Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by log_e on Saturday October 19, 2024 @01:13AM
(#41885786)
You realize tautology is a logical fallacy, right?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by auggierose on Saturday October 19, 2024 @03:56AM
(#41886364)
It is not. It is actually quite the opposite.
Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by schrodinger on Saturday October 19, 2024 @01:49AM
(#41885893)
It's like saying "A beginner is new to a subject." That's tautological since the definition of beginner implies being new to a subject.
Those aren't logical fallacies; they're just not very useful.
Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by pdonis on Saturday October 19, 2024 @01:16AM
(#41885799)
Huh? A tautology is a statement that is automatically true by the laws of logic.
Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by maxbond on Saturday October 19, 2024 @01:40AM
(#41885867)
GP is correct that the argument contains an informal fallacy[1], and people often express this criticism by saying "your argument is tautological," and you are correct that a tautology is a statement which is always true [2].
Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by pdonis on Saturday October 19, 2024 @07:37PM
(#41891683)
> GP is correct that the argument contains an informal fallacy
The GP didn't say that.
As for which informal fallacy the GGP's argument contained, I would say it was more like a false dilemma. And the GGP did say "almost tautological", which implicitly recognizes that there might be other possibilities.
> people often express this criticism by saying "your argument is tautological,"
I have never seen this (nonsensical) way of expressing the criticism that an argument is false by saying that it is tautological (and therefore true).
Re:Strep A kills half a million per year; why don't we have ...
by maxbond on Saturday October 19, 2024 @08:23PM
(#41891910)
The point is that it's an overloaded term, which makes it easy to talk past each other.
If you wish to see usages like I described, have a look here.
https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...