News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by jodacola on Friday October 25, 2024 @04:31PM (#41949367)
Small Town Truth says it's a registered 501(c)(3). I just found it by searching here: https://apps.irs.gov/app/eos/

It leads to further rabbit holes I don't have the time to dig into now, but I might later, because now I'm very curious where it leads.

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by jodacola on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:29PM (#41950473)
Meetings ended and I couldn't wait to get back!

So, searching via that Exempt Organization Search led to a 501(c)(3) letter being issued to Small Town Truth, mailed to a residential address in the care of the "Better Narrative Group" - another "interesting" site[0].

Doing a little more searching, I've found another 501(c)(3) in care of Better Narrative Group: Soul of a Nation Media. Similar setup. In trying to find more information to connect some dots, I found Soul of a Nation Media's taxes were filed by ChurchBiz[1], but this hasn't led to anything interesting.

Both Small Town Truth and Soul of a Nation Media changed addresses to a PO Box in Virginia in 2022.

Oh, and here are another two I just found related to Better Narrative Group: American Volunteer Corps[2], Better Neighbors Network[3].

To not assume malice, maybe it's a concerned citizen trying, in their own way, by establishing these organizations. Something feels off about the sites, though - not much content, a little dead behind the eyes, and I can't put my finger on the actual purpose of the sites. Odd.

[0] https://www.betternarrativegroup.org

[1] https://www.churchbiz.com

[2] https://www.americanvolunteercorps.org/

[3] https://www.betterneighborsnetwork.org/

edit: formatting

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by dartos on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:44PM (#41950607)
Not at my desktop, so I can’t really dig into the technical details of these sites, but by the look of them, they were all made either with the same tool and general components OR they were all made by the same group (maybe the same contracting firm or something)
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by neom on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:58PM (#41951880)
The images are all hosted on wix, so I guess they're all built with wix (I checked through them all to see if I could track the images back to anything, it's all stock photos)

The weirdest thing I find about everything in there is this hobby lobby page: https://www.smalltowntruth.org/our-economy

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by dartos on Saturday October 26, 2024 @12:37AM (#41952590)
Yknow maybe these are just actual us political groups… they have to exist, right?
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by crazygringo on Saturday October 26, 2024 @10:36AM (#41954990)
"Real" legitimate domestic political groups usually have the names of the people running them, with bios, etc. Who founded them, etc.

They try to make it easy to figure out who they are so you trust them.

When that information is missing it's extremely suspicious, and rightly so.

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by uoaei on Saturday October 26, 2024 @10:48AM (#41955067)
I think that's a pretty obsolete take that hasn't been reliable since Obama '08 and the "digital strategy".

Not saying anything about "should", zealous downvoters...

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by singlepaynews on Saturday October 26, 2024 @11:31AM (#41955375)
Why? Do you know something I don’t? Intuitively to me it seems like “unverified identities are usually fake” is the core tenant of post-internet media literacy.
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by uoaei on Saturday October 26, 2024 @11:38AM (#41955414)
Have you interacted with any political organizations in the last 10 years offline? If/when you interact with them online, do they claim provenance through some actual recognized body or just some vagaries around how they want to depict their alignments?

If this was such a big deal, where is the hubbub about pretty much every email in my inbox?

NGPVan (for instance, on the Dem side) doesn't require much except the bare minimum of legal registration for political organizations, I don't buy that what is essentially a "marketplace for voters' email addresses" suddenly legitimizes anyone who signs up for their service.

My point is, if this is a problem, it has been one for a long time and the cultural zeitgeist seems to have simply ignored this except in cases that can be used to demonize enemies.

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by crazygringo on Saturday October 26, 2024 @02:37PM (#41956758)
I don't understand anything you're talking about.

Nobody likes e-mail spam from anonymous groups. NGPVan has an about page that lists who runs it with photos, they have an office and a phone number, they have a Wikipedia page. But they don't legitimize anyone else, as you seem to be suggesting.

Anonymous interference like this hasn't been a problem for a long time, contrary to your assertion -- it's very specific to this and the past two elections, because it's a tactic especially used by foreign influence like Russia. And this isn't about "demonizing enemies", it's about identifying illegal foreign influence, which is a very real thing.

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by uoaei on Saturday October 26, 2024 @10:23PM (#41959376)
NGPVan doesn't email you with influence campaigns -- their customers do. You are completely mistaken to believe their legal team hasn't insulated themselves from the activities of those who pay rent on their infrastructure.
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by neom on Sunday October 27, 2024 @01:33AM (#41960087)
The original point was it's typically not difficult to know who is behind legitimate things when political influence is involved. Nathaniel Pearlman in the instance of NGPVan, unknown entities in the instance of this conversation, or am I mistaken?
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by singlepaynews on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:27AM (#41980878)
> Have you interacted with any political organizations in the last 10 years offline?

No, I haven’t. Honestly surprised at myself but post-2014 the answer is straight-up no.

When I interact with them online (or, especially lately, by getting text spam), I assume astroturf until proven otherwise. I’m having trouble coming up with an example of a campaign that has succeeded at proving otherwise.

I don’t know what NGPVan is, would you explain?

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by dartos on Saturday October 26, 2024 @07:28PM (#41958500)
Update to this, I’m convinced it’s not.

Idk if it’s Russian or whatever, but I’ve been convinced by other comments that it’s probably not a community run internet group.

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:51PM (#41950662)
> Both Small Town Truth and Soul of a Nation Media changed addresses to a PO Box in Virginia in 2022

What else is at that P.O. box?

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by jodacola on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:37PM (#41952326)
Good question. Uncovering some more things here, with a wider web.

Another tax-exempt org was established in 2021 (like the others), named NORTH CAROLINA VOLUNTEER CORPS. This one, though, was established in Asheville, NC. Like the others, it was moved to the same P.O. Box in 2022. It was registered under the care of a different name. Its taxes were also filed by ChurchBiz.

Another entity registered at this address is AMA AL PROMIJO. This has a web presence like the other original sites[0]. It was also registered in 2021 and changed address in 2022 to the P.O. Box, but was registered in care of another different name. The fact that the website has the same feel as those others that branched off Small Town Truth is odd, though.

There is also a BORN BROWN INSTITUTE, which has some different presences on LinkedIn and such[1].

Now that this address appears associated with some different non-profits, I wonder if there’s some entity that acts as an agent for helping establishing non-profits operating out of this P.O. Box, hence the mix of entities I’m now bumping into.

Still. It’s an interesting web here I can’t quite make sense of. I’m also being a little circumspect here in order to not accidentally dox someone, but the research is fairly straightforward with the Exempt Organization Search site and some googling.

[0] https://www.ama-al-projimo.org/

[1] https://www.wjbf.com/business/press-releases/ein-presswire/6...

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by jodacola on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:56PM (#41952418)
One more interesting update: AMA AL PROMIJO was established in care of an individual named Eric Sapp. Some googling landed me on an org’s site named Public Democracy. One of the other team members at the company[0] is the person named in care of one of the NORTH CAROLINA VOLUNTEER CORPS.

Seems we have some glue here! Time to learn more about this Public Democracy thing to try to figure out their angle.

[0] https://www.publicdemocracy.io/teammates

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by riley123 on Saturday October 26, 2024 @12:29AM (#41952556)
Here's the website that has info about the program, and lists AMA AL PROMIJO as a 'partner': https://www.publicdemocracyamerica.org/better-angels-program

All these orgs are taking advantage of the 'Google Grants' program, which provides up to $10,000 per month in free search advertising for registered nonprofits. $120,000/yr in free ads for the cost of registering a nonprofit seems like a no-brainer for spreading a message. Likely drives up ad prices and gives a nice tax-break to Google, so they win too.

https://www.google.com/grants/faq/

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by fHr on Saturday October 26, 2024 @10:47AM (#41955062)
this is insane and shows how dangerous big tech is, break them up already
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by actionfromafar on Saturday October 26, 2024 @12:05PM (#41955610)
These incentives are incredibly misaligned. How big is this tax loop hole to Google? Truck sized or Battlestar sized?
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by rapind on Saturday October 26, 2024 @01:22PM (#41956192)
So to summarize, someone saw the Google Grants program, figured out how to abuse it and scaled it up. I wouldn't even call this much of a loop hole because it seems so obvious.

How widespread / prevalent is this? Does Google care? Is Google incentivized to not care? Is it such a small drop in the bucket that it's basically irrelevant (and boring)?

I wonder if we'd see the same on other ad platforms like Facebook.

Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by euroderf on Saturday October 26, 2024 @04:15AM (#41953379)
headline: Russian disinfo webring busted by HN diligence
Re:All Political Ads Run on Google in the US by datavirtue on Saturday October 26, 2024 @04:37AM (#41953459)
Spot on.