News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by mindstab on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:17PM (#4191067)
Yes. It's the iPhone disruption... That over half the market there that's android? Doesn't count cus they entered later (well they were working on it before but launched later) and therefore nothing they contributed counts. Yes clearly

"All of this, because of the iPhone."

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by alanh on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:21PM (#4191086)
Look at Android before and after the iPhone was announced:

http://www.tekgadg.com/storage/Android_before_after_iphone_t...

Gruber & his audience know (believe? Is there doubt?) that.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by jinushaun on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:30PM (#4191125)
I played with the Android SDK back in 2007. It was totally a BB clone before the iPhone came along. Granted, Android was designed to support multiple resolutions and form factors, but the default was a BB-like device until 2008.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by dannyr on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:20PM (#4191348)
Are you claiming that Apple was not inspired by any previous device for the IPhone?

There were a bunch of full-screen touch devices way before the IPhone.

What about the Mac UI? If not for Xerox, it would have been completely different.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by technoslut on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:16PM (#4191568)
You miss the entire point about why the iPhone was revolutionary. Yes, there were other touchscreen devices (mostly capacitive and plastic). There were fundamental rethinking of the hardware internally which hadn't been done before. However, it was about the software. The software on the iPhone was leaps and bounds ahead of anything that existed. It made the experience fun, beautiful and intuitive which was not how smartphones were previously.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by dannyr on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:21PM (#4191586)
technoslut: I did not say that the IPhone is not revolutionary but it doesn't mean it didn't take inspiration from earlier products.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by rgnrgn on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:32PM (#4191138)
June 2007: iPhone launches

July 2008: iPhone 3G

October 2008: HTC Dream, aka T-Mobile G1, the first Android phone, launches: has both touchscreen and keyboard

June 2009: iPhone 3GS launches

October 2009: Motorola Droid and the big Verizon advertising campaign starts making a dent into the iPhone market share.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by programminggeek on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:25PM (#4191099)
Well, Android certainly hopped on, but most of the basic innovations and vision came from the iPhone and Android took them and did their own thing with them. They copied. Apple, Microsoft, IBM, Dell, HP, etc. all have taken turns copying their peers at something. Good for them, it is the right decision. Otherwise, Android would have turned out a lot more like the Microsoft Kin.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by Tichy on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:04PM (#4191525)
I'd say Palm were really the first to provide a usable pocket computer. iPhone did not come out of nowhere.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by tjogin on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @05:01AM (#4193193)
Being first is about as useful as saying "first!" and there is zero value in "coming out of nowhere". What matters is creating something great.

The iPhone turned the industry on its head. Palm did not.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by Tichy on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @09:51AM (#4194050)
Most useless discussion ever. But still, how do you define "turned the industry on it's head"? By the amount of money that is made in a market segment? I developed mobile apps long before the iPhone existed. I still get requests for web development.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by mkaltenecker on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:28PM (#4191113)
The iPhone very clearly disrupted the market for mobile phones. Whether or not someone else had the same idea at the same time (but couldn’t bring a disruptive product to the market) doesn’t really matter. Current market shares don’t really matter.

This Android defensiveness is getting on my nerves. Worse than rabid Apple fanboys in the 90s.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by Androsynth on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:31PM (#4191132)
imo, the android defensiveness stems from the rabid Apple fanboys of the past ~5 years (eg daring fireball).
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by mkaltenecker on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:57PM (#4191248)
My advice is to not be so sensitive. Android is very successful. There is no need to jump in loudly screaming whenever someone mentions Apple or the iPhone.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by mitchty on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:55PM (#4191715)
Exactly, we aren't rooting for football teams here, no need to act territorial.

In addition, its a factual reality that Android came out after the iPhone. That doesn't discount its contributions however, just puts into perspective its place in history.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by dannyr on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:16PM (#4191333)
Your advice works for the Apple fanboys too. IPhone is very successful as much, if not, more than Android.

It's interesting though that it was Apple dissing Google in its WWDC keynote (how its latest OS is in most phones unlike Android's). Google, unlike last year, didn't diss Apple at all at Google I/O.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by flatline3 on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:27PM (#4191372)
Can we just not do this? I already lived through the "MACS SUX PCS ROOL" 90s, and I don't really want to deal with the modern Android vs. iOS incarnation.

Next, someone will be saying "right tool for the job", a Linux desktop guy will pop in to say "you're both wrong!", some benevolent Windows user will pipe in with "Macs are mostly good for design." I can't remember what gamers would say, but it was probably something equally inane.

To this I all say: No. Stop. There is nothing interesting here to say. We've done this before, and it had more to do with tribal us vs. them simplification than it did with any genuine mature comparative analysis of the options.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by mattgreenrocks on Monday July 02, 2012 @10:31PM (#4192199)
But how will they feel Right On The Internet with that sort of perspective?
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by mixmastamyk on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:08PM (#4191542)
"All of this has happened before, and it will all happen again."
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by falling on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:44PM (#4191191)
I think you are not very clear on the meaning of the word disrupt:

interrupt (an event, activity, or process) by causing a disturbance or problem: a rail strike that could disrupt both passenger and freight service.

a disruptive product is a product that breaks with what was before and changes the course of its class of products.

It relates to market share only insofar that it needs enough share of its market to make an impact on it, which is not necessarily a majority.

Now, I think it’s a bit silly trying to say that mobile phones/smartphones/pocketable computers didn’t change after the introduction of the iPhone (see also link below by alanh: http://www.tekgadg.com/storage/Android_before_after_iphone_t..., or check how many phones with and without keys are available today, or the success of the “app store” model).

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by rprasad on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:58PM (#4191252)
Apple's disruption is not the hardware, the software, or the integration of the two.

Apple's disruption is spending several hundreds of billions of dollars on marketing to tell people what they could do with the hardware and software.

Androids, Windows Mobile, Blackberry could do everything the iPhone could do, and usually faster, cheaper, and better. But they never told anyone how to do all the cool stuff, or even that the cool stuff was possible. Which is a shame, because most people actually credit Apple with inventing the smartphone, more than a decade after smartphones hit the market.

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by bluthru on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:22PM (#4191351)
Oh, here it is. The inevitable "Apple is only successful because of marketing" comment.

Have you even used a mobile web browser before the iPhone?

Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by pinaceae on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:20PM (#4191345)
utter nonsense. rather than regurgitating the same old facts to dispute you, i'll just hope you work for one of my competitors.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by blubbix on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:13PM (#4191325)
If so, why didn't Microsoft spend their money on marketing instead of replacing WM6?
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by rprasad on Monday July 02, 2012 @08:06PM (#4191748)
Microsoft targets enterprise customers. Their customers are swayed by personal relationships, not television ads.
Re:The iPhone and Disruption: Five Years In by greedo on Monday July 02, 2012 @10:14PM (#4192159)
Ha. Yes Microsoft targets enterprise customers. By purchasing tons of print ads in PC Magazine etc. Take a look at the SG&A for both companies and you'll see that for a company that doesn't manufacture many tangible goods (the xbox is a blip on the radar compared to Apple's manufacturing) sure spends a lot of money, much of it on advertising:

http://ycharts.com/companies/MSFT/sga_expense#series=type:co...