Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by adduc on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:12PM
(#41710366)
Are you certain extensions can be downloaded and installed from anywhere? Firefox's documentation[1] states "Extensions and themes need to be signed by Mozilla before they can be installed in release and beta versions of Firefox." If UBlock Lite was rejected through Mozilla's signing API, they'd have no ability to create an XPI that can be installed by release/beta version of Firefox.
[1]: https://extensionworkshop.com/documentation/publish/signing-...
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by Semaphor on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:11PM
(#41710353)
No, the normal version blocks (at least permanent) installs. You need the developer version to install unsigned extensions.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by Zak on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:31PM
(#41710667)
I see. The extension I installed to test that actually is signed, though it's not in AMO.
I don't like this. I know there have been issues with malicious extensions, so it makes sense to me that installing unsigned extensions is turned off by default, but requiring developer builds is a step too far.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by pxc on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @01:30PM
(#41711504)
What release made this change effective?
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by Semaphor on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @01:59PM
(#41711866)
That was many years ago, there was a bit of a public complaint.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by sunaookami on Wednesday October 02, 2024 @12:09AM
(#41717068)
Correct. It's incredibly how much misinformation there is about signing, even here where people should know better. It's very tiresome.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by bytebolt on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @12:32PM
(#41710692)
You can no longer package extensions yourself and if you try using "Load add on from file" you get that extension loaded but it's gone after a restart. All extensions have to be signed first to be permanent and Mozilla denied to fix that on their bug tracker.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by burnte on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @01:03PM
(#41711142)
Signing is such a low bar to pass I agree that not offering that as an option is reasonable. It takes seconds to do.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by Zak on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @06:28PM
(#41714949)
We're talking about signing by Mozilla to indicate the extension has passed some sort of review process, not signing by the author. It isn't a low bar because it gives Mozilla veto power over what extensions users can install.
Re:Mozilla's lapse in judgement causes clash with uBlock Ori...
by Arnavion on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @01:50PM
(#41711772)
To add on to the other replies, you *can* load unsigned extensions with desktop Firefox if the build you're using disabled the signing requirement at build time. A bunch of distros' FF packages do that, for example, and is why I use a bunch of extensions I wrote myself (and thus trust) for myself without having to deal with Mozilla. (Zip up the files, change the file extension to `.xpi`, drop it in `$libdir/firefox/browser/extensions/`)
I think mobile requires using a nightly build to install extensions from outside Mozilla's repository, and that suggests their thinking is becoming contaminated by the rest of the mobile ecosystem.