Obviously it's true that people bust stereotypes every day. I'm in th same boat you were... Computer/math/video game/comics "nerd" who also was vp of the class, captain of the wrestling team, very popular, and accepted by every group.
Just because there are people who violate the stereotypes doesn't mean that my original observation doesn't hold any water.
That said; there are a lot of people out there and if you go looking for a stereotype you can often find it, or at least convince yourself that's what your seeing.
PS: Team sports can actually be a lot of fun.