News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:24AM (#41984819)
It's $800 to go up to 2TB from the 256GB model which is just criminally over priced. I can get double that for half the price with a Gen 4 NVMe drive. Weirdly the 8TB drive on the Pro is at least in line with the top of the line 8TB NVMe SSDs you can buy though there are cheaper options at about $600 vs the $1200 Apple is charging.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by wongarsu on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:29AM (#41984889)
That's regular Apple pricing for you. Great deals on the baseline models, but insane margins on the upgrades that make them usable. And of course the ability to upgrade the devices yourself has been phased out in the name of performance and power efficiency
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by wtallis on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:57AM (#41985511)
I just checked some Dell prices: $730 to upgrade an XPS desktop from 512GB to 4TB (Apple charges $1200), or $508 to upgrade an Optiplex tower from 256GB to 2TB QLC, or $654 to upgrade it from 256GB to 2TB TLC (Apple charges $800). Scalping on upgrade pricing is something all the PC OEMs do.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by jsheard on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:58AM (#41985530)
Yeah, but the 5 minute job of installing a cheap retail SSD in that Dell machine yourself is still an option which Apple has removed from all but the Mac Pro, which offsets any SSD savings by being $3000 more expensive than an equivalently specced Mac Studio.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by wtallis on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:00PM (#41985572)
Right. The repairability argument is the reasonable discussion to have. The silly pricing games are more of a red herring.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:31PM (#41986094)
I think it's more relevant with Apple because they've removed all the competition for basically all upgrades to their devices by either soldering things to the board or bundling them into their SOC. When there's no alternative their prices become the only option.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by wtallis on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @01:52PM (#41987428)
I think repairable or not, the pricing to upgrade to the max config just isn't something a price-sensitive consumer should take seriously. Beyond one or two upgrades, you might as well pretend it says "call for quote" and just not consider 4+ TB as a realistic option to get from the OEM, because those prices are trying to cause sticker shock. And that goes for any PC OEM—the price-gouged upgrades are so far beyond reasonable that it really doesn't matter whose prices are the most silly or by exactly how many hundreds of dollars. What does matter is whether aftermarket upgrades and repairs are possible.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:12PM (#41987636)
It matters that there are no after market options for Apple because it means the inflated OEM upgrade price is the ONLY price available for every given upgrade. It matters less with Dell/Asus/Lenovo etc. because that's not the only price available.

The top of the line is also not where Apple is gouging the worst. It's in the middle tiers that are actually relevant to many more people. Most don't have a need for 4+ TB main drives but 1-2 TB is a size that's pretty easy to justify for a lot of people and Apple's price is the only option for them and they're absolutely lining their pockets with cash at the expense of anyone not going for the bargain bin basic tier that can't hold 2 modern games.

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by wtallis on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @03:51PM (#41988588)
By all means, complain about the cost to get a 1TB config, and put that price in proper context. But it still doesn't make much sense to focus on the $1200 upgrades, or any of the other upgrades whose price rounds up to "lol, no".
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @06:57PM (#41990286)
The gouging is bad at all levels as well as the design effects on repairability and the issues with obsolescence. If you'll look way back though I acknowledged the $1200 is at least vaguely in line with the top of the line Sabrent 8tb NVMe of the same size.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by jsheard on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:38PM (#41986209)
The Mac Studio technically still has socketed SSDs, which presumably cuts costs by not having to manage a separate motherboard SKU for every SSD capacity, but they went out of their way to design a proprietary SSD module format rather than just using the standard...
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @01:07PM (#41986720)
Kind of, they were socketed NAND cards and the controller lived on the mainboard, so as far as getting out of the problem of Apple entirely setting the prices for everything it's not relevant. As far as I'm finding no one managed to find a way to create a compatible card to create an avenue for DIY upgrades. I've found a few upgrades but they consist of buying an entire second Mac Studio to harvest the drive from.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:13PM (#41987643)
Giles from Polysoft is manufacturing 3rd party mac studio nand cards. There is still a problem sourcing nand because apple doesn't let the owm sell to anyone but them.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:21PM (#41987737)
I thought I had seen something about that but couldn't find the actual boards mentioned for sale. Sounds even worse though because it should be possible but Apple being Apple has ensured there's no source for Giles or other companies to perform repairs.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:29PM (#41987827)
There's an industry in China for desoldering and reusing apple bands. Unfortunately getting new oem nands is going to take legislation.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:36PM (#41987902)
Yes, though that relies on the product being fairly popular and for the chip to be stable for a while for it to be a useful source. Mac Studio NAND chips aren't going to be readily available from them unless they happen to be a shared part from a more popular device.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @03:09PM (#41988234)
All macs use the same compatible nand chips.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by wtallis on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:11PM (#41988798)
Is there any compatibility between generations, eg. harvesting NAND from a M1 generation machine to upgrade a M3 (or now M4) generation machine?
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @08:33PM (#41990892)
As far as I'm aware, yes they're all compatible.

Apples segmentation takes place in the nand firmware. The firmware contains the location in the storage configuration. And this may or may not be rewriteable. Iboffrc has done a video explaining how some of it works. It's all from reverse engineering though.

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by sangnoir on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @01:54PM (#41987442)
"Repairability" is a red-herring when the discussion is about user-upgrades and the ability to purchase components from 3rd-party suppliers (who compete against each other and the OEM)
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by dvfjsdhgfv on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @05:44PM (#41989719)
Apple is getting at throwing this red herring.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by pantulis on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:46AM (#41985300)
Edit: sorry, answered to the wrong post.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by angoragoats on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:10PM (#41985740)
At least on the storage side, Apple's parts are neither more performant nor all that much more power-efficient than a standard, replaceable SSD.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by Y_Y on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:45AM (#41985276)
in the name of [share price] performance and [market] power efficiency
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by matheusmoreira on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @01:41PM (#41987281)
Apple's silicon is good but I don't see what's so special about all the other stuff. Looks like they just solder components to the motherboard instead of using industry standard interfaces.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:14PM (#41987652)
*industry standard physical interfaces. The electrical interace is bog standard.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:10PM (#41987613)
Phased out in the name of profit efficiency. Despite what marketing will tell you the SSD is industry standard NVMe and the RAM is standard LPDDR5.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by angoragoats on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:09PM (#41985722)
> I can get double that for half the price with a Gen 4 NVMe drive

It's worse than that -- 4TB gen 4 drives can be had for well under $300, sometimes $225-250, and that's for buying a drive outright, not "trading up" from a 256GB device. I think it'd be more accurate to say that you can get double the capacity for a _quarter_ of the price.

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by rtkwe on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @02:18PM (#41987690)
I was ballparking it based on my recent buy of a Samsung 990 Pro 4TB and inflated the price a little in my head to closer to $400 than the $330 it actually was.

I also, as a side note, try to give the loosest most favorable (to my opposite) comparison because when I err on my side it becomes a "well actually" debate a lot of the time about how it's "not quite X times as many it's more like X-1 (so I'm not even going to touch that X-1 is still quite bad)" that is really tedious and annoying especially when the favorable version of the comparison is still quite bad for their point/side.

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by FireBeyond on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @05:40PM (#41989691)
Very much so. When I bought my "cheesegrater" Mac Pro, I wanted 8TB of SSD.

Except Apple wanted $3,000 for 7TB of SSD (considering the sticker price came with a baseline of 1TB).

I bought a 4xM.2 card and 4x2TB Samsung Pro SSDs, cost me $1,300, I got to keep the 1TB "system" SSD, and was faster, at 6.8GBps versus the system drive at 5.5.

Similar with memory. OWC literally sells the same memory as Apple (same manufacturer, same specifications. Apple also wanted $3,000 for 160GB of memory (going from 32 to 192). I paid $1,000.