News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by gman83 on Monday October 14, 2024 @06:33PM (#41842863)
I have dozens of clients on WordPress and I've not heard from a single one. I'm pretty worried personally, though.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by bigiain on Monday October 14, 2024 @07:30PM (#41843320)
We've had 3 queries so far out of about two dozen clients on WP/WPEngine.

We are _actively_ making contingency plans. But our best estimate at this stage is that WPEngine will provide a suitable way to keep all our WPEngine sites running at least in the short and medium term, but we are also making disaster plans in case this all goes, as Matt intends, "nuclear".

Matt keeps talking about how he's doing this "for the WordPress Community", but as I commented elsewhere:

So far as I can tell, when Matt talks about "the WordPress Community", he means:

  - Matt
  - the people who didn't quit Automattic last week
  - _maybe_ the WP core developers who don't work at Automattic, so long as they keep their criticisms to themselves
And the community of people who _use_ WordPress to run their websites, and the people who help them to do that, and the 3rd party plugin and theme developers who make WP work for so many different kinds of websites - can all go and get fucked.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by belorn on Monday October 14, 2024 @07:55PM (#41843519)
I can see how clients that have sites hosted on WPEngine can be a bit concerned. Did you receive any queries by people who do not have anything hosted by WPEngine, but rather simply have a wordpress site on some other hosting company/self-hosted?

I work at a hosting company and we have received zero questions, and we have a fair larger number of clients who sites are built on wordpress. In terms of going nuclear, anything regarding trademark will have zero impact on our clients.

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by bigiain on Monday October 14, 2024 @09:28PM (#41844031)
Yeah. One of those clients is hosted on GCE. She is quite technical and plugged into general IT news, and they are in the middle of due diligence with potential investors though.

> In terms of going nuclear, anything regarding trademark will have zero impact on our clients.

Is that true if Matt/Automattic win against WPEngine, and he starts using that as precident and starts demanding 8% of revenue as his standard shakedown on anybody who's used the "WordPress" trademark to generate revenue?

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by belorn on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @06:09AM (#41846949)
Yes, it is true. Websites built on wordpress do not generally use wordpress trademark to generate revenue. Its not recommended to have footers that says "built on wordpress", nor is recommended to keep the default website icon. If the client is, say a medical company that sells medical products, any reference to wordpress would be unprofessional to have on their company website.

Is that client of yours a web developing company that focus on wordpress in their marketing?

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by bigiain on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @09:02PM (#41854666)
No. They're in a completely different agriculture related business. They have a custom web app to run the business part of their business, but rely heavily on their WordPress site for marketing, discovery, and customer acquisition.

They have a quite technical marketing team (well, two people) who run the WP site, which they're quite aware of how often plugin and partner theme upgrades show up. The call was basically "So what's going to happen with WordPress and plugins? Are we going to be able to rely on updates and future security for the website?" She wasn't worried that they were gonna get caught up in a trademark problem, but that the trademark "war" would kill off WordPress core development, and/or the future development and bug/security fixes of the plugins they rely on. A reasonably valid fear, and one that I certainly don't dismiss out of hand.

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by chairmansteve on Monday October 14, 2024 @06:41PM (#41842937)
Why are you worried? I am struggling to understand why anyone cares. I am not a WordPress user though.

The WordPress code is available to WPEngine. How are Mullenweg's actions damaging them?

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by fortyseven on Monday October 14, 2024 @06:49PM (#41843019)
So you don't use it, or understand anything about what's going on, apparently, but you have big opinions on it contrary to those who actually do know what's up. Brilliant. No notes.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by chairmansteve on Monday October 14, 2024 @08:15PM (#41843633)
I don't see any opinion in my post. I am literally asking why this is important. Are you a troll?
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by SAI_Peregrinus on Monday October 14, 2024 @09:24PM (#41844012)
Automattic are claiming they own the trademark on WordPress, WP, etc, when it comes to CMS software & hosting of that software.

WP Engine is a prominent hosting provider for WordPress, who also contribute several very popular plugins.

Automattic have sued WP Engine. Automattic have blocked WP Engine from updating any of their plugins, or anything else on wordpress.org. A vulnerability was found in a WP Engine plugin, and Automattic have taken it over (but are not doing any maintenance). Automattic's CEO went on a number of unhinged rants here and elsewhere.

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by chairmansteve on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:37PM (#41862264)
Got it, thank you.

But everyone is still able to publish their blogs, on both WordPress and WPEngine?

And both WordPress and WPEngine are able to fork each other's code and run separate platforms?

So long term fragmentation is the main danger?

Am I completely off the mark?

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by SAI_Peregrinus on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:32AM (#41870053)
Well, WP Engine's users can't (legally) use wordpress.org's services any longer, so they're at risk since they can't log in there to check for plugin updates. Also the takeover of the ACF plugin removed all pro features, which broke some users' websites.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by Brian_K_White on Monday October 14, 2024 @09:37PM (#41844074)
You very clearly expressed the opinion that no one should care what Matt has done.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by chairmansteve on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:33PM (#41862215)
It turns out that my question means something else in American English vernacular. My question was meant literally. I was very surprised at the triggered response. Unusual on HN. But another HN user clarified. Lesson learnt.
Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by edanm on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @02:32AM (#41845577)
I think the phrase "struggling to understand why anyone cares" implies that you think no on should care.

Maybe that's not what you meant. I have no dog in this fight. Just telling you why someone would assume you are expressing an opinion.

Re:Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork by chairmansteve on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:25PM (#41862114)
Thanks, I am not American, that clarifies the apparently random attack.