News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenVMM – A New VMM for Windows and Linux, Written in Rust by acdha on Thursday October 17, 2024 @09:59AM (#41869753)
It is a useful feature. We’ve had tons and tons of bugs caused by C/C++ misfeatures which is both why Rust was invented and why users are looking for more stable alternatives after decades on the patch of the week treadmill. A tool like this is aimed at a technical audience who will see the appeal of a tool which is safer and easier to work on.
Re:OpenVMM – A New VMM for Windows and Linux, Written in Rust by kreetx on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:47AM (#41870181)
Right, but I suspect people would like to use it to run VMs rather than start developing it. If the indent is to invite developers who "know rust", then that is the wrong measuring bar (IMO, of course), as you'd want developers who are interested in hypervisors instead of a specific language.
Re:OpenVMM – A New VMM for Windows and Linux, Written in Rust by acdha on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:21AM (#41870501)
As a user of VMs, I would value memory safety because hypervisor exploits are nasty and patching is higher risk.
Re:OpenVMM – A New VMM for Windows and Linux, Written in Rust by kreetx on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:43AM (#41870719)
Not disagreeing with you on the memory safety. It's just that the way "written in Rust" is used, it seems like a marketing gimmick to invite anyone who knows (or maybe wants to learn) Rust. Shows (IMO!) the weakness of the project rather than its seriousness.
Re:OpenVMM – A New VMM for Windows and Linux, Written in Rust by acdha on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:58PM (#41871981)
I haven’t observed people taking that as a learning opportunity as opposed to an expression of a modern version of an existing tool which emphasizes safety.