News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by rprasad on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @01:41PM (#4168081)
I agree. this story plays out exactly like every teenage coder's wet dream. It's got everything: persecution, vindication, crap boss who for some reason gets fired for firing the teenager (in the real world, firing someone who refused to turn over company property is not a reason to get fired), teenager saves everyone else's jobs, and even gets a promotion to a much better job.

This kid apparently also has insane negotiation skills, and somehow managed to negotiate his own salary increase and salary increases for everyone else around him.

All this, in a month...

We'll probably see an update in the next day or two that this story was a hoax.

UPDATE: More evidence of a hoax: the kid was making more money in an entry-level data-entry position than a manager-level employee in the company. And that entry-level data-entry position paid substantial bonsuses (which is the alleged reason the kid was making more than his manager.) And on top of all that, the boss was not eligible for bonuses bases on the productivity of his supervisees. Finally, the kid is now apparently the lead programmer in his own frigging department but somehow does not have the authority to change his desk chair. Yeah, that's all completely believable.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by shalmanese on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @08:28PM (#4169907)
> Finally, the kid is now apparently the lead programmer in his own frigging department but somehow does not have the authority to change his desk chair.

Sadly, this is probably the most believable part of the entire story :(.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by zheng on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:03AM (#4170333)
Not really. I'm the most junior person in my department and I can get a new chair if I want one. Big company too.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by cookiecaper on Thursday June 28, 2012 @02:28AM (#4170543)
This is actually more likely in a big company. Money means little to big companies; unless they screw up in a very serious way, the money available for individual trinkets like desk chairs is almost unlimited. In a small company, an extra Aeron can put you in the red.

Also, if money belongs to a faceless entity and does not directly effect the individuals that hold the purse strings, people tend to be much more loose with the cash. This is a big reason why B2B is almost always a much better course than B2C. In a small company, there's still a founder who considers overall income vital to his sustenance, and as such is much stingier than a big corp.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by kenrikm on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @03:26PM (#4168760)
I guess you have not worked at a company where these types of things can and do happen? It's a plausible story in my book since I had something similar happen early in my career. My boss hated me and another new hire (fear) and kept telling the VP that were were "not working and slow" well without letting my manager know the VP started logging all of the work and found that in a given week I produced 40% of the work, the other new hire produced 30% and the other three people on the team produced 10% each (including my manager) She was fired and I was given her position after being with the company for only a few months.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by ceol on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @04:01PM (#4168947)
That isn't the same at all.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by kenrikm on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @05:20PM (#4169300)
Boss, wanted to fire, Boss got fired, got Boss position. Similar plot line IMO.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by kd0amg on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:04PM (#4169448)
Similar to "entry-level data entry job that pays more than the management job above it"?
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by sangaya on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @09:09PM (#4169994)
We're making wild guesses about the pay scales there. I've worked at places where employees make 30,000 and the boss makes 35,000.

Also, the bonus system sounds like it was based heavily on quantity, where it is believable that one automated system could substantially out-perform the sum of the other employees. In a system designed to split a bonus more normally (say 10% for 10 employees) it's not hard to imagine that in the scenario described it could have gone 90% for 1, and 10% split among 9.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by rprasad on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @09:22PM (#4170021)
According to reddit commenters, the reddit poster was making 6 figures (in Euros) for a data entry job (another HN commenter put this number at 250,000, but I couldn't find anything on reddit to support that). The manager was apparently only making 5 figures.

I'm willing to believe that managers can make less than their underlings (for example, project managers can make less than programmers depending on experience, sales managers can make less than salesmen once commissions are factored in) but I am not willing to believe that an entry-level data entry position pays 6 figures. Especially not in the Netherlands.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by radicalbyte on Thursday June 28, 2012 @02:35AM (#4170558)
250k is more than the entire department cost.

If data entry was that expensive then they'd have outsourced it to Poland pretty quickly. Or have invested in one of the many document scanning and OCR companies.

I've worked in The Netherlands for 6 years now (5 as consultant in this area), and am pretty sure that this story is bullshit. I've seen nothing like it.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by coopdog on Thursday June 28, 2012 @05:00AM (#4170828)
I agree that level of bonus for data entry smells funny.

Although, the one exception could be some kind of government or hospital data where it cannot be exported out of the country, and therefore the only option is to pay local wages. Even then though, the bonus does sound bogus

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by radicalbyte on Thursday June 28, 2012 @11:07AM (#4172009)
There's another issue.

Here in The Netherlands, it's very hard to sack people. For that reason you don't see the kind of salaries that you do in the US. An employer has less insentive to offer massive salaries, because with the massive salary comes an even bigger liability.

There's no way he's earning 250k a year in a data entry position. Or even as a developer.

Additionally, I've read nothing on the biggest dutch-language IT/Developers community. I can't believe that someone would boast about this on reddit and not on tweakers :)

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by ehutch79 on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @10:56PM (#4170199)
that wasn't his base pay, it's his base pay + 90% of the bonus pool for the department.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by bowyakka on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:04PM (#4182502)
I still find that odd, perhaps I should quit my current job and do exactly what he does? after all automating data entry has to be a lot simpler than most programming jobs.

Lets play with the maths of this, lets say that he is generously making 40 euros, which is a lot for data entry (think like double what specialist data entry people are normally paid)

That leaves us with a bonus pool of 2100000, the claim is that he was taking 90% of the bonus, that would make the bonus pool 233333, lets round up to 250000

Ok so lets split this evenly across several employees

5 clerks = 50,000 bonus each on a base salary of 40,000 = 90,000 each !

10 clerks = 25,000 bonus each on a base salary of 40,000 = 65,000 each !

20 clerks = 12,500 bonus each on a base salary of 40,000 = 52,500 each !

Thats a stunning salary ! really, I would be motivated myself to get my bonus, even if I was only taking my _equal_ share of the magic pot.

Ok lets assume that his department is huge say ....

50 clerks = 5,000 bonus each on a base salary of 40,000 = 45,000 each

Sounds reasonable right? but the 50 clerks would be costing the company 2000000 Euros ! At that cost even the most stupid of organisations would be looking at automation (human via india or say the meat-cloud), or computers)

Now you might say that 40K is generous for the type of work, that he would really be earning something like 25K, still a lot for data entry which is a low skilled job that is typically hourly paid; a fine argument but if that is the case then the bonus pool becomes larger which still makes all the numbers look suspect.

Maybe he got a raise (and didn't really declare it, for some reason), even then that is somewhat higher than a basic internet search gives me for someone in Holland as a programmer (http://www.payscale.com/research/NL/Country=Netherlands/Sala...). Now the company he works for might be clueless, but I would be surprised if they did not do a wage equivalence as most companies are low that way.

So colour me extremely skeptical, the _only_ way it makes sense is if he misplaced a zero

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by Goladus on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @01:52PM (#4168126)
Upper-level bosses probably never had any intention of firing all the workers just because some script automated a portion of their work. If it's a large-scale, decisions like that probably wouldn't be made without considering MPL abstractly or without considering the costs and bad PR incurred when laying off a significant number of people. That part of the narrative was likely more significant in the kid's mind than reality.

And apparently, the sub-boss was already on thin ice. This may have just been the final excuse needed to get rid of him.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by mst on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @02:30PM (#4168381)
Also, much empire building happens by headcount; if the work's all still getting done, better to retain the headcount than to faff around with redundancies.

I got my first real programming job because I automated dumb work and my then-boss handed me a bunch of extra unautomatable administration work; I went and explained this to his ex-boss at the company he'd left and started competing with, and said ex-boss figured anybody the idiot wanted to shit on was worth a try.

Now, in this case we're talking about two people still within the reporting chain, but if $redditor->boss->boss hated $redditor->boss as much as my first programming boss hated the previous boss, and $redditor->boss->boss managed to look good screwing him ... then it seems entirely plausible.

I still feel like it doesn't smell quite right, but it is to my mind way more plausible than people are giving it credit for.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by wisty on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:35AM (#4170370)
Also, I'd guess that when all his employees were re-assigned, there wasn't much point in keeping him on.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by simonbrown on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:10PM (#4172370)
The post states that one of his coworkers was promoted to the role.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by onedev on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @11:32PM (#4170274)
Regarding your update, I'm pretty sure that he was making more money at the entry-level data-entry position than his manager because he was ALSO getting 99% of the bonus pool.

So Bonus Pool + Base Salary > Manager's Salary

Which is more believable.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by smallegan on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @01:44PM (#4168094)
I was under the impression the boss had fired him and then asked for the password.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by pcrh on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @03:26PM (#4168759)
In the Netherlands he wouldn't be let go immediately, there would be a variable legally-required period of time before he is shown the door, during that time he is still technically employed by the company. I suspect that it is during this period that he spoke to the senior manager.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by rprasad on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @02:05PM (#4168227)
That would be standard operating procedure. The kid's program (if it really exists) would be company property, and his failure to turn over the password could result in civil litigation (or potentially, but unlikely) criminal prosecution.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by tijs on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @02:28PM (#4168368)
Luckily all of this happened, i think i believe it did, in The Netherlands where litigation over this sort of thing is just not very common. Especially in smaller companies as this one seems to be.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @03:27PM (#4168771)
A password is not property. The company holds the copyright to the software, but the employee has no obligation to have made the software usable for any purpose. (No more than a cabinetmaker who creates an innovative jig is reqyired to write a manual or provide training.)
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by Confusion on Thursday June 28, 2012 @12:43PM (#4172529)
You're wrong. Anything you produce in company time that is even remotely jon related, is company property. The code, the binary, the password and any intellectual property rights protecting them is the company's property. Every contract clearly arranges that, so you can't extort your former boss, as in the story. If your contract doesn't contain such clauses, your company is incompetent.
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by Daniel_Newby on Thursday June 28, 2012 @01:30PM (#4172796)
Property is tangible. The computer that stores the software is property, the software is merely a configuration of the property. Certain monopoly privileges regarding that configuration (copyright) might be assigned to the company depending on the details of the contract and local laws.

Providing a password is an activity. Whether the employee has a duty to perform that activity depends on the contract and circumstances. In this case, the employee was not assigned the task of writing down the password, so failing to write down the password was not a breach of duty. His boss attempted to negotiate a new employment arrangement involving writing down the password, and negotiations fell through.

Extortion is the threat to perform an unlawful act unless demands are met. This case was not extortion because the employee did not perform any act, let alone an unlawful one.

Put simply, if an employee goes beyond the call of duty, the employer cannot compel them to continue going beyond the call of duty. All the employer can do is fire them.

Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by esrauch on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:16PM (#4182176)
By setting the password and not providing it is denying the company access to their own property and is likely to be criminal in most states. For example http://www.networkworld.com/slideshows/2008/071708-report-it...
Re:Kid Automates Work, Is Fired, Hired Back, Automates Business by qq66 on Wednesday June 27, 2012 @06:23PM (#4169501)
I can't really speculate on whether the story is true or not. At least some parts of his story are similar to my own, which I posted on the original Reddit thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/tenoq/reddit_my_f...