News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by mrich on Thursday June 28, 2012 @09:37AM (#4171616)
This quote from the article describes the business model of many financial firms quite well:

"Essentially, JPMorgan has been operating a hedge fund with federal insured deposits within a bank," said Mark Williams, a professor of finance at Boston University, who also served as a Federal Reserve bank examiner.

Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by BigTuna on Thursday June 28, 2012 @09:57AM (#4171685)
Yep. You can either be a bank backed by the full faith and credit of the United States, or you can be a casino. You can't be both. Or at least that's how it would work in a world where the banks don't own Congress.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by roc on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:02AM (#4171989)
And even the casino analogy is largely unfair to casinos.

They don't get to bet against their clients, lie about returns, or collude with other casinos.

And that's even if we grant the rumors and whispers as true; that the casinos might have the gaming commission in their pocket the way Wall Street owns the ratings agencies, and that they may well get the same sweetheart penalty deals when busted, as Wall Street does with the SEC.

But even there, what casinos may be doing can't compare to what Wall Street does -- not even as open secrets, but on the public record.

Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by sopooneo on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:12AM (#4172028)
I'm with you here, but isn't betting against their clients exactly what casinos do?
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by TylerE on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:15AM (#4172045)
No, casinos take bets, they don't make them. Important distinction. They don't initiate anything.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by cluda01 on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:47AM (#4172240)
Would saying that the casinos play the role of market maker be appropriate?
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by roc on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:09PM (#4172362)
Close enough.

The market maker knows the odds and is incentivized to be honest with the customer, to keep their trust and get as many people to play as possible as it 'wins' only in the aggregate as more and more people play. [1]

But the point is that there isn't another, let's call it 'evil', branch of the casino, separate from the market maker. Where this 'evil' branch can bet against each gambler.

So now, instead of making 2% off a gambler, you can now make massive sums betting against any gambler you lure into horrible odds.

So the incentives have been thrown out of balance. Pulling in astute gamblers and making 2% becomes an inefficient strategy. Reeling in unsophisticated gamblers, luring them into games with terrible odds and then betting against them, becomes an optimal strategy.

And down that road, almost inevitably, comes distortion and outright fraud.

[1] Slot machines only earn something like 2% for the casino. It's more in their interest to be very transparent about those odds and get more people to play, than to be shady and try to squeeze out 3%. Because you'll lose more gamblers than you can get with a 'tighter' slot.

EDIT: to be clear, I only used 'evil' because the 'gambling against' branch was housed with and colluding with the market maker in this example. I have no problem with the analogous financial services. The argument is simply that you can't do both. It's bad for the market as a whole.

Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by jerf on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:05PM (#4172339)
I don't see how trying to slot casinos into the market model would help understand them any better than simply understanding them as casinos. There isn't much of a liquid market of betting in a casino. Compare with Wall Street and its endless array of derivatives and hedges and mutual funds and all that stuff to... $25 on red. Wall Street may have elements of betting, but it's also a lot more. Casinos are much simpler.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by TylerE on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:10PM (#4172675)
There actually is. If you read the sites for serious gamblers, they pay lots of attention to the exact rules in place, especially for blackjack. It's defiantly not a commoditized industry.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by jerf on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:23PM (#4172750)
There actually is... what? Variations in local rules do not a market make. Where's the arbitrage between the difference in local rules?
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by TylerE on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:53PM (#4172915)
The gamblers visit the places with the best rules. If you're playing blackjack at $500 a hand, playing against a 1.1% house edge instead of a 1.2% house edge matters.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by retube on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:03PM (#4172324)
they're still betting against their customers. and not only that the odds are hard-coded stacked against the customer.
Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by krschultz on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:27PM (#4172441)
Not really. A casino could hire a bunch of professional/expert poker players, put them in the poker room, and have them literally play against the novice/intermediate guys. They would make a lot of money. But that's illegal.

On same games the casino just rake a bit off the top - basically a cover charge. Others the casino profits off you - but the odds are known.

Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by cynicalkane on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:35PM (#4172818)
A casino could hire a bunch of professional/expert poker players, put them in the poker room, and have them literally play against the novice/intermediate guys

This is actually done, and fairly common. Usually, casnios pay small-time pros a flat rate to seed poker tables, and don't take a stake in their wins or losses, but the point is casinos do hire pros to play against customers.

Re:JPMorgan Trading Loss May Reach $9 Billion by sseveran on Thursday June 28, 2012 @02:52PM (#4173281)
Not exactly. Hedges can blow up just like any other trade. There is a very gray line between hedging legitimate risks, i.e. moves in interest rates, and speculation that the interest rate will rise. In this case here they were trying to become more risk neutral to comply with coming regulations from Basel III.