Re:Cisco’s cloud vision: Mandatory, monetized, and killed at...
by gergles on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:52PM
(#4191226)
A router is not a 'cloud service'. I give specific information to a cloud service to do with as it sees fit; I give my router literally everything I do on the Internet.
Somewhat of a difference there.
Re:Cisco’s cloud vision: Mandatory, monetized, and killed at...
by agwa on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:58PM
(#4191254)
Gmail is a very popular cloud service, and email contains almost everything you do.
Re:Cisco’s cloud vision: Mandatory, monetized, and killed at...
by eswangren on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:59PM
(#4191506)
It does? Last I checked my gmail was full of letters to/from my mom and spam. Hardly "everything I do" on the Internet. I also willingly signed up for gmail because, you know, it offers a service that is useful for me. Hard to make that argument here.
Re:Cisco’s cloud vision: Mandatory, monetized, and killed at...
by agwa on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:17PM
(#4191573)
I tried to make the argument that a cloud router (though not this one) could provide a useful service. I guess people don't agree, hence the downvotes.
Re:Cisco’s cloud vision: Mandatory, monetized, and killed at...
by rhubarbquid on Monday July 02, 2012 @11:11PM
(#4192322)
> difficulty of pushing out firmware updates
They've obviously already solved that problem... this article is about an update that was automatically installed. It wasn't part of a "cloud service" when they bought it.
For instance, Marshini Chetty, a researcher at Georgia Tech, has been working on a project called Kermit[1] to provide increased visibility into home networks, mainly to provide QoS (e.g. you can determine your teenager is hogging the bandwidth with video streaming and throttle him back). However their system generates a lot of data, too much to process on the router itself, so IIRC they schlep it over to a PC running on the network. If this were coupled with a cloud service, you wouldn't need to keep a PC running all the time. I'm not sure how much of a market there really is for this, though in a presentation she said they had done a study where they put these in average people's homes and received a positive reception.
On a different note, I find the outrage about this (both here on HN and elsewhere) somewhat ironic because the privacy policy isn't that different from the privacy policies people put up with everyday with other cloud services they use. I think it's just when it's put in contrast with the status quo of routers (not in the cloud and with good privacy guarantees) that people find it outrageous. This is not a comparison people make with other cloud services; perhaps they should.
[1] http://www.cc.gatech.edu/~marshini/kermit.html