Ask HN: Is this Symfony PHP project garbage?
I am working on a new codebase as a frontend developer and the backend is in Symfony PHP. I haven't worked with Symfony before but this project seems to be poorly maintained. Help me get a grasp of whether or not this is normal or total garbage.
They are using really outdated dependencies. Symfony itself is in 5.4 and they have 368 deprecations and some critical vulnerabilities. The project is 10+ years old and there are no software tests at all. Everything is manually tested.
And I did a PHPStorm Error Inspection and it found 650+ Errors, 1,4k warnings and 140k+ weak warnings. 520 Errors are because of "Undefined symbols" though
The project seems to be poorly maintained to me and there are runtime errors and downtimes but the backend team always accuses the hosting service for the downtimes.
is this normal or not, that is the question
(
10 comments
| on HN
)
Not saying normal isn't dysfunctional--no tests at all is a little insane. At the same time, it enabled the business.
With better tooling now, of course some issues are more obvious. Maybe the codebase has its own patterns or way of doing things; some fixes might be more risky than others.
Add automation around linting, running the test suite, and build & deployment. A lot of it can go in dark, in case there's concern about blocking urgent things. Lay down a skeletal pipeline.
Create a couple template projects, for front- and backend, so future work can start at the highest quality bar.
Partner with QA to collect and document test scenarios. On the frontend, at least you'll be able to mock or stub the backend.
Eventually, you'll want this system to block merges and deployments based on agreed-upon criteria. Exceptions can be made, so long as it's documented.
Now you can feel somewhat safe to add tests. Otherwise, the tests will break, no one will update them, and it won't mean much.
Add mutation testing too.
you can still use 5.4 up until 2026, but you need to update your packages
https://symfony.com/releases
this will show you how to upgrade: https://symfony.com/doc/6.4/setup/unstable_versions.html
The engineering question is "Is Symfony good enough?" There are money and staffing and personalities that go into the answer. For example insuring against security problems might easily be cheaper than the costs and risks of pursuing alternatives.
The ability to work in such contexts is why senior staff are senior staff. Good luck.