News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by anon808 on Monday July 02, 2012 @01:43PM (#4189896)
"I just can't figure out how to do it without losing contact with my friends."

easy . . . call them, visit them, email them, write letters to them. you don't need an application to managed personal relationships.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by betterth on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:29PM (#4190156)
If it was this simple than Facebook would never have caught on in the first place. The answer isn't "rollback" because clearly there is some value here. The answer is finding out how to maximize that value to our lives, not maximize the payout for investors.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by malandrew on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:14PM (#4190419)
The main thing Facebook provides that isn't addressable with the systems we'd be left with in a "rollback" is a universal way to stay linked to other people that provides both people with control over whether that link exists or not. Everything else is just features glommed on top of that basic feature.

AFAICT there are only two ways to provide that basic feature:

(!) A centralized service like Facebook that manages the identity network. Any centralized organization is most likely ultimately going to exploit the fact that they own the network for their own gain, financial or otherwise.

or

(2) A decentralized service based on the similar cryptographic math as bitcoin, where every user gets one token representing their identity, and some sort of way to propagate changes to their identity signed by that token to everyone they are connected to and this needs to be accomplished in such a way that you can always re-establish the links to your friends in the network to be able to sync data.

I can't even begin to imagine how you'd develop the latter into a form that would be usable and therefore adoptable by the average person.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by Silhouette on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:15PM (#4191559)
I am still trying to work out why something approximating (2) can't be done through a simple combination of:

- tried-and-tested public key cryptography techniques

- using e-mail as a buffered delivery mechanism (everyone has an e-mail account that can store plenty of messages until they're next on-line)

- borrowing the typical DVCS copy-the-whole-repo approach so you've got distributed back-ups

- writing a native client for whichever platforms you wanted to support.

If someone wants to make money off it, come up with a neat physical way to connect something personal but memorable to keys of sufficient complexity to encrypt everything robustly: mobile app, USB device, whatever.

The only obvious limitation is physical bandwidth and storage capacity, which would make copy-the-whole-repo unsustainable if people kept sharing lots of photos/multimedia content but their friends don't want to "download" all of it. How much this will matter as data storage and communication network capacity increases is anyone's guess.

In the meantime, if you were willing to accept a delay you could have a request/reply system to fetch larger items, or someone could charge a modest sum of real money to people who want to use an actual centralised escrow-like system that is always available to their friends even when they're not on-line. The system doesn't need to be able to see into any content, just to act as a more real-time substitute for the default buffered transmission via e-mail.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by wodemaye__ on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:40PM (#4191664)
Hi, I'm actually in the process of designing such a system, with the goal of maximizing privacy, sovereignty, decentralization, and overall empowerment (not to mention destroying the facebook spying machine). If you'd like to help out with ideas and brainstorming, please do email me at bash.vcs [squigllydoo [SHIFT+TWO]] <google's mail service> . com. I already have some ideas for unique features that will set this apart from other similarly oriented efforts in a significant way. I'm getting close to starting up a mailing list and code repository, so please be in touch if you're at all interested. I'll keep you filled in.

PS it will be completely F/OSS, most likely GPL depending on contributor consensus.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by wodemaye__ on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:42PM (#4191670)
Hi, I'm actually in the process of designing such a system, with the goal of maximizing privacy, sovereignty, decentralization, and overall empowerment (not to mention destroying the facebook spying machine). If you'd like to help out with ideas and brainstorming, please do email me at bash.vcs [squigllydoo [SHIFT+TWO]] <google's mail service> . com. I already have some ideas for unique features that will set this apart from other similarly oriented efforts in a significant way. I'm getting close to starting up a mailing list and code repository, so please be in touch if you're at all interested. I'll keep you filled in.

But yeah, you've hit the nail right on the head. Obviously, my will fall into your (2) category, so we've got some major usability and cryptographic hurdles to tackle. But please rest assured that the solutions exist and that I've got most of them hammered out in my mind - the rest just require a little brainstorming and puzzle solving.

PS it will be completely F/OSS, most likely GPL depending on contributor consensus.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by Ralith on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:52PM (#4191702)
Why will you succeed where so many others have failed?
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by wodemaye__ on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @09:41AM (#4194011)
I have unique ideas for solutions to unsolved problems. I plan to use a painless and ubiquitous deployment platform, as well as an unparalleled level of decentralization (not federation where you're still a slave to the pod operator who can still sell you out) and sovereignty. I plan on publishing essays of my ideas as proposals on a site in the near future when I get around to doing so. I can keep you filled in if you're interested in contributing. (it'll all likely be GPLd.)
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by toemetoch on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:29PM (#4191380)
I guess the FB cookies in your browser is a simplified version of the token. It's used to identify you not only on FB but also on other sites that load their javascript for comments & likes. There was some anger a while back about how fb could track you with cookies even if you're logged out - due to the ubiquity of their js on the web.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by mark_integerdsv on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @01:35AM (#4192699)
You are describing (1) a cellphone network and (2) a cellphone number.

The rest is overthink.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by malandrew on Monday July 02, 2012 @11:55PM (#4192428)
I forgot one detail. They don't just provide the links, but a way of discovering the link via other unique identifiers, some of which are confirmed. e.g. email addresses and phone numbers.

With #2 you'd still need trusted sources that can verify that a person i found via [email protected] or +1 (914) 555-1212 is in fact the owner of that email or phone number.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by mongol on Monday July 02, 2012 @04:47PM (#4190918)
Number 2 is very interesting. I don't know either how it would work, but Bitcoin proves that intelligent stuff in this direction can be done and have some success
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by k-mcgrady on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:01PM (#4189995)
>> "you don't need an application to managed personal relationships"

You do when you're keeping in touch with friends you've made throughout your life and not just your current ones. That's the thing Facebook makes easy.

Also email and writing letters don't really work. If I sent a letter to a friend I seriously doubt they would bother responding, and most people I know personally don't use email. They use Facebook. That's the big problem - Facebook has replaced email for a lot of people making it one of the only ways (besides visiting/calling) to contact them.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by gnaritas on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:44PM (#4190251)
> You do when you're keeping in touch with friends you've made throughout your life and not just your current ones.

Your friends are the current ones. Those other people aren't friends anymore, they're acquaintances, people you used to know but don't see anymore. Friend isn't a permanent status, it's the people you hang out with and see on a regular basis. If your only contact with a person is through facebook, they aren't your friends.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by joeblubaugh on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:01PM (#4190989)
You know what? You don't get to decide who people's friends are. 30 years ago people had all kinds of friends they only got to communicate with on the phone and through letters. Non-face-to-face friendships (and romantic relationships) have existed since we had semi-reliable postal services. People happen to find things like Twitter & Facebook really helpful in this regard.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by gnaritas on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:47PM (#4191682)
I'm not telling anyone who their friends are, I'm telling you you're using the English language sloppily if everyone in your Facebook you really consider a "friend". You've devalued the word to nearly meaninglessness. Everyone you've ever met is not your friend. Everyone you've had a friendly conversation with and looked up on Facebook is not your friend.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by abduhl on Monday July 02, 2012 @08:06PM (#4191749)
This is a ridiculous argument. There are plenty of people I see every day that I would consider, at best, an acquaintance. There is also a very small group of people that I see maybe once or twice a year that I would consider friends.

Your definition of friendship is outrageously shallow and is contrary to any other definition I have heard.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by greedo on Monday July 02, 2012 @09:54PM (#4192094)
Agree. My best friend is moving to another state, 16 hours away. I skypechat with him on a daily basis, and he knows me like a brother. I haven't "seen" him in over two years, and when I joked that he was going to leave town without saying goodbye, he said "what will be different?"

He was right, nothing is different. It's like friends back in the 1800s exchanging letters. Doesn't mean that our friendship is less because we don't go out on Fridays and pound down a few pints.

In contrast, the people I work with, I spend far more time with, and interact directly with more frequently than my friend. Yet I wouldn't consider any of them friends.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by Karunamon on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @12:03AM (#4192453)
Thank you. I for one am tired of seeing the "People you only interact with online are not friends" canard. Relationships don't work that way.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by gnaritas on Monday July 02, 2012 @08:27PM (#4191816)
> There are plenty of people I see every day that I would consider, at best, an acquaintance.

Ditto, where did I say seeing someone every day made them a friend? If it's this "it's the people you hang out with and see on a regular basis" that wasn't meant to qualify everyone you see daily as a friend.

> There is also a very small group of people that I see maybe once or twice a year that I would consider friends.

But you see them, which is my point. If your only contact with them is on Facebook, and losing Facebook would end your contact with them; they aren't your friends.

> Your definition of friendship is outrageously shallow and is contrary to any other definition I have heard.

I don't think you've understand what I'm saying well enough to say what my definition is since you've gotten it so clearly wrong.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by abduhl on Monday July 02, 2012 @09:19PM (#4191968)
I'm sorry but you're moving the goal posts here.

>Friend isn't a permanent status, it's the people you hang out with and see on a regular basis.

In my post where I say "maybe once or twice a year" I am saying precisely that I do NOT see them on a regular basis.

It is not that I don't understand what you're saying, it is that you're not saying what you mean correctly.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by gnaritas on Monday July 02, 2012 @09:44PM (#4192053)
Which I've already clarified as well as described several different ways, you're just being pedantic.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by Nursie on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @02:37AM (#4192836)
What makes you think that some of us don't use facebook in a different way to you, and only 'friend' actual friends?

It's you that's devalued the word IMHO, if you are codifying a 'friend' relationship with everyone you've ever met.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by k-mcgrady on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:02PM (#4190351)
That's highly subjective. For example, if I moved abroad the people I hung out with regularly before would still be 'friends' to me. I would still care about what's happening in their lives and Facebook is a great way to continue that relationship. To me a friend is someone, not related, that I care about. Not someone that I hang out with regularly.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by brownbat on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:15PM (#4190426)
I'm not sure how these semantic distinctions affect the argument.

Replace the "friends" in his original post with "acquaintances," and his point stands.

Facebook is useful as a long term rolodex.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by gnaritas on Monday July 02, 2012 @04:11PM (#4190715)
> Replace the "friends" in his original post with "acquaintances," and his point stands.

That's changing the argument, those words mean totally different things. My point is, Facebook makes keeping in touch with acquaintances easy, but isn't necessary to keep in touch with actual friends. Friends are people you see outside of Facebook.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by Jach on Monday July 02, 2012 @04:45PM (#4190908)
For less introverted people, "friend" and "acquaintance" are more-or-less synonymous. See why Facebook chose the word "friend" now? (I agree with your assessment of course, I consider them very different. My best friend doesn't even have Facebook, I only succumbed a few months ago...)
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by gnaritas on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:41PM (#4191666)
> For less introverted people, "friend" and "acquaintance" are more-or-less synonymous.

Ask any of those less introverted people to name someone who's an acquaintance but not a friend, I bet they come up with a name showing that when pressed, they can make the distinction and do have different meanings for those words.

I do not believe there are people who cannot make that distinction.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by brownbat on Saturday July 07, 2012 @11:47PM (#4213536)
> That's changing the argument, those words mean totally different things.

Sure, you're concerned he was using "friends" too loosely. I'm saying you should give him a pass. It's of course up to you.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by jessedhillon on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:11PM (#4191045)
And who says nerds don't understand other people?
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by cheap on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:07PM (#4190384)
Facebook gave you the problem that you didn't have before Facebook.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by RegEx on Monday July 02, 2012 @01:58PM (#4189983)
Facebook has monetized the hardship of letting friendships go. People change, shit happens, and you have to move on. Facebook, however, makes us believe we can keep these relationships going forever. I'm sure there are many successful reconnection stories, but I bet there are magnitudes more 'talked for a few days after not seeing each other for a few years, and that was that' stories.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by pinkbucket on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:30PM (#4190161)
That's not to say there isn't value in that. I've been really happy to connect with old acquaintances over just a message or two. I don't really want much more contact than that.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by bmj on Monday July 02, 2012 @01:58PM (#4189981)
I agree with you, but there's another issue here: some of your friends may not actually respond to email messages. Personally, I'm a fan of email and letter writing (and not a fan of the phone), but I've fallen out of touch with several friends because if you don't contact them via Facebook or Twitter (I do neither), you won't hear back from them.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by freehunter on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:11PM (#4190059)
Another thing email doesn't do well: the idea of "I have something to say, but passively". Maybe you want to announce a change in your life, or a party, or some thought that you had. It's far less annoying to put it on Facebook where your friends can digest it (or not) at their leisure, rather than in an email demanding to be read.

"Hey, what's your new address?"

"I emailed it to you, go search through your messages"

vs

"Check my Facebook profile"

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by fallenhitokiri on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:31PM (#4190172)
The only problem I see with your email sentence is that some clients lack a decent search functionality.

Some improvements and it would IMHO be as easy, if not easier, as opening Facebook, trying to find a contact and fight against the timeline to find the information you are looking for.

I think the party part is a bit of personal choice. If I run a party I want to notify $foo people. And $foo is always a smaller number than my Facebook "friends". I just prefer the ability to select people and only tell them what I want to say without creating tons of groups for everything.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by freehunter on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:02PM (#4190354)
This might be locale-specific, but there's a lot of times I'm notified of a party/get-together via a Facebook post saying "I'll be down at $taphouse tonight at 9, feel free to stop by!" That's a very passive invite, and Facebook (or Twitter or G+ et al) is perfect for that.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by pinkbucket on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:27PM (#4190142)
I get what you are saying. The one good thing about Facebook is that it took a lot of that fluff out of my inbox. But could I not have learnt to manage/gloss over it?

The thing that Facebook does well - is tracking down contacts - to add to your 'address book.' It's not so easy in the world of email. That's because we aren't publishing our address books publicly (probably for good reason.)

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by Spooky23 on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:28PM (#4190492)
You're missing the point -- those people aren't your friends anyway. The fact that you can "like" a picture of someone's kid or say happy birthday on their Wall doesn't change that fact.

Facebook can be a great tool for sharing photos and other things with your friends. But most of what is actually happening on Facebook is voyeurism -- you get to stalk people whom you sort of know.

Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by greedo on Monday July 02, 2012 @09:56PM (#4192103)
I know hating FB is all the rage (and sometimes well deserved) but you're attributing your feelings about FB to all the users. Failbook.com isn't indicative of all the FB users.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by baddox on Monday July 02, 2012 @03:49PM (#4190600)
Do you need phones to manage personal relationships? What about a postal service? What about automobiles? Of course not. I could choose to only maintain relationships with people within walking distance of my home, but I prefer using technology to facilitate communication over longer distances.
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by vibrunazo on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:07PM (#4190039)
How do I find their email address, tho? :P
Re:Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion" by pinkbucket on Monday July 02, 2012 @02:20PM (#4190105)
You join!