Or put another way - if there were an investment opportunity that that had an 80% chance of 3x-4x returns in the next 2-3 years, I might consider investing 25% or even 50% of my net worth in that opportunity. But I certainly wouldn't invest 95% of my net worth.
But to an elected politician that might not even be in office in a few years, money now is worth more at any cost than money later.
A gov agency is best suited to ride these things out because their cost of capital is among the lowest. Generally dumb for a county to sell an asset to a hedge fund: the HF has to pay more in interest than a county does just to pay you money now. There's nothing to do here except wait, nothing to whip in shape and make more profitable.
(Also cities shouldn't own stadiums, that's a gamble on the success of your local sports team and solvency of whomever you sell the naming rights to)
Municipalities have a higher borrowing cost then the Treasury, though it's still relatively low.
By selling during bankruptcy they gambled that the "experts" were wrong and it turn out not to be the case.
That's why exchanges often suspend shares during bankruptcy: To make it clear that price manipulation and outright corruption is likely.
I have both a claim in FTX and shares in a suspended ("bankrupt") company listed outside the US. I just ride these things out because I don't need the money right now.
Your cited article makes it abundantly clear that the provenance of said $17 million claim was a default clause entitling Miami-Dade County to three years worth of naming-rights fees.
They sold that speculative claim for $5 million cash---effectively recovering that year's otherwise uncollectible receivables---then immediately turned around and locked in a 17-year, $117.4 million agreement with Kaseya[1]; back-of-the-envelope says that's an implied ~$5.4 million (2023 dollars) per year with 3% annual inflation adjustment baked in.
Call me naive, but I imagine that if you're in the business of running a multi-purpose arena with real opex, you've gotta be the dumbest risk manager in South Florida to allocate expensive legal resources in chase of speculative claims when a mutual opportunity to repair a gapping hole in your balance sheet presents itself and you have a willing long-term replacement suitor lined up.
[1] https://www.miamidade.gov/global/news-item.page?Mduid_news=n...
Usually when you have several suitors that purely have profit in mind, you're the mark. Doubly so when their cost of capital is higher than your own.
> to allocate expensive legal resources in chase of speculative claims
On a claim this big, the bankruptcy trustee takes care of that for you. They're literally a fiduciary. The cost would be reading whatever gets mailed to you, but at the end of the day, there isn't much control you have over the ultimate outcome.
And uhhh, in terms of credit worthiness, Kaseya has an interesting history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaseya_VSA_ransomware_attack .
They they sold the stake ultimately worth 17 million, but they got their rights back, which they resold for 16 million. As long as they sold their stake for 1 million or more, they are in the green.
(They won on the reselling of the naming rights too by leasing them out for more per year than ftx)
I find it weird that you condemn that decision based on perfect hindsight.
> Selling your claim is only a good deal if the hedge funds are drunkenly stupid, you have no other assets/lending sources and are going to die soon or have debt at payday loan rates.
Selling your claim reduces your exposure and eliminates the risk that you'd get even less after the bankruptcy process concludes. It also lets you book the loss now and move on. That's valuable to some people. Consider that people have different motivations and needs than you do.
> “I’ve never worked on a bankruptcy case that got better. It always gets worse,” said Commissioner Raquel Regalado, a lawyer who now works as a broadcaster. “The idea of just getting out as early as possible seems like a great idea to me. “
Those were some expensive words. And in general, always somewhat expensive words because the hedge fund buyers generally don't work "lose" into their models.
https://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/...
Selling your claim is only a good deal if the hedge funds are drunkenly stupid, you have no other assets/lending sources and are going to die soon or have debt at payday loan rates.