News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by meiji on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:34AM (#4180796)
From the article - "The outage underscores the vulnerabilities of depending on the public cloud versus using your own data centers."

No it doesn't. It underscores the vulnerabilities of not understanding your hosting and accepting the "no outages" slogans of ANY cloud. A single data centre is always susceptible to outages like this, it doesn't matter who owns it. If any of those sites had owned a single data centre that was hit by storm damage, the impact would be the same. I know this is supposed to be the year of the cloud backlash but even so...

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by URSpider94 on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:26AM (#4180912)
Exactly. Anyone running their own data center would be subject to exactly this kind of outage, and wouldn't have access to the many, many resources that cloud providers make available to ensure successful fail-over.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by TuanaRegis on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:30AM (#4181295)
Yes, I can see the "many, many resources" Amazon is making available to you in this situation. Did they send you a rubber ball that you can squeeze while waiting for your servers to come back up?
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by cbr on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:46PM (#4182626)
They said fail-over. Those "many, many resources" are other regions and zones.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by adrianpike on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:45AM (#4180828)
I thought both Heroku & Netflix had fairly robust multi-AZ deployments, so I'm hoping they share any of their learnings from this outage.

Either way, that quote is ridiculous.

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by datasage on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:07AM (#4180868)
Netflix does, but considering the time, running out of capacity after loosing a zone might have been more of an issue.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by adrianpike on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:42AM (#4180942)
Definitely a possibility - I was actually watching Netflix when my phone started rattling with all the alerts.

I was able to finish out the episode, so their CDN was working for the actual media, but everything else was dead for me.

Another useless anecdote: A coworker was watching on his xbox, and it apparently cut mid-stream for him.

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by tansey on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:47AM (#4180833)
Heroku doesn't. They are on US-East.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by rdl on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:26AM (#4180914)
Heroku is single-AZ within US-East, not even multiple-AZ.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by asenchi on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:16AM (#4181180)
Sorry but that is not even remotely true. We are hosted across all availability zones in the US-EAST region.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by rdl on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:39AM (#4181218)
Ah, I didn't know that. Sorry. (I don't remember where I heard about single-AZ but it seemed consistent with observation)

Is Heroku resilient against single-AZ failure (so only some subset of customers go down, and then it restarts), or is it exposed so that if any AZ goes down, core stuff also goes down? The sites I care about on Heroku seem to go down whenever any US-East badness happens at all, even if it is "limited to a single AZ" per Amazon.

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by tomjen3 on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:24AM (#4181193)
Actually it shows the inability to rely on amazon. A storm causes a complete disaster? Where is the redundant connections? The independent power supply? Heck where is the storm drains?
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by sandfox on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:34AM (#4181379)
Thats sort of what some large storms can do - esp when they come with a large amount of electrical activity in them. You can easily suffer all kinds damage to power system that generators can't deal with.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by brown9-2 on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:10PM (#4182349)
That's exactly why they offer multiple zones. You can't make a single zone of anything 100% fault-tolerant.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by Homunculiheaded on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:13PM (#4182537)
It's funny, the more I think about I think this is actually a good reason to host on the cloud. From a technical standpoint it's terrifying to see all these big players down at once. But what the average user likely sees is "something is wrong with the internet". So rather than seeing that your site X is down and users being angry with you, users are probably likely to think "well instagram is also down, oh and so is netflix, something big must be broken, I'll check back later" the same way users don't blame you if the power goes out.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by nutjob123 on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:01PM (#4182810)
Interesting thought. A couple users may be empathetic because the actual problem is somewhat visible but I'm not sure if that is an real benefit. It is of course a negative perception when they see that youtube is up and then perceive all the down sites as being less technically competent.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by lubos on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:16AM (#4180893)
It's interesting how AWS outage didn't take down Amazon.com.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by wdewind on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:05PM (#4182507)
Actually temporarily it did. At least for me for about 5 min amazon.com was unreachable yesterday when i first read about this. was around 10pm EST i believe.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by heretohelp on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:32AM (#4181014)
That would be because Amazon.com doesn't use AWS.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by revertts on Saturday June 30, 2012 @04:37AM (#4181119)
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by notmyhnname on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:57PM (#4182312)
While what you say was certainly true when AWS launched, today it is not. Much of Amazon is hosted in an EC2 VPC connected to the traditional prod network. This includes all of retail website and (today) many of the services that power said website.

Other AWS services are also used frequently and heavily. AWS use is strongly encouraged for any new projects.

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by zhoutong on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:35AM (#4181020)
No, it doesn't. Even the name servers of Amazon.com belong to UltraDNS and Dynect, instead of their own Route 53.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by sandfox on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:36AM (#4181381)
Route53 uses UltraDNS.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by zhoutong on Saturday June 30, 2012 @08:47AM (#4181480)
No it's wrong.

> "I also wanted to clarify that Route 53 is an Amazon-built and operated service. It is not a re-branding of a third party DNS service. Over time you'll see various parts of Amazon move over to use Route 53."

https://forums.aws.amazon.com/message.jspa?messageID=209251#...

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by heretohelp on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:45AM (#4181041)
I've always found the double-standard amusing :)
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by poppysan on Saturday June 30, 2012 @11:44AM (#4181900)
If you are hosting on a server(as everyone is) it will, at some point fail. You have to choose a service that has minimal failure combined with quick resolution times. I think AWS fits this description...
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by dangrossman on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:21PM (#4182558)
AWS has had far more failures than my servers at any data center ever have. Running in 'the cloud', you're taking all the unavoidable points of failure (power, network, hardware) and adding in a bunch of proprietary ones (all the software that manages EC2, EBS, ELBs, internal routing between them, etc) that have all failed spectacularly at least once already with hours- to days-long resolution times.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by ibejoeb on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:04PM (#4182956)
Yes, risk still exists, and risk profile shifts a little, but I find it to be a toward the better. Here's an anecdote:

I run applications on EC2 and RDS. I'm using Oracle. AWS has recently introduce Multi-AZ Oracle, but I haven't enabled yet. Before it was available, though, I set up a poor-man's procedure that consists of running data exports and dropping them on S3.

Now, when everything went to hell in the east, I lost an RDS instance. I couldn't do point-in-time restore, and I couldn't snapshot (both are still pending since 7 AM or so).

Luckily, I was able to spin up an RDS instance in the west, pull down the latest data from S3, and do an import. I repointed my apps at the new database, and now I'm back up.

The process took about 45 minutes. Setting up the backup scripts took about 20 minutes about 2 years ago. Now I'm just sitting on my hands waiting for the AWS ops team to fix everything. This is work I'd normally be scrambling to do myself. I'm quite happy to let those talented folks deal with it. When it's all back up and running, I'll check integrity and consistency, and I might have to restore some interim data, but for now I'm operational.

I'm sure there are worse scenarios, but the major outage last year and in the past 24-hours were quite easily mitigated.

There's something to be said for being part of a giant machine. AWS really is utility computing, so even the small guys get the benefit by virtue of standing next to the big guys.

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by cocoflunchy on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:46AM (#4181392)
Instagram is still down! However Netflix & Pinterest seem to be back.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by azarias on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:36PM (#4182599)
Google, MS, Rackspace etc. ought to give a good look at all the middle layer libraries like boto, and support them to make it a matter of configuration to switch cloud service providers.

This already works well for email providers.

Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by Nux on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:23AM (#4181189)
Here's to keeping all the eggs in one basket!
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by samuel1604 on Saturday June 30, 2012 @04:50AM (#4181141)
Just use rackspace already, they hardly have an outage.
Re:Amazon cloud outage takes down Netflix, Instagram, Pinter... by philip1209 on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:57AM (#4180847)
If Pinterest is down, then there may be a net gain for the internet.