News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A review after using Rust on embedded in production for o... by rob74 on Monday October 14, 2024 @04:14AM (#41835352)
a.k.a. "resume-driven development"
Re:A review after using Rust on embedded in production for o... by makeitdouble on Monday October 14, 2024 @04:50AM (#41835558)
Typically, devs polishing their resume instead of prioritising business metrics probably means the overall org is on the down slope.
Re:A review after using Rust on embedded in production for o... by mytailorisrich on Monday October 14, 2024 @05:00AM (#41835636)
Perfectly normal for people to want to develop their skills and to enhance their value.

The thing is that this is not a developer's decision, this is a management decision. The developer might pitch for Rust or even start developing in Rust but if that is not right for the org then their manager should say 'no'.

So ultimately this is a red flag about management.

Re:A review after using Rust on embedded in production for o... by ndndjdjdn on Monday October 14, 2024 @04:44PM (#41841777)
Slightly disagree.

Needing the managers permission is more of a "wartime" mode.

For peacetime the management should set a culture of peer review and data and logic driven discussion. The culture would ideally have a Rust lover sit there and think "would love to do this in Rust but...." because they know their peers will be affected by this decision.

The problem with management approval required is it usually meams no or bias towards management pressures. A management veto that is occasionally used may be better.

Disclosure: not a Rust programmer but pretty neutral on it. It is on my radar if I get a problem Node or Go can't solve.

Re:A review after using Rust on embedded in production for o... by makeitdouble on Monday October 14, 2024 @09:44PM (#41844111)
I'd agree with ndndjdjdn in that management getting involved should be the last resort, and potentially only to veto a very bad decision.

I think the main issue here is having a single dev going for Rust. Ideally someone interested in a new technology would pitch it to the team, and they'd discuss if they want to have a shot a it and if they can justify the investment for the whole team. That's where a tech that doesn't fit would be discussed and rejected, potentially with a proposition for a better option that devs are also interested in.

Even if it starts with just a prototype, if it touches production the other members of the team should be able to review it and maintain if needed.

That's this whole bit missing, and the team looking at it as a thing of life, that makes me think they're not focused on pushing things forward anymore at an org level.

Re:A review after using Rust on embedded in production for o... by ndndjdjdn on Monday October 14, 2024 @05:17AM (#41835738)
Or the dev wants more money