And Google Search's past* behaviour was far less toxic.
NB: I've relied all but entirely on DDG search for over a decade. I'm increasingly finding FastGPT from Kagi useful for search-framed-as-question, though the answers have to be carefully vetted. One advantage of Kagi's LLM is that it provides references for its answers making vetting far more straightforward than with, say, OpenAI's LLM.
And my criticism isn't about toxicity as in "ads are bigger", but search result quality, where the level of degradation is an open question. Like with your DDG example: I've tried to switch to it permanently for all search many times, but couldn't because found many instances where Google was just better (think DDG is mostly Bing, which isn't better vs Google)
Now it's mostly really old websites, > ~20 years. Here Google's crawl still seems more robust than DDG's / Bing's. (And yes, DDG leans heavily on Bing.)
Again, I use DDG and retry failed searches via !g bang search. But that's rarely any better.
FastGPT via Kagi is transformational in that I can ask questions and get answers, rather than turning up web pages. Kagi's GPT adds links which reference its sources, which is hugely more useful than ChatGPT in my experience. FastGPT still occasionally hallucinates, but its sources can be much more readily verified. ChatGPT OTOH, hallucinates sources when requested to provide them.
But near the end of the segment "Google with its ... level of intelligence... data... has the ability... to the single best rated product" (a great example of this is trying to find "world's most comfortable chair")
This is unadulterated magic thinking. There is no such thing as "single best" product in any diverse category, especially when you want something so subjective as "comfort". Even if understood literally as "best rated" where theoretically you could have the highest number, there is no source where you could get this number from.
With this fantasy level of Google fu I seriously doubt the author could make an accurate quality assessment of search results besides the "ads take more space now"