Re:The Feds Are Coming for John Deere over the Right to Repair
by titzer on Saturday October 19, 2024 @09:53AM
(#41887772)
> Basically removing the dealers and therefore the OEM's stranglehold on software would take the teeth out of emissions enforcement.
I don't buy that. This strangehold is the only way that VW managed to cheat emissions for years without getting caught.
Re:The Feds Are Coming for John Deere over the Right to Repair
by Cheezmeister on Saturday October 19, 2024 @11:18AM
(#41888308)
In a world where rolling coal[1] is a thing that people do voluntarily, I submit that emissions enforcement (as it stands) is a failed experiment. It's time to rethink it from first principles.
Won't happen. Feds find the status quo too useful to let every tom dick and harry start wrenching on these things
I'm pretty familiar with what's going on at CAT. A large part of the way all the emissions stuff that everyone (I'm talking about the customers, dealers, OEMs, the people who actually pay for things, not the online peanut gallery) hates gets enforced is that the OEM threatens the dealers that they'll cut them off from the software if they don't run a tight ship and their techs are too frequently caught doing things like plugging into vehicles outside the scope of their job, working on deleted equipment and whatnot. The dealers roll this downhill to their employees. I assume Deere is similar.
Basically removing the dealers and therefore the OEM's stranglehold on software would take the teeth out of emissions enforcement.