pretty good, and for an editor which is gonna be mostly a static image with just elements switched on and off, surely it can't be "that much". it can't be worse than some github pages with dozens of huge pngs
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by LegitShady on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:26PM
(#42027359)
It seems like I have to select the note in the piano roll to adjust the velocity, instead of selecting and adjusting in the velocity area, which is annoying.
Re:Signal: Online MIDI Editor
by rriley on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:54PM
(#42028358)
Love it! This is great way to quickly explore musical ideas online. I couldn't find a way to enable looping while playing. Is this possible in the current version?
Maybe it should be added to the readme.
Please consider changing the name. A generic common word is hard to search for, and there is already well-known software named Signal.
People are free to use the name they want, whether it is the NSA or an individual, it doesn't matter
I got lucky with naming my app: "Video Hub App" and despite being generic-enough, organically around 50 people find my software every day. With a name like "Signal" I suspect almost no one will ever find this software unless they already knew of its existence and searched specifically with "Midi Editor" prepended to "Signal" :/
I spent much too long looking for a "Record" button. Is the idea that you're supposed to 'draw' your ideas? I have a MIDI keyboard connected to my MBP, but Signal didn't seem to recognize it.
I'm a hobbyist musician and nearly always sketch out ideas by playing them into the DAW. Only after I've roughed out the idea do I get surgical with editing tools like those on display here. Of course to each his own.
Or you could just follow the link to the website where there is a fully functioning demo of the app?
https://signal.vercel.app/