News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by rsynnott on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:05PM (#41947216)
Today in incredibly obvious things...

Smartphones are an absolute graveyard of fads; remember the 3D screen phones, the phones with projectors, and so forth? They generally go nowhere. I suspect 'AI' on phones will be similar.

Overwhelmingly, what people want out of phones is "like my current phone, but with better battery life and maybe a better camera." Previously 'faster' was also a concern, but modern phones are largely Good Enough.

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by ip26 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:55PM (#41947738)
There's a lot we quietly take for granted. Supposedly the NPUs on phones were originally added to let the phone identify objects in your photo library. When shopping for phones, I tend to shop for better battery and camera... but I also wouldn't go back to a photo library without identification.
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by rsynnott on Friday October 25, 2024 @03:28PM (#41948759)
Yeah, I should possibly qualify; by ‘AI’ on phones I would expect that the average person polled understands LLMs, image generation, that sort of thing. OCR, image classification, etc, I doubt they’re thinking of that when answering this; that wouldn’t even have been marketed as ‘AI’ until a couple years ago.
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by chihuahua on Friday October 25, 2024 @03:36PM (#41948840)
My favorite one is Amazon's Fire Phone, which had multiple cameras so it could figure out where your face is relative to the screen, which would enable some crazy 3D effect.
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by changing1999 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:16PM (#41947329)
Even camera improvements are overblown. My usage and photo quality did not improve much since ~iPhone 6. Taking decent travel photos, selfies, etc - I was happy with the results 10 years ago.

Technically, I understand the difference in the technology, I just don't know who needs that vs who gets excited about new features for a brief moment.

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by jsbisviewtiful on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:34PM (#41947501)
> Even camera improvements are overblown.

I would love to take a photo using my smartphone that doesn't look pixelated, blurry and or over-processed. Maybe asking too much considering smartphone sensors can't compete with DSLRs in some situations, but I'm always baffled with how dark and desaturated some of my photos turn out on my smartphone, as well.

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by changing1999 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:47PM (#41947638)
Me too! If anything, iPhone photos became more over-processed over the last decade.
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by shinycode on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:08PM (#41947897)
I’m often surprised that my iPhone photo app show old photos in the widget that look stunning and were taken with the iPhone XS and 11 PM. Night photos are better now but day photos stalled a long time ago. I find joy taking some shots with halide or photon in trueRaw where all processing is removed and grain is present. It gives an authentic look … so all HDR stuff is often too much
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by jajko on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:33PM (#41948184)
Few years ago there was usual 'Apple look' on Instagram where every photo was taken at golden hour, all skin blemishes and moles ironed out into oblivion. Everybody was doing it in some form, but Apple was (is?) going furthest, into territory of painting more than representing reality (I compared my Samsung ultra with wife's iphone and its consistently this... but generally all reviews I saw few years ago stated the same).

Now pendulum has swung so all go for 'realistic look', but I expect people actually want rather milder version of above.

Phone photos look OK on phones, but enlarged even the top contender from current dxomark show very much how hardware limits work. Its just not presentable, maybe apart from very bright scenes. Now I wouldn't go bashing phones per se, its marvel what they achieve from those tiny plastic lenses and some CPU time. And they are always there. But any low hanging fruit in phone photography was picked up long time ago by whole market, what lies ahead are slow computational improvements, coupled with very slow increase in size and thickness of camera section of phones to capture more light.

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by rsynnott on Friday October 25, 2024 @03:29PM (#41948772)
I think some people do genuinely care about the camera improvements; personally anything I’ve used from the iPhone 7 on has been _fine_, but I’m not a demanding camera-user.
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by eleveriven on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:37PM (#41948234)
These days, manufacturers seem to focus on more niche improvements (like for mobile gamers)
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by eleveriven on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:36PM (#41948221)
They’ve all been hyped, only to be forgotten as consumers consistently revert to what they actually care about
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by x0x0 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:50PM (#41947674)
I would kinda like search that works over my thousands of photos
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by 243423443 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:57PM (#41947761)
Google Photos has that. But I guess you mean locally?
Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by x0x0 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:58PM (#41947777)
Google photos search doesn't work well at all for me.

Even things like "[my dog name] beach" isn't reliable.

Or things like I use photos as notes. It doesn't reliably recall things like cheese when I take pictures of cheese in various stores to remember what is sold where. Not even the name of the cheese; just cheese. Ditto spices.

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by mattlondon on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:07PM (#41947882)
Don't use the name - "Mr Floppy at the beach" is meaningless, but "dog at a beach" will probably yield a lot more.

I've found google photos search to be pretty good, and if it can't find something usually the map-mode is enough to pin it down (e.g. go to the beach where you took the photo and it shows you the photos from there)

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by x0x0 on Friday October 25, 2024 @03:03PM (#41948522)
Thanks for the suggestion.

I did just check, and "dog at beach" generates sub 20% recall for me. I go to the beach weekly with my dog, take lots of photos because I'm a dork, and that first query skips many weeks.

Also, I did add my dog as a known / named pet under the explore tab, which is why I thought the name should work.

I can make it work by picking out the beach via geo, but I think the whole thing illustrates how much better this could be. I'd like to be able to get responses to queries like

* [pet name] at [beach X]

* [pet name] with sand on face

* dead seal, or even just dead animal (pics on beach)

* seaglass (recall is poor there too until I manually added to a photo album)

* dent in car

* [spice name] (I take pics of spices to know which stores offer what)

etc etc. The only way I manage the thousands of photos I have now is by carefully sorting into hundreds of albums, which google also doesn't support well.

Amongst the many many deficiencies of the app (which, tbf, does work extremely well as a read-through cache and seems to back things up very well), it likes to surface spotlights of dead people and pets. Which is not at all what I want proactively surfaced.

Re:Smartphone buyers meh on AI, care much more about battery... by mattlondon on Saturday October 26, 2024 @03:05AM (#41953098)
I think the classification engine is likely just like 500 common object classifications. It's quite old and has been around for ages so I don't think it is currently as sophisticated as modern LLMs etc. So "sand" and "face" are probably fine, but "sand on face" might be tricky. No idea though - just guessing from my own personal experience

It was also hobbled quite hard near the start as they had a scare with searches for "gorilla" accidentally returning pictures of black people so they have probably turned all the safety knobs they have up to 11, even if that impacts recall.