At least in the Kantian sense, the guy was not really bad in that he didn't really intend to do much harm. His writing is very tied to bringing Christianity to Caribbean tribes, some of which were still actively practising cannibalism. He "scammed" them by trading glass beads for gold, but that still feels somewhat minor. I wonder if people don't sometime confuse him with Cortés (who was a true piece of work) and the later stage of Spanish colonisation which all happens several years after the death of Columbus.
Perhaps not the most neutral source.
> At least in the Kantian sense, the guy was not really bad in that he didn't really intend to do much harm.
No, they just recognize him as someone whose torture and other cruelty and abuses as a colonial administrator were so severe and notorious that he got thrown in chains, dragged back to Spain, and stripped of titles for them, in late 15th century Spain, not exactly a model of moderation when it came to conversion of subject populations to Christianity or paragon of human rights more generally.
Considering most of the things raised against him in the 21st century were not really frowned up in the 15-16th, I don't think this is a major issue. Additionally, the version I read was https://www.amazon.com/Four-Voyages-Dispatches-Connecting-Na... which has some contextualization by the editor.
> whose torture and other cruelty and abuses as a colonial administrator were so severe and notorious that he got thrown in chains, dragged back to Spain
I did not say he was an inspiring role model and that was abuse directed towards Spanish settlers which is definitely not what people refer to when they call Colombus a monster...
Gold was abundant in America and not worth much for those tribes, but glass beads or mirrors were products of a technology not available to those natives, so for them the exchange was extremely valuable, as they were obtaining something unique and unavailable to hem in exchange of some shiny stones found everywhere.
He was very, very far from a nice person.
In reality the settlers were not supervised and the laws were not always followed, but they were expected by the Government back in European Spain.
What else exactly did he achieve?
He didn’t get to the western hemisphere first, cuz duh, people already lived there, and if I recall correctly, a couple came before him. Eric the Red, and later his son Lief Erikson. There were the Polynesians which basically populated most of the major islands thousands of years before that. Traded with the natives in present day South America that arrived via the land bridge.
He raped, murdered, subjugated and stole from the natives. There are no achievements to celebrate to people with any humanity in them. Only bigots love him.
What else did he achieve? You can’t be that stupid to ask that question in honesty.
The native tribes of the western hemisphere already lived there, but a place is “discovered” if another people become aware of it now, much like we “discover” new tribes in the Amazon with no previous contact with the Brazilian society at large. Likewise such tribes “discovered” Europeans when they first encountered them.
Bravo.
So if I “discover” a house down the street I’ve never seen before, I “achieved” the title of “discoverer” as well! Ok so I guess he did “accomplish” something, I stand corrected.:
He “discovered” the place that was not called Hispaniola by any of the people that called it home.
He “discovered” the gold that those people were literally wearing at their home. I guess that means he can keep that too?
He “discovered” that he could force those at gun point to bring him all the gold they could find from their home.
He “discovered” that he could coerce the people into doing that by beheading the leaders of their home.
He “discovered” he and his crew could rape the women they found in their home.
Such an interesting choice of words you were taught to describe home invasion, rape, murder, robbery.
No, but if you find a house nobody else in the city, country and even the content you live in have ever seen or aware of then yes you can yourself a “discoverer”.
e.g. if humans somehow found sentient aliens somewhere in the galaxy you wouldn't consider that a discovery either? Whether or not they later enslave or murder them doesn't really change that...
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Edit: you've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines in other places too, e.g.:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41481393
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41462599
We have to ban accounts that won't stop doing this, so if you'd please stick to the rules, we'd appreciate it.
The act of sailing over the Atlantic and discovering the new world was pretty cool, what happened after that not. There is no need to make a hero or villain out of him.