Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by elteto on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:57AM
(#4172287)
I am not very familiar with graphene but I would like to know how well it scales up from the molecular/nano scale to the macroscopic. I took a Material's Engineering class in college and I remember the professor saying that the "theoretical" strength of materials (in general) was supposed to be extremely high, orders of magnitude higher than what you find in real life. The disparity is a result of imperfections in the crystal lattices of the materials. You can probably build a graphene tube 50nm in length and find that at that scale it has all those superior properties, especially since at that size you are almost handling molecules individually and can arrange them correctly. But what happens when you go up in the scale? Will it retain all of those wonderful properties to the same extent?
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by tcpekin on Thursday June 28, 2012 @06:41PM
(#4174338)
Graphene is simply a single layer of carbon atoms. If you roll one up, voila, you have a carbon nanotube you've been hearing about for the past 10 years. Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have similar properties as graphene (act as a metal or a semiconductor, are the "strongest materials known, etc.[1]).
From what I understand, it is very difficult to make large sections of pure graphene or long CNTs. As long as they're pure, they remain strong, and therein lies the difficulty of graphene and CNT production. Like you said, the impurities do weaken CNTs and graphene. The impurities can be contaminants which occupy a carbon location, or missing carbon atoms, forcing the lattice to reconstruct. According to [1], this can lower the tensile strength of a carbon nanotube by up to 85%. The problem with manufacturing long CNTs and large areas of graphene is that it is thermodynamically impossible to, on a large scale, have a perfect lattice. The imperfections will weaken the entire structure. So yes, as you go up in scale, the incredible/fantastic properties will just become impressive.
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by ColinWright on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:14PM
(#4172383)
The Royal Institution of Great Britain. I've spoken in the Faraday Lecture Theatre, and will be doing so again tomorrow, Saturday, and next Friday. It's a fabulous place with an amazing history and ongoing present.
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by soofy on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:40AM
(#4172196)
That's BTW an old Russian idea. The key concept of the space elevator appeared in 1895 when Russian scientist Konstantin Tsiolkovsky was inspired by the Eiffel Tower in Paris to consider a tower that reached all the way into space, built from the ground up to an altitude of 35,790 kilometers (22,238 mi) above sea level (geostationary orbit).[6] He noted that a "celestial castle" at the top of such a spindle-shaped cable would have the "castle" orbiting Earth in a geostationary orbit (i.e. the castle would remain over the same spot on Earth's surface). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by nkoren on Thursday June 28, 2012 @02:02PM
(#4172975)
Well, yes, but with a liberal interpretation of the word "cruise", that would be 100% accurate. Indians were indeed the first to employ self-propelled artillery in a truly effective military capacity. Probably not in Vedic days, but certainly against the British: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mysorean_rockets.
It's interesting to note that much of the tradition of western rocketry is descended from captured and reverse-engineered Mysorean rockets. And most of the rest of the western tradition of rocketry is descended from half-crazed Russian mystics and Egyptian ceremonial magicians. But that's another story entirely...
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by Symmetry on Thursday June 28, 2012 @03:46PM
(#4173539)
Did you read the Wikipedia article they linked to? It was experience fighting against rockets in India that led the British to develop the Congrave Rocket, which was made famous in the "Rocket's Red Glare" line in the US National Anthem. Britain might have had military rockets at some point before that, but they hadn't used them for at least a century before that point.
India wasn't as backwards as you might suppose, there were lots of areas of technology they were very good at such as chemistry and metalurgy. After the Battle of Plassey, I believe, the British captures a number of Indian cannons and found that they were better than the guns that the British had. Of course, they all had different bores and it was too logistically difficult to keep that many different kinds of ammunition, so the British just destroyed them. Which, I think, goes a long way towards illustrating the actual reasons the British ended up ruling India.
So long as you don't require the tether to be stationary and to meet up with a stationary point on the ground, you can have a space elevator with materials we already have.
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by stcredzero on Thursday June 28, 2012 @05:49PM
(#4174147)
> That made no sense. How you can have a space elevator if it's not geo-stationary?
Apparently, you didn't read. The tether rendezvous is with a pod carried by a hypersonic spaceplane, not the ground. The tether can be spun, to make the ground speed of the tether-end even slower. Rendezvous slows down the spinning tether and lowers its orbit, but it can be boosted between rendezvous using very high ISP motors like ion thrusters, which dramatically lowers the amount of fuel to be lifted.
You didn't actually say what materials are strong enough for this (that we can actually produce without bankrupting whole countries).
Spectra and Kevlar have the required tensile strength for many proposed configurations. There is the added complication of dealing with ions, free radicals, and radiation, however.
Re:Graphene: The Wonder Substance
by stcredzero on Friday June 29, 2012 @11:47AM
(#4177193)
Apparently, you are pedantic with terminology. So call it a "Skyhook" and read the HASTOL links. Kevlar is strong enough for some configurations, but none we'd be anxious to use.
From what I understand, it is very difficult to make large sections of pure graphene or long CNTs. As long as they're pure, they remain strong, and therein lies the difficulty of graphene and CNT production. Like you said, the impurities do weaken CNTs and graphene. The impurities can be contaminants which occupy a carbon location, or missing carbon atoms, forcing the lattice to reconstruct. According to [1], this can lower the tensile strength of a carbon nanotube by up to 85%. The problem with manufacturing long CNTs and large areas of graphene is that it is thermodynamically impossible to, on a large scale, have a perfect lattice. The imperfections will weaken the entire structure. So yes, as you go up in scale, the incredible/fantastic properties will just become impressive.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_nanotube
*I currently study materials science and can produce literature upon request. Also this is from the top of my head so it may contain some errors.
It's interesting to note that much of the tradition of western rocketry is descended from captured and reverse-engineered Mysorean rockets. And most of the rest of the western tradition of rocketry is descended from half-crazed Russian mystics and Egyptian ceremonial magicians. But that's another story entirely...
I find it hard to believe. Any references?
India wasn't as backwards as you might suppose, there were lots of areas of technology they were very good at such as chemistry and metalurgy. After the Battle of Plassey, I believe, the British captures a number of Indian cannons and found that they were better than the guns that the British had. Of course, they all had different bores and it was too logistically difficult to keep that many different kinds of ammunition, so the British just destroyed them. Which, I think, goes a long way towards illustrating the actual reasons the British ended up ruling India.
http://duckduckgo.com/?q=hastol+tether
So long as you don't require the tether to be stationary and to meet up with a stationary point on the ground, you can have a space elevator with materials we already have.
You didn't actually say what materials are strong enough for this (that we can actually produce without bankrupting whole countries).
Apparently, you didn't read. The tether rendezvous is with a pod carried by a hypersonic spaceplane, not the ground. The tether can be spun, to make the ground speed of the tether-end even slower. Rendezvous slows down the spinning tether and lowers its orbit, but it can be boosted between rendezvous using very high ISP motors like ion thrusters, which dramatically lowers the amount of fuel to be lifted.
You didn't actually say what materials are strong enough for this (that we can actually produce without bankrupting whole countries).
Spectra and Kevlar have the required tensile strength for many proposed configurations. There is the added complication of dealing with ions, free radicals, and radiation, however.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator#Cable
http://www.toast-clothes.com/